Assembly of Muslim Jurists of America (amjaonline.org) 431 fatwas

The museum records these fatwas as history, attributed to those who issued them; it issues no ruling and advises no one.

  • Abortion and the breathing of the soul

    A questioner asked where the scholars' linking of abortion to ensoulment came from, since the soul is of God's affair. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 83087, 11 November 2010) answered that the soul's essence and manner are indeed God's affair, yet the soul is known by its effects — we distinguish life from death and the living from the dead; when it enters the fetus, known by its effects such as movement in the womb, aborting it is forbidden by consensus like any assault on the living, so there is no contradiction in this linkage.

    Original page

  • Daily absentee funeral prayers for COVID's dead — the ruling

    A questioner asked about forming groups that commend a daily absentee funeral prayer for those dying in the COVID pandemic. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 87746, 4 April 2020) answered that the absentee prayer — in this crisis or otherwise — is legislated only for one not prayed over by agreement, and in the most evident of the scholars' sayings for those of standing — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Absentee prayer for a Muslim left dead after a traffic accident

    A questioner asked about a Muslim who died in a traffic accident whose body was left — is the absentee prayer legislated for him? AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 86783, 25 April 2012) answered that the absentee prayer is legislated for Muslims not prayed over, as the Prophet prayed over the Negus — as the answer states.

    Original page

  • The report ascribed to Abu Hanifa that Abu Bakr's and Iblis's faith are one

    A questioner asked about a report transmitted from Abu Hanifa via al-Fazari that Abu Bakr's faith and Iblis's faith are one. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 87079, 8 July 2012) answered that the report — if authentic — has nothing to do with what slanderers claim: iman is applied to knowledge, to assent, to humble submission, or to all of these; Abu Hanifa — if the report is sound — meant to note that two opposites may meet in one aspect without the others: Abu Bakr is the summit of faith and Satan the head of disbelief, yet they share the root of knowing God, as Mecca's polytheists acknowledged lordship — and the difference between them is the answer spells out.

    Original page

  • Acting on a fatwa later shown to be wrong

    A questioner asked whether God would hold him accountable if an official fatwa body's answer he acted on turned out wrong. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 84032, 18 March 2011) answered that if he sincerely sought the truth, asked one whose religion and knowledge he trusted and followed the answer, there is no blame and he is excused whether the mufti erred or hit right — that being his reach of knowledge; he must then follow what later proves right and repair what can be repaired, and what is past and irreparable is pardoned, God willing.

    Original page

  • Acting on preponderance in worship

    A questioner said he had found no proof permitting reliance on conjecture in worship, only proofs forbidding it. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77894, 19 February 2009) answered that zann is the outweighing of one side of possibility, unlike doubt which is the mind's equal wavering between two things; among fiqh's proofs some are certain in transmission and indication, and some conjectural in one or the other where one side outweighs without reaching certainty — yet acting on the preponderant is agreed among scholars; conjecture is blameworthy generally in the creed-chapter, which is built on certainty.

    Original page

  • The span between Adam and Muhammad

    A questioner noticed, reading the prophetic biographies, the span from Adam to Muhammad and asked about it. Dr. Muhammad Mawfiq al-Ghalayini (fatwa no. 21851, 13 November 2006) answered that no established proof exists in the prophetic biography for this span, nor decisive scientific facts — only differing theories; he counselled the questioner not to spend his time on such matters but to concentrate on what benefits his religion and his world.

    Original page

  • Must Muslim prisoners appoint one to raise the adhan

    A questioner asked whether Muslim prisoners must appoint one among them to raise the adhan. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 21991, 14 October 2012) answered that the adhan is Islam's emblem, announcing the prayer time's entry and calling to it — a collective duty on Muslims in every land; when some in a town perform it, its obligation falls from the rest — as the answer details for prisoners.

    Original page

  • The after-prayer adhkar belong to the obligatory prayers

    A questioner asked whether the adhkar said after the obligatory prayers are legislated after sunna prayers too. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 87638, 25 October 2012) answered that these adhkar came tied to the prescribed prayers and stay restricted to them, quoting the Permanent Committee for Ifta in the Two Holy Precincts asked this very question and answering likewise — as the answer sets out.

