BinBaz.org.sa 22 fatwas
The museum records these fatwas as history, attributed to those who issued them; it issues no ruling and advises no one.
- Acting on a weak hadith
A short question on acting upon a weak hadith. Ibn Baz answered that "weak" covers several grades: a report that is hasan with a good chain is acted upon, while a severely weak one is not, giving as examples of severe weakness a liar in the chain, a narrator of very poor memory, or a break in the chain.
- Saying 'by the blessing of so-and-so' or 'by the blessing of the Qur'an' in supplication
A question about the ruling on saying in supplication 'O God, grant me this matter by the blessing of so-and-so, or by the blessing of the Qur'an', in which Ibn Baz answered that if so-and-so had a part in bringing the matter about, or could have had one, there is no harm, as in 'O God, ease my affair by the blessing of so-and-so' or 'O God, settle my debt through so-and-so', meaning through his agency; but where the person had no part in it, the statement is a falsehood. He said that saying 'O God, forgive me by my reading of the Qur'an, my knowledge of it, my recitation of it or my memorisation of it' does no harm, because the Qur'an is God's speech, so this is seeking a means through God's speech.
- Bathing and ablution in standing ponds
A questioner from the countryside describes a pond whose water stands for months, in which people bathe from major impurity and some make ablution. Ibn Baz answered that a wide pond with plentiful water stays pure so long as no impurity has changed its taste, colour or smell, but he ruled out bathing in it from major impurity, urinating in it or cleaning oneself in it, citing the prohibition on bathing in standing water, and advised drawing the water out and purifying oneself outside the pond so as not to foul it for others.
- Burying the dead in a coffin inside the grave
A question about placing the dead in a coffin when necessary, as for a drowned person or one whose body has begun to decay, and whether he is buried in the grave together with the coffin; Shaykh Ibn Baz answered that a drowned person carried from one country to another is placed in the grave without harm, that if taking the body out of the coffin is feared to harm people it stays in it and is not taken out, while if it does no harm the body is taken out and laid in the niche of the grave; but if taking it out would hurt people and its smell would distress them, it is buried in the coffin and that suffices. He closed with a prayer for success and for soundness of intention and action.
- Donating to non-Muslim children in need
A reader's objection to an earlier fatwa by Ibn Baz in the magazine al-Da'wa permitting donations to the children of the world whatever their nationality or religion, provided their state is not hostile; the questioner argued that such donations harm Islam because there is no guarantee the money reaches the children and because it relieves non-Muslim states that are hostile to Muslims. Ibn Baz answered that what was meant is the weak who are shown kindness, such as children gathered up from the aftermath of wars, when a trustworthy party handles the aid, to rescue children who bear no guilt and who are not the children of those at war with Muslims but of people under safe conduct, treaty or truce. He argued that the Prophet permitted giving to non-Muslims who were not combatants and allowed Asma bint Abi Bakr to give to her non-Muslim mother from her wealth, and cited the verse of al-Mumtahana that God does not forbid kindness to those who have not fought the Muslims. He said that the weak among children, women and others, even if they are polytheists, when they are under safe conduct or treaty or are weak refugees, may be shown kindness without objection, but that the weak among Muslims have the greater claim; if there is enough for both, there is no harm.
- Washing and praying over one who took his own life
A question on washing and praying over a person who took his own life, in which Ibn Baz answered that he is washed, prayed over and buried among the Muslims. Ibn Baz answered that he is washed, shrouded, prayed over and buried among the Muslims, because killing oneself is a sin, not unbelief. He held that it is good for the ruler, the judge, the governor of the town or others of standing to refrain from leading his funeral prayer, as a public disavowal of the act, so that no one thinks they approve of it. He said that other Muslims still pray over him.
- Does the reward of Qur'an recitation reach the dead?
A question on gifting the reward of Qur'an recitation to the dead, in which Ibn Baz set out the disagreement and held that it is better left, in favour of charity and supplication. Ibn Baz said the question is disputed: most scholars hold that the reward arrives, while others say neither the Prophet nor the Companions are reported to have done it. He held that it is better to leave it, with each person reciting for himself, and that charity on behalf of the dead and supplication for them benefit them by the consensus of Muslims. He added that fasts a person neglected after recovering from illness are fasted on his behalf after his death, and an obligatory or vowed pilgrimage is performed for him, but praying on behalf of the dead has no basis.
