The proverb 'By my own hand, not Amr's'

Words Ideas

مثل «بيدي لا بيد عمرو»

A proverb for one who prefers defeat by his own hand to surrender to his enemy; its tale is that al-Zabba, queen of Palmyra, drank the poison of her ring when Amr's soldiers surrounded her palace 1.

Depth

At a glance

Linguistics

The proverb and its meaning

The proverb 'By my own hand, not Amr's' is one of the Arabic proverbs recorded in the old proverb books, as a research summary supplied to the museum sets out in a choice of ten. Its meaning, in the summary, is preferring self-inflicted defeat over falling into the hands of an enemy. It belongs to the matter of the great Arabic proverb collections treated in the page The Arabic proverb books 1.

The story as the books tell it

It was said by al-Zabba, queen of Palmyra, when the soldiers of Amr ibn Adi, smuggled in hidden in sacks by Qasir ibn Sa'd, surrounded her palace. Realising that escape was cut off, she drank the poison from her ring rather than fall into Amr's hands. 1

The old sources

The summary places the proverb in Majma al-Amthal and ascribes the telling to the Noonpost article. Volume, page and serial numbers stand as in the summary, and the museum has not checked them 1. Majma al-Amthal is the work of Abu al-Fadl al-Maydani, who died in 518 AH, 1124 CE, and holds according to the summary over 6,000 proverbs; the summary tabulates it with Abu Hilal al-Askari's Jamharat al-Amthal and al-Zamakhshari's al-Mustaqsa 2.

When the proverb is used

The proverb is used for what fits its meaning, that is preferring self-inflicted defeat over falling into the hands of an enemy, and the hearer calls its tale to mind even when it is not told. The proverb books agree in keeping a proverb together with its story, because the story explains why it was said, and the sense it is applied to may widen with use; but the summary gives no other instances of its use, so the page gives none.

A note on the nature of the story

The story here is as the books tell it. It is one of the widely repeated traditional reports, and the museum cannot establish that it happened; it is a narrative told to explain the proverb, not confirmed history. The museum has not opened any of the books and pages named.

Basis

This entry rests on a research summary supplied to the museum; the museum did not open the pages it cites, and the founder approved relying on it as it stands on 21 November 2026. All that is here, the text, the meaning, the story and the page numbers, is attributed to the summary 1.

Connections

Explore the connections

Related to
The great Arabic proverb books· al-Zabba bint Amr· Amr ibn Adi ibn Nasr al-Lakhmi· Tadmur (Palmyra)

People and things also explored

The proverb 'Eternity has overtaken Lubad'· The proverb 'His own feet brought a doomed man to you'· The proverb 'Sinimmar's reward'· The proverb 'He returned with Hunayn's two boots'· The proverb 'The sword preceded the blame'· The great Arabic proverb books· The proverb 'In summer you wasted the milk'· The proverb 'Against her own people Baraqish sinned'

Sources

  1. Noonpost article 16943 on Arabic proverbs and their stories (Noonpost)
  2. Arabic proverbs (blog post) (Arabic Typing Lab)
Cite this page

islam.museum contributors. “The proverb 'By my own hand, not Amr's'”. islam.museum, https://islam.museum/en/concept/mathal-biyadi-la-biyadi-amr/. CC BY-SA 4.0. Last updated 2026-11-21.

Improve this page on GitHub · Report an error · Help complete it · JSON

Wing

Words

Qur'an, hadith, poetry, and the languages and scripts of Muslim peoples.
Related

The proverb 'Eternity has overtaken Lubad'

A proverb for the thought that nothing outlasts time; its tale is that Lubad, the last of Luqman ibn Ad's eagles, died and Luqman's own life ended with it.