    Original page

  • Adultery and the plea of sorcery — the door of repentance

    A man of thirty said a married former friend could not forget him, resorted to sorcery-kinds, and though he restrained himself repeatedly he could not hold. Dr. Muhammad Mawfiq al-Ghalayini (fatwa no. 21825, 11 April 2005) answered that he must not plead sorcery — adultery is among the greatest of major sins, and with a married woman graver still for the mixing of lineages, ruining of families and betraying of husbands it breeds; repentance's door stands wide open — God stretches His hand by night for the day's sinner and by day for the night's; let him mend his past with remorse, his present with desisting and his future with resolve never to return.

    Original page

  • Advising siblings who do not pray — constancy and gentle winning

    A devout woman asked — her brother a flight officer never prays, and her unmarried younger sister prays only if she sees them praying. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 86811, 2 May 2012) answered that what falls on her is constant counsel and striving to win their hearts to God's obedience as possible; there is no harm in courteous dealings toward that end, winning their hearts to obedience and stirring them to repentance — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • The Ahbash group's strife among Ethiopia's Muslims

    A questioner asked about the Lebanese Ahbash group stirring strife among Ethiopia's Muslims and dividing their ranks, in his account with official support. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 85691, 18 October 2011) answered that their ruling had been set out — their method being innovation in creed and approach and misguided in many creed and practice matters, in AMJA's view — and quoted the Saudi Permanent Committee's answer on Abdullah al-Harari al-Habashi calling him a head of innovation and misguidance and holding it a duty to warn against the group, as quoted. Recorded as AMJA's answer citing the committee.

    Original page

  • The Prophet's family's right in the khums and fay'

    A questioner raised Ibn Taymiyya's saying that the Prophet's household has rights that must be observed, God having assigned them a share in the khums and fay'. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 80682, 22 December 2009) answered that khums and fay' have lapsed since lawful jihad lapsed, with secularism declared in many Muslim lands and the sharia's authority receded; he hoped matters return to their right state and the Prophet's household regain their rights therein — and that is not beyond God. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Al-Afuww or al-Ghaffar — which is more emphatic

    A questioner raised the scholars' disagreement over whether God's name al-Ghaffar is more emphatic than al-Afuww or vice versa. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77772, 9 February 2009) answered that afw is overlooking the sin and leaving its punishment, while ghifara is from ghafr — covering and veiling — so al-Ghaffar is the One who veils His servants' sins and passes over them; it is possible afw is more emphatic, ghifara indicating veiling and afw indicating erasure, and erasure is more emphatic — citing al-Ghazali to that effect, with the servant's share being that he pardon whoever wrongs him.

    Original page

  • Do God's acts fall under the name al-Batin

    A questioner asked whether God's acts fall under His name al-Batin — a man dies and we do not see how God did it. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77599, 27 January 2009) answered that God does what He wills, His acts never part from His wisdom, and He executes His decree through causes, without them or against them; none repels His judgment and none reviews His decree; everything touching God's names and attributes is known to us in meaning, its how consigned to God — then counselled him to busy himself with what benefits, since every question on which no action rests is the needless exertion we were forbidden.

    Original page

  • Al-Luhaydi the Mahdi claimant — prophethood is sealed

    A questioner asked about the Luhaydi sect in Yemen claiming their man is the awaited Mahdi and a messenger from God. Dr. Walid Basyouni (fatwa no. 21841, 20 July 2006) answered that whoever claims prophethood and the message were not sealed with Muhammad ibn Abdullah brings what contradicts the foundation of Islam and the religion — the ummah's consensus stands on it; as for the details of what this sect holds he had no knowledge of them, referring to Dr. Nasir ibn Abd al-Karim al-Aql's writings on the Mahdi question.

