At a glance
- Era
- The Prophetic Era
- Region
- Arabia
- Review
- Draft Completeness 1/5 · Help complete it
In time
In space
Map: Natural Earth, public domain · places and route from the graph
After Tabuk, three Muslims stayed behind 'without doubt or hypocrisy': Ka'b ibn Malik, Murara ibn al-Rabi' and Hilal ibn Umayya. The Muslims kept away from them for fifty nights, then their repentance was accepted.
The Prophet returned to Medina after Tabuk, a band of hypocrites having stayed behind in Ibn Ishaq's account — and three Muslims who stayed back 'without doubt or hypocrisy': Ka'b ibn Malik, Murara ibn al-Rabi' and Hilal ibn Umayya. The Prophet told his Companions 'Do not speak to any of these three'; the laggard hypocrites came swearing and excusing and he pardoned them, and the Muslims kept away from speaking to the three. Ka'b told the story himself through Ibn Ishaq's chain from al-Zuhri: the return and the laggards' excuses, Ka'b's delayed preparations, his truthfulness to the Prophet ﷺ, the boycott of the three with its episodes — Abu Qatada on the garden wall, the Ghassanid king's letter, the order to keep apart from their wives — then the accepted repentance and Ka'b's vow of truthfulness.
Storytellers (10–12) read the Explorers text, then cross to the Scholars text.
The Prophet returned to Medina after Tabuk, a band of hypocrites having stayed behind in Ibn Ishaq's account — and three Muslims who stayed back 'without doubt or hypocrisy': Ka'b ibn Malik, Murara ibn al-Rabi' and Hilal ibn Umayya. Ibn Ishaq says the Prophet ﷺ told his Companions 'Do not speak to any of these three'; the laggard hypocrites came swearing and excusing and he pardoned them, 'and the Muslims kept apart from speaking to those three men'. The full story is Ka'b ibn Malik's own account through Ibn Ishaq's chain from al-Zuhri: the return and the laggards' excuses, Ka'b's delayed preparations, his truthfulness to the Prophet, the boycott of the three and what happened in it — Abu Qatada on the garden wall, the Ghassanid king's letter, the order to keep apart from their wives — then the accepted repentance and Ka'b's offering of his wealth and vow of truthfulness. Its concepts: repentance, the social boycott, and truthfulness in speech.
Summary
The Prophet entered Medina after Tabuk, a band of hypocrites having stayed behind per Ibn Ishaq — and three Muslims stayed behind "in neither doubt nor hypocrisy": Ka'b ibn Malik, Marara ibn al-Rabi' and Hilal ibn Umayya. 1
The account
Ibn Ishaq said: the Prophet said to his companions "speak to none of these three", and the hypocrites who stayed behind came swearing oaths and making excuses, and he pardoned them — "and the Muslims shunned speech with those three". 1 The story's detail is Ka'b ibn Malik's own account, on Ibn Ishaq's chain from al-Zuhri, in Ka'b's account. 1
The story's stages
The return and the stragglers' excuses, then Ka'b's delay in preparing, his truthfulness with the Prophet, the boycott of the three and what befell in it: Abu Qatada at the wall, the Ghassanid king's letter, the order to keep apart from the wives, then the acceptance of repentance and Ka'b's vow of truthfulness. The timeline is in the dataset.
Concepts
Source notes and markers of doubt
- Describing the others who stayed behind as hypocrites is Ibn Ishaq's phrasing; none of them is named here.
- "And neither God nor His Messenger excused them" (p. 175): the verb's vowelling on the page is not settled, and the phrase attaches to the excusers in context; to be reviewed.
- "Eighty-odd men", the number of the excusers, is on Ka'b's tongue (p. 177).
Your choice is kept in this browser only.
Opinions on the question
The question: How is the story of the three who were left behind after Tabuk understood?
First opinion · Sunni tradition (the museum's frame)Main reference
More opinions (1)
Academic viewSecondary opinion
Connections
- Had participant
- Hilal ibn Umayya al-Waqifi· Ka'b ibn Malik al-Ansari· Murara ibn al-Rabi al-Amri· Muhammad
- Has part
- The fifty-night boycott of the three· The letter of the king of Ghassan to Ka'b ibn Malik· Ka'b and Abu Qatada at the garden wall· Ka'b ibn Malik puts off his preparations for Tabuk· Ka'b offers his wealth and vows to speak only the truth· Ka'b tells the Prophet the truth· The order that the three keep apart from their wives· The Prophet's return and the excuses of those who stayed behind· The acceptance of the repentance of the three
- Part of
- The expedition to Tabuk
- Occurred at
- Medina
- Mentioned in
- Ka'b ibn Malik's account of staying behind at Tabuk· Bukhari 4418 — Ka'b ibn Malik's account of staying behind at Tabuk
People and things also explored
Medina· Ka'b ibn Malik al-Ansari· Muhammad· The fifty-night boycott of the three· The acceptance of the repentance of the three· The order that the three keep apart from their wives· Hilal ibn Umayya al-Waqifi· Murara ibn al-Rabi al-Amri
Sources
- al-Sira al-Nabawiyya — Ibn Hisham, al-Saqqa edition (1355/1936) , 4/175
- Sahih al-Bukhari
Cite this page
islam.museum contributors. “The three who were left behind after Tabuk”. islam.museum, https://islam.museum/en/event/the-three-left-behind/. CC BY-SA 4.0. Last updated 2026-10-26.