- How a lawful marriage is contracted
A question from a young man who wished to marry and asked how to approach his wife in the way the Prophet did, what to wear, and whether to keep away from her if she is pregnant; Shaykh Ibn Baz answered that lawful marriage is well known: the man proposes to the woman and asks about her religion and circumstances, and once he knows she is a suitable Muslim, her guardian contracts the marriage for him in the presence of some students of knowledge who can explain what is proper, before two upright witnesses, the guardian saying 'I have married her to you' and the groom saying 'I accept', for a dower known between them according to their means, so that the contract rests on four: the guardian, the groom and two witnesses. He mentioned that some scholars recommended that the husband, on first entering upon his wife, pray two units and ask God to bring the two together, and that when he touches her he ask God for her good and the good of her nature and seek refuge from her evil and the evil of her nature, after which he may be intimate with her if he wishes. On pregnancy he distinguished: if she has conceived by him, there is no harm in intercourse while she is pregnant, though not during menstruation or post-natal bleeding; but if he entered upon her and found her pregnant by another man, she owes a waiting period for that other man and the marriage is void.
- Is semen ritually pure or impure?
A question whether semen is ritually pure or impure, and whether rubbing it off suffices when dry and washing when wet; Ibn Baz answered that on the correct view semen is pure, being the origin of the human being, citing Aisha's statement that the Prophet sometimes washed it and sometimes rubbed it off, and that she used to scrape it dry from his garment, which shows its purity, since had it been impure it would have had to be washed rather than merely scraped and cleaned without water; and because the human being is pure, his origin in earth is pure, and so semen, which comes after, is pure.
- Catching the imam in the last unit of the sunset prayer
A question from a worshipper who joined the imam in the last unit of the sunset prayer and sat with him for the final sitting, asking how to complete his prayer; Ibn Baz answered that after the imam's closing salutation he performs a second unit, then sits after it for the first sitting, then rises and performs a third unit reciting al-Fatiha, before the final sitting and salutation.
- Being married to a woman and her maternal cousin at the same time
A question from a man with three wives who wishes to marry a fourth, the maternal cousin of one of them, with both women's consent; Ibn Baz answered that there is no harm in being married at once to a wife and her maternal or paternal cousin, nor in combining two paternal cousins, two maternal cousins or the daughters of two aunts, and that what is forbidden is combining two sisters, by the text of the verse of al-Nisa, and combining a woman with her paternal or maternal aunt, or with her brother's or sister's daughter, since the Prophet forbade this, saying the younger is not married over the elder nor the elder over the younger. He explained that the prohibition covers aunts even at a distance: a woman may not be combined with her father's or mother's paternal aunt, or her grandfather's or grandmother's, nor with her mother's, father's or grandmother's maternal aunt, because the maternal aunt of her father or mother counts as her own.
- Mourning for an elderly widow, and jewellery that is hard to remove
A question on whether mourning applies to an elderly widow and on removing jewellery that is hard to take off, in which Ibn Baz answered that mourning applies to all and the jewellery is removed. Ibn Baz answered that mourning applies to the young and the elderly alike, and to a wife whether or not the marriage was consummated. He distinguished the widow from the divorcee: a woman whose husband dies after the contract but before consummation owes the waiting period and mourning and inherits from him, whereas a woman divorced before consummation owes no waiting period. He said the jewellery is removed, and a bracelet that has grown tight on the wrist is cut off rather than left on.
- The opening supplication in the funeral prayer
A question whether the opening supplication (du'a al-istiftah) is obligatory in the prayer over the dead, in which Ibn Baz answered that the funeral prayer is a lightened prayer, and that the scholars have said there is no opening supplication in it: the worshipper begins with seeking refuge and the basmala and recites al-Fatiha, because it is a prayer in which haste with the dead is sought, so it is better that there be no opening supplication, and this is what is stated by the people of knowledge. He noted that some scholars hold that there is an opening supplication in it, but that the closer view in his judgement is that there is none, because it is a lightened prayer with neither bowing nor prostration.
- A person in retreat (i'tikaf) visiting the sick and attending funerals
A question whether a person in retreat (i'tikaf) may visit the sick and attend a funeral, some scholars having said this is allowed only if he stipulated it before beginning the retreat; Ibn Baz answered that if the sick person is in the mosque there is no harm in visiting him, and likewise praying the funeral prayer in the mosque, but otherwise he should not go out, since the Sunna for the person in retreat is not to visit the sick or attend a funeral unless it takes place in his mosque.
