DraftWritten with AI help from the sources it cites, and not yet read by a human editor.
At a glance
- Era
- The Umayyad Period · The Early Abbasid Caliphate · Abbasid Fragmentation · The Buyid, Fatimid and Seljuk Era · The Crusades, Ayyubids and Mamluks · The Gunpowder Empires · The Modern Era · The Contemporary Era
- Region
- Levant & Iraq · Persia & Central Asia · Egypt & Nile · Maghreb · al-Andalus & Europe · Anatolia · South Asia · Arabia · Global / Diaspora
Summary
The mutakallim practises kalam, the discipline that takes Islam's first principles as its subject: establishing the creeds with decisive proofs and demolishing counter-arguments by rational method 1. Al-Farabi defined it as a debative faculty that confirms the beliefs and acts laid down by the religion's founder and shows the falsity of whatever contradicts them; al-Iji described it as the science that gives the power to prove religious beliefs with certain evidences 1.
What the science is for
Kalam answers criticisms directed at the whole religion: the entry's own synthesis defines it as the science that determines Islam's principles for belief and conduct from the texts and grounds them by rational methods, noting that its task is not defence alone but proving the truth of the principles, drawing where relevant on the social and natural sciences 1. Taşköprizade gave it two conditions: that the principles be present in the Qur'an and sound Sunna, and that they be confirmed by rational method 1. The discipline was also known as tawhid, usul al-din, al-fiqh al-akbar, aqa'id and the science of nazar and istidlal 1.
The first mutakallimun
The entry credits Jahm ibn Safwan as the first scholar to use the kalam method, putting reason before the texts and preparing the ground for the Mu'tazila 1. At Basra, al-Hasan al-Basri's student Wasil ibn Ata launched the Mu'tazila about 100-120 AH (718-738) by holding the grave sinner to stand between belief and unbelief, and he is credited with the first kalam book 1. The Mu'tazila then grew through Amr ibn Ubayd, Abu al-Hudhayl al-Allaf, al-Nazzam, al-Jahiz and the Jubba'is into a major school, splitting into Basran and Baghdadi wings whose scholars differed in detail but united on interpreting the texts in the light of reason 1.
The Sunni masters
As the schools formed, conservative scholars — mostly hadith men — reacted against the kalam enterprise itself, and the emergent Sunni mainstream divided between the Salafiyya, who refused rational instruments altogether, and the Sunni kalam school of the Ash'ariyya and Maturidiyya 1. Abu al-Hasan al-Ash'ari, who had taken kalam lessons from the Mu'tazili Abu Ali al-Jubba'i and defended Mu'tazilism until the age of forty, left the school declaring its views contrary to both text and reason, and founded the Ash'ari line in the Middle East 1. Abu Mansur al-Maturidi, of Abu Hanifa's scholarly tradition, founded the second Sunni school in Transoxiana, perhaps earlier still; joined to the Hanafi legal school it came to hold the Muslim majority by itself 1.
Mutakaddimun and muta'akhkhirun
The early period of the mutakallimun closed with al-Ghazali among the Ash'aris and Abu al-Mu'in al-Nasafi among the Maturidis; its characteristic was an Islamic rationalism rooted in the Qur'an, working with instruments like the analogy of the seen to the unseen, sebr ve taksim and the validation of proofs, rather than a philosophical metaphysics 1. Al-Ghazali opened the later period by bringing classical logic into the religious sciences and reconciling kalam with tasawwuf; after him, in the works of Fakhr al-Din al-Razi, al-Amidi and Qadi Baydawi, philosophical topics came to occupy more space than kalam questions proper 1. From al-Iji onward the sharh and hashiya tradition began, reaching its peak with al-Taftazani, al-Jurjani and al-Dawwani, which the entry marks as the science's period of stagnation 1.
The new ilm-i kelam
In the nineteenth century, translations and books by Western-educated intellectuals carried materialist, evolutionist, positivist and Freudian criticisms into the Islamic world, and the classical science's proofs proved insufficient against them 1. Nearly all the scholars of the age felt the need for a rebuilt kalam: the 'new ilm-i kelam' associated with İzmirli İsmail Hakkı, Elmalılı Hamdi, Muhammad Abduh, Sayyid Ahmad Khan, Shibli Nu'mani and Muhammad Iqbal reopened the gate of ijtihad, partly set aside school partisanship and took up the old questions afresh, weighing God's existence by the argument from purpose and order and answering each new critique in turn 1.
References
- Yusuf Şevki Yavuz, 'KELÂM', TDV İslâm Ansiklopedisi (2022), web edition 1.