    Original page

  • Alcohol-based hand sanitizer — permitted in medicine

    A questioner asked the ruling on using a hand sanitizer containing a large proportion of alcohol in the pandemic days. AMJA's Permanent Fatwa Committee (no. 87745, 3 April 2020) answered that the scholars examined alcohol not meant for drinking but for medical sterilizing and disinfecting or perfumery; the International Islamic Fiqh Academy at its sixteenth session in Mecca ruled medicines containing alcohol in consumed proportions demanded by pharmaceutical manufacture with no alternative are lawful if prescribed by a fair physician — and likewise alcohol may be used in sterilizing and disinfecting, as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Taking non-Muslim citizenship — AMJA's ruling

    A young man from the Maghreb resident in Canada for three years — the period qualifying him for citizenship — asked about naturalizing. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 80516, 23 November 2009) answered that the Assembly of Muslim Jurists of America examined the question and resolved that there is no harm in naturalization taken as a means to order the affairs of residents outside or inside Muslim lands, so long as its holder keeps his loyalty to his creed and his ummah and stands by his covenant with God and His messenger. Recorded as AMJA's resolution.

    Original page

  • The ruling on anal intercourse with one's wife

    A sharia-college student asked about a question debated in a lecture. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78387, 29 March 2009) answered that approaching one's wife anally is among the major sins: the 'tilth' of 'your women are a tilth for you, so come to your tilth as you will' confines permission to the front passage alone, being the seedbed of offspring — what is cast into the womb likened to seed cast into soil — and 'as you will' means from whatever direction, front or back, provided it is the place of tilth; he cited the hadith that whoever comes to a menstruating woman, a woman anally, or a diviner has disbelieved in what was sent down on Muhammad. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • The angel's touch and the devil's touch — the hadith

    A questioner asked for the meaning of 'the angel has a touch and the devil has a touch: the angel's is affirmation of truth and promise of good; the devil's is denial of truth and promise of evil'. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77750, 7 February 2009) answered that what falls into the heart by way of the angel is a promise of good — prayer, fasting — and an affirmation of truth — God's books and His messenger; what falls from the devil — Iblis or his soldiers — is a promise of evil — disbelief, wickedness, injustice — and a denial of truth in God's right, creation's right, or the established matter such as tawhid, prophethood, resurrection, the Fire and the Garden; the devil's touch is called waswasa, the angel's ilham.

    Original page

  • He almost uttered an ill word in anger but held his tongue

    A questioner who was so angered he nearly uttered an ill word but caught his tongue asked whether he must repeat the testimony. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78017, 28 February 2009) answered with the Prophet's counsel — do not be angry — thanking God the matter never passed inner thought, his tongue held; God has pardoned this ummah what their selves whisper so long as it is not done or spoken; he should seek forgiveness and renew his resolve to uprightness away from anger's provocations.

    Original page

  • Calamities befalling unaccountable animals

    A questioner raised the atheists' doubt that unaccountable animals suffer calamities with no afterlife compensation. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 86371, 22 January 2012) answered that God's acts are never without wisdom — some grasped, some not; though beasts bear no obligation, on the Last Day retaliation is exacted for the hornless ewe from the horned one as the sunna records, so it is possible that part of what befalls them in this world — besides being a punishment or trial for their owners — is a worldly penalty for them too; and the injustice God forbade Himself is placing a thing out of place and withholding a due.

    Original page

  • The apostate's ruling and penalty — how to answer at Islamic centres

    Islamic centres asked how to answer questions reaching them about the apostate's ruling and penalty. Dr. Hatim al-Hajj (fatwa no. 21837, 17 April 2006) answered that the answer should begin by stating this matter belongs to the judiciaries of Muslim states, not to individuals there or elsewhere; then that the courts examine such cases on many details and considerations; and the ruling in the sharia is death for men per the four imams — and for the woman at the majority, confinement at the Hanafis — for 'whoever changes his religion, kill him' and 'a Muslim's blood is unlawful but by one of three', as the answer details. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • A group's apostasy in Minnesota, and dawa's two missions

    A questioner reported a group in Minnesota who had left their religion and begun speaking against the religion and the Prophet. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81733, 23 June 2010) answered with sorrow at their apostasy — preferring blindness to guidance — citing the verse that God will bring a people He loves and who love Him should any turn back from their religion; they lose only themselves and do not harm God. He reminded that dawa outside Muslim lands has two missions: preserving Islam among its people — the top priority — and calling non-Muslims to it, and hoped the questioner would not despair of restoring them through sincere effort and knowing their circumstances closely, as detailed. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Appointing an amir over Muslims in a non-Islamic land

    A questioner asked whether Muslims in a non-Islamic land must appoint an amir, whether he must bear that title, and what his required qualities are. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81745, 25 June 2010) answered that the duty is for Muslims to remain within the sharia's fold, ruling their social lives by it when they cannot rule politically — resorting to their scholars and putting forward their jurists when the age lacks a lawful sultan guarding the religion and steering the world by it; the community's two orders are the scholars and the rulers, so when the rulers are absent affairs fall to the scholars; the aim is unity of word around applying the sharia and submitting to its authority, whatever the chosen title — community dean or other — as detailed.

    Original page

  • The aqiqa hair custom

    A questioner asked about some Muslims' aqiqa custom of collecting the boy's shaved hair in a paper placed in the shroud when he dies. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 86468, 22 February 2012) answered that they know of no evidence for it and that, as far as their knowledge goes, it is among the newly invented practices that should be done away with. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Unifying Muslim discourse in the Quranic tongue

    A questioner asked whether Muslims' discourse with one another may be unified in the tongue of the Quran rather than intermediary languages. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 82485, 9 September 2010) answered that speaking Arabic is among Islam's rites and expressed his wish that it be the mother tongue on which all Muslims meet in speech on every land under every sky. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Frequent washing for mere thoughts — it is madhy

    A woman was washing often merely for her husband's phone talk, his fondling or imagining. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 23382, 25 July 2008) answered that what exits at thinking of desire or fondling — a thin white fluid that is no gush and is followed by no lassitude — is madhy, which obliges only wudu, as Shaykh al-Qaradawi said; its difference from semen is plain — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • The Ash'aris and the manners of creedal disagreement

    A questioner asked AMJA's view of the creed of the Ash'aris — the great majority of the people of the sunna and the community — and of those who attack it. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81577, 30 May 2010) answered that transgression is unlawful whether against this creed or any other — by justice the heavens and earth stand; the Ash'aris got some things right and erred in others, and matters are discussed among their people on their merits, within mutual counsel, with proofs and scholarly arguments and far from the atmosphere of trading accusations and abuse. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Asking 'by God's face' — the hadith and its meanings

    A questioner asked about asking 'by God's face' and giving 'for God and His messenger' in light of tawhid and shirk. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21862, 6 August 2007) answered that 'none is asked by God's face but paradise' is reported though the hadith-scholars weakened it; supposing it stood, scholars differed on its meaning: first, that one should not ask creatures by God's face — they cannot give paradise — while whoever is asked by it should answer his asker; second, that God is not to be asked for anything but paradise, worldly trifles being unworthy of asking by the Face. The answer continues on giving for God and His messenger.

    Original page

  • An attraction resisted — no sin in the struggle itself

    A questioner described an inclination toward males rather than females and asked whether it is a trial or a punishment — would God test His servants with what displeases Him? Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 792, 13 September 2005) answered that the mere inclination, if a man curbs its reins and does not indulge it — fearing his Lord's standing, forbidding his soul it and resisting it with all he can — carries no harm and no blame; he may even be written the reward of one who struggles with his soul and trains it on his Lord's obedience, it becoming a cause of raised ranks and expiated sins; the harm begins only when indulgence begins and the soul and desire are answered.

    Original page

  • Attributing feeling to God — the names are revealed

    A questioner asked about the line 'I suffered, and none but You felt my pain' — may feeling be attributed to God? Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21873, 28 November 2007) answered that the rule is God's names and attributes are revealed, not coined — it should rather be said 'none but You knew my pain'.

    Original page

  • Madhy and avoiding arousing scenes

    A young man asked about a state befalling him sometimes when viewing arousing scenes. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 86032, 1 December 2011) answered that his first counsel is to avoid looking at such scenes — unlawful in themselves on one side and clouding, possibly corrupting, his worship of his Lord on the other; madhy does not oblige a washing but only istinja and wudu, per Ali's account — 'I was a man of much madhy and shied from asking the Messenger of God for his daughter's sake, so I had al-Miqdad ask him, and he said: wudu for it' — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Balancing religious and worldly sciences

    A questioner asked how to balance religious and worldly sciences. The Assembly of Muslim Jurists of America (fatwa no. 21824, 14 October 2012) answered that religious sciences divide into individual obligations binding every Muslim — learning what his prayer, fasting and worship cannot be valid without, where asking a trustworthy scholar suffices so he worships with insight — and communal obligations on the umma as a whole, not each person, such as inheritance detail and the fine points of transactions, which must have people in the umma who master them; and it set out on this basis how the two kinds of learning are combined.

    Original page

  • A paint barrier and a tight prayer-time

    A questioner had paint on his hand barring the water, hard to strip until the prayer-time narrowed. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 82348, 27 August 2010) answered that wudu binds him when he rises to pray — God accepts no prayer of one in hadath till he does wudu; the wudu as described in God's book and His Messenger's sunna requires water reaching its limbs, so no wudu stands with a barrier keeping water from the limb; where the barrier cannot be removed he does tayammum — as detailed.

    Original page

  • What was truly made beloved — Ahmad's hadith

    A questioner forwarded by email a long hadith claiming the Prophet had three worldly things made dear to him. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77608, 28 January 2009) answered that the long hadith is not sound; what is sound is 'women and perfume were made dear to me from this world, and the coolness of my eyes was placed in prayer' — narrated by Ahmad and al-Nasa'i — and it does not say three, for he named two, women and perfume, while the third, prayer, is his eye's delight and belongs to the religion, not to this world.

    Original page

  • The best generation is mine — answering the objector

    A questioner cited 'the best of generations is mine, then those who follow them' — asked if it is sound in that wording, and reported an impure-creed objector belittling the Companions' society. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77839, 15 February 2009) answered that the hadith is established in the two Sahihs from Abu Hurayra in that very wording, received by the ummah with acceptance and consensus on its meaning; a few hypocrites in the Companions' society do not lower their rank, nor do rare lapses diminish its worth — so rare they became famous for being told; the apostasy emerged in Abu Bakr's time, not the prophetic era, and even so it opened to the Muslims gates of servitude and brought many of them to the highest paradise. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Blood donation and the wudu — the schools on copious blood

    A questioner asked whether a blood donor must do wudu for the prayer or his wudu stands. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21947, 16 January 2007) answered that the two imams Abu Hanifa and Ahmad held copious blood breaks the wudu, while Shafi'i and Malik held it does not; the cautious course is doing wudu — as the answer details the weighing.

    Original page

  • The book 'The Limit of Islam' — a reading caution

    A questioner asked for remarks on the book 'The Limit of Islam'. The site's sharia department (fatwa no. 21866, 3 September 2007) answered that they do not recommend reading it except to scholars and the clear-sighted among students — to expose the creed-errors in it that might deceive people. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Buying the products of states at war with Islam

    A questioner asked whether eating or buying the products of states warring against Islam — such as America or France — is permissible, and whether boycott is obligatory. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 82012, 1 August 2010) answered that where alternatives from Muslim or peaceable states are available one should hold to them and seek no substitute, and where they are not, one may buy what is lawful from whomever one wills.

    Original page

  • Classifying dawa groups as deviant

    A questioner put three questions about the Muslim Brotherhood, including whether it counts among the deviant groups. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 87474, 21 September 2012) answered that it is not the Assembly's practice to discuss dawa groups and figures — it describes truth and falsehood and leaves the questioner to apply the criterion; a dawa collective is not a deviant faction unless it rallies around an innovated root principle contradicting what is fixed by Book, sunna and consensus, or around novel practices that dominate its striving, and they know no such thing of the Muslim Brotherhood, a dawa collective standing for the sharia's support and an Islamic state — it is not classed among those factions; if a branch in a given country is known for that, that branch alone bears the mark without the ruling spreading beyond it — and he answered the remaining questions as detailed. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Camel meat and the wudu — an ijtihad question

    A questioner asked the decisive word on eating camel meat — does it break the wudu? Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 3206, 10 July 2007) answered that this is among the ijtihad questions admitting difference: the majority's madhhab holds camel meat does not break the wudu; the Hanbalis, and the Shafi'is in the old position, held it breaks it and wudu is required — chosen also by Ibn Khuzayma and Ibn Baz — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Too ill to wash on waking in ihtilam — tayammum, then pray

    A man of twenty-four could not manage the washing on waking in ihtilam for illness. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21951, 13 July 2007) answered that if the matter is as he described — harm to him prevailing in likelihood on washing — he may do tayammum and pray with the congregation until he washes at a near suitable time to lift his janaba, taking the means of treatment and asking people of knowledge — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Praying before a non-Muslim cellmate — his rights of neighbor

    A questioner lives in a cell with a non-Muslim and finds praying before him on the floor difficult. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 21998, 14 October 2012) answered that this companion decreed upon him in the cell holds a set of rights: the right of humanity — he is human with rights that must be met — and the right of neighborhood, for the Prophet commended the neighbor — the answer detailing the prayer's rulings in such a place.

    Original page

  • The marks of the saved sect ⁦(a prisoner asking how a new Muslim should choose among prison groups)⁩

    A prisoner asked by what marks a new Muslim should choose a leadership and community among the various groups present in prison (Sunni, Nation of Islam, Muslim societies and others). The Assembly of Muslim Jurists of America (fatwa no. 21821, 14 October 2012) answered that the norm for a Muslim is uprightness on the Book and the Sunna and keeping company with the persons and groups closest to them, in the measure of their closeness; that a newcomer should first devote himself to seeking sound religious knowledge from its sources and people until he holds the criterion by which persons and gatherings are weighed; and that he should not spend the beginning of his quest chasing the branches of their disputes, which wastes lifetimes and scatters the seeker.

    Original page

  • A Christian's ten questions on Islam

    A Christian reader of the site's articles put ten questions, including paradise in Islam and the corruption of the Gospel. Dr. Walid Basyouni (fatwa no. 21842, 20 July 2006) answered among them that after Muhammad's mission no believer's faith stands nor his tawhid is sound except by believing in his prophethood once he hears of him and his call reaches him — 'Islam' naming every believer of the earlier nations and, specially, Muhammad's followers; and the Gospel's corruption is plainer than needing proof: the Gospel writers themselves are unknown, no one knows who translated or transmitted them by connected chains, let alone the contradictions among them admitted by Christian scholars themselves. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • The Christian wife's doubtful Islam

    A man who married a Christian woman — she outwardly accepted Islam and wished to declare it at al-Azhar, then told him she had never believed and only acted to please him — asked where he stands. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 85565, 22 September 2011) answered that the matter is doubtful: viewing her acknowledgment of Islam and consent to declare it makes her a Muslim whose later act is apostasy; viewing her own testimony that she never believed keeps her on her first state; it is better for him to part from her, since the default of the private parts is prohibition until permission is proven with certainty. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Social courtesy toward Christians on their feasts

    A questioner asked whether they may greet Christians on Christmas as courtesy while residing in their lands, or reply if greeted. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 80630, 13 December 2009) answered that the default with covenant non-Muslims is kindness and equity, including congratulating them on shared social occasions — marriage, a new child; religious feasts belong to each creed's particularities and stay with their people, yet where benefit prevails there is no harm in courtesy with general words that neither violate those particularities nor affirm their religion or show approval of it. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • A lasting excuse and the congregational prayer

    A questioner asked whether to join the congregation when he suspects he would emit drops if he moved or bent in the prayer. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 83747, 10 February 2011) answered that people of lasting excuses who suspect that bearing a certain span after the time enters will end the excuse should wait for its ending to preserve purity — purity being half of faith and its obligation agreed, while the congregational prayer's obligation is disputed; the answer details the rulings of excuse-holders.

    Original page

  • The passing whisper and the settled doubt

    A chronic whisperer — unsure whether the grave thoughts against faith he entertained or uttered were whispering or meant — asked what to do. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77887, 19 February 2009) answered that he had answered him before: be gentle with yourself and do not weary it with hardship; passing whispers — cast them off, give them no heed and do not indulge them, saying 'praise God who turned his plot into whispering'; if they become a settled established state, seek their cure with the godly among the scholars and