- Recycled sewage water
A hospital worker whose gardens are watered with recycled sewage asks about its spray and about the fruit of trees irrigated with it. Ibn Baz answered that once it has been fully treated so that the colour, taste and smell of impurity are gone, it takes the ruling of purity: its spray does not harm and the fruit of what it waters is acceptable; but if traces of impurity remain it is not to be used for irrigation or anything else and should be diverted where it harms no one.
- Repeating the funeral prayer
A question on repeating the funeral prayer, in which Ibn Baz answered that there is no harm in it when one comes upon a group praying over the deceased. Ibn Baz answered that if someone has prayed over the deceased and then comes upon people praying over him at the grave and joins them, there is no harm in it. He compared it to repeating an obligatory prayer, as when someone who has already prayed comes to another mosque for some need or to attend a lesson while the people are praying, and prays with them. He said repeating for a legitimate reason is acceptable.
- Saying 'you helped me with this after God'
A question whether one may say to a person 'it was you who helped me with such-and-such after God', in which Ibn Baz answered that there is no harm in it, nor in saying 'were it not for God and then you', 'this is from God and then from you', or 'you helped me after God with such-and-such'; what is not permitted is joining with the conjunction 'and', as in 'were it not for God and you', 'this is from God and you', or 'what God wills and you', since it is this 'and' that is impermissible, whereas 'then' and 'after' are unobjectionable.
- Students standing up when the teacher enters
A question from a middle-school teacher whose pupils stand up for him out of respect when he enters the classroom without his asking them to, which he dislikes; Ibn Baz answered that standing up for a person who enters, by way of honouring him, is something the Sunna forbids: the Companions did not stand for the Prophet because they knew he disliked it, and the Prophet said that whoever likes people to stand up for him should take his seat in the Fire; so the pupils must not stand but keep their places and greet him, this kind of standing being at the least strongly disliked, and the teacher may neither like it nor order it, but must admonish and forbid them sincerely, for when they see he means it they will sit; the Ministry of Education and the General Presidency for Education should instruct schools accordingly, for boys and girls alike. He distinguished this from rising to meet and shake hands with the person, to seat him in one's place or to walk him out, which is unobjectionable, citing Talha ibn Ubaydallah rising to Ka'b ibn Malik when God accepted his repentance in the Prophet's presence, the Prophet's words to the Ansar 'stand up for your chief' when Sa'd ibn Mu'adh arrived, and Fatima rising to her father and he to her. He answered those who call the standing a way of alerting pupils that this is a satanic pretext, since his greeting alerts them, and advised one whose superior is angered by not being stood for to explain to him that it is not allowed and that the Messenger disliked it.
- Impure water purified by scientific treatment
A question on impure water that has been recycled and filtered until its smell, colour and taste are like natural water. Ibn Baz distinguished between large and small quantities: a large quantity, two qullas or more, becomes purifying again once its change is removed, by treatment or otherwise; below two qullas the matter is disputed; and a very small quantity is not purified merely by losing the traits of impurity, citing the command to pour out a vessel a dog has drunk from.
- A wife intervening when her husband disciplines his children
A question about a wife's right to speak up to her husband when he disciplines his children, in which Ibn Baz answered that there is no harm in her intervening when the husband is excessive in discipline and lacks insight in it, but with wisdom and a good manner, not with harshness and severity nor in a way that leads him to leave her or insult her; it is better that she intervene when the children are not present, at another time, by way of advice and cooperation in good, unless the matter is so serious it cannot be borne, in which case she may intervene in their presence. When the discipline is sound and appropriate and does not exceed the limits, however, she should not intervene, since that would turn the children against him; rather she should support him, pray for him and encourage him, both in front of the children and in their absence.
- Women praying over the dead and following funerals
A question on women attending funerals, in which Ibn Baz distinguished praying over the deceased from following the bier to the cemetery. Ibn Baz answered that there is no harm in a woman praying over the deceased with the people, noting that women prayed over the Prophet's body. He said what they are barred from is following the deceased to the cemetery and visiting graves. He described their praying over the dead together with the people as legitimate.
- What is said on rising from bowing
A question on which wording is best after rising from bowing. Ibn Baz answered that all four wordings are reported: "Rabbana laka l-hamd", "Rabbana wa-laka l-hamd", "Allahumma rabbana laka l-hamd" and "Allahumma rabbana wa-laka l-hamd"; alternating between them is good, and there is latitude here for the imam and the one praying alone.