Held by
Undated
- Abd al-Halim Mahmud Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave
- Abd al-Hayy al-Lakhnawi Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 40
- Abd al-Jabbar al-Hamadhani Main post merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 42
- Abd al-Qadir dan Tafa Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave
- Abd al-Qahir al-Jurjani Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 41
- Abdul-Hussein Dastghaib Main post merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 43
- Abdul-Majid al-Khoei Main post merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 43
- Abdullah Musawi Shirazi Main post merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 43
- Abu Abd Allah ibn Mujahid al-Ta'i Main post merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 41
- Abu al-Fadl Abd al-Wahid ibn Abd al-Aziz al-Tamimi al-Hanbali Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 40
- Abu al-Hasan al-Ash'ari Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 32
- Abu al-Qasim al-Lalaka'i Hibat Allah ibn al-Hasan Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave
- Abu al-Qasim al-Qushayri Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave
- Abu Haritha ibn Alqama Main post merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 42
- Abu Hatim Yaqub b. Labid al-Mazuzi al-Nafusi Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 44
- Abu Isa al-Isfahani Main post merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 41
- Abu Ja'far al-Tahawi Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 34
- Abu l-Khattab Abd al-A'la b. al-Samh al-Ma'afiri Main post merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave
- Abu l-Khattab Muhammad b. Abi Zaynab Miqlas al-Asadi Main post merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 40
- Abu Mansur al-Maturidi Main post merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 40
- Abu Mansur Ilyas al-Nafusi Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 44
- Abu Nasr ibn al-Qushayri Main post merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 41
- Abu Rashid al-Nisaburi Main post merge-map link from role 'mutakallim', Job Browser linking wave 42
- Abu Ya'qub Ishaq al-Sijzi Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 38
- Adud al-Din al-Iji Main post merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 30
- al-Allama al-Hilli Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave
- al-Ayki, Shams al-Din Main post merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 40
- al-Babarti Akmal al-Din Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 42
- al-Baghdadi Abu Mansur Abd al-Qahir ibn Tahir Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave
- Al-Bajuri, Ibrahim ibn Muhammad Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 42
- al-Bukhari, Ala al-Din Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 42
- al-Fadl ibn Shadhan Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 42
- Al-Husayn ibn 'Ali al-Jall Main post merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 41
- al-Iji Adud al-Din Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 41
- Al-Isfara'ini, Abu Ishaq Ibrahim ibn Muhammad Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 39
- al-Jubba'i Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 35
- al-Khayali Ahmad ibn Musa Shams al-Din Main post merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 41
- al-Shahrastani Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 35
- al-Sharif al-Murtada Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 35
- al-Shaykh al-Tusi Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 29
- Al-Zamakhshari Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 34
- Ali Suavi Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 39
- Amina Wadud Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave
- Bayan ibn Saman al-Tamimi Main post merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 43
- Fayz Kashani Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave
- Fazl-e-Haq Khairabadi Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave
- Galimjan Barudi Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 39
- Gregory Palamas Main post merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 41
- Hacı Pasha Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 43
- Hisham ibn al-Hakam Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 36
- Husam al-Din al-Abiwardi Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 42
- Husein Đozo Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 39
- Ibn Abi al-Izz al-Hanafi Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 40
- Ibn al-Bitriq al-Hilli Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 38
- Ibn al-Malahimi Main post merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 43
- Ibn Batta al-Ukbari, Ubayd Allah ibn Muhammad Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 23
- Ibn Jirjis Main post merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 42
- Ibn Kamal Pasha Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 39
- Ibn Qudama al-Maqdisi Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 31
- Ibn Taymiyya Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 30
- Ilkiya al-Harrasi, Ali ibn Muhammad Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 42
- Imam al-Haramayn al-Juwayni Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 30
- Israr Ahmed Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 39
- Jahm ibn Safwan Main post merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 43
- Jalal al-Din al-Hilli al-Taftazani Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 39
- Jamal al-Din Khwansari Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 30
- John of Damascus Main post merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 41
- Kaddour Benghabrit Main post merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave
- Kamal al-Din Ibn Yunus Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 31
- Maimonides (Ibn Maymun) Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 29
- Maytham al-Bahrani Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 41
- Moslem Malakouti Main post merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 43
- Muhammad al-Tahir ibn Ashur Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 39
- Muhammad ibn Falah Main post merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 43
- Muhammad Ilyas Ghumman Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave
- Muhammad Taqi Amoli Main post merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 43
- Mulla Sadra Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 33
- Musa Bigiev Main post merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 29
- Najmuddin Hotsinsky Main post merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 39
- Nasim al-Din al-Tabrizi Main post merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 42
- Nihat Hatipoğlu Main post merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 40
- Nur al-Din al-Sabuni Main post merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 42
- Nuriddin Khaliqnazar Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 39
- Qadi Abd al-Jabbar Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 29
- Said Nursi Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 40
- Serigne Fallou Mbacké Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 39
- Seyed Hossein Nasr Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave
- Seyhizade Main post merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 43
- Shah Abd al-Aziz al-Dihlawi Main post merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 41
- Shams al-Din al-Asfahani Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 40
- Shams al-Din al-Khasruwshahi Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 40
- Sharif abu Jafar Main post merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 42
- Shaykh Ahmad al-Ahsa'i (founder of the Shaykhi school, 1753–1826) Main post merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 40
- Shaykh Ahmad Sirhindi (Mujaddid-i Alf-i Thani) Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 40
- Sidi Boushaki Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 39
- Sinan Efendi Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 43
- Sir Sayyid Ahmad Khan (educational reformer, 1817–1898) Main post merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 40
- Táhirih (Qurrat al-Ayn) Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 43
- Usman dan Fodio Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave
- Yahya ibn Adi Also held merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 30
- Yahya ibn Ali al-Munajjim Main post merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 42
- Yousef Madani Tabrizi Main post merge-map link from role 'theologian', Job Browser linking wave 43
References
- KELÂM (Islamic theology) — TDV İslâm Ansiklopedisi (Yavuz)
Cite this page
islam.museum contributors. “Mutakallim (kalam theologian)”. islam.museum, https://islam.museum/en/job/mutakallim/. CC BY-SA 4.0. Last updated 2026-11-16.
Improve this page on GitHub · Report an error · Help complete it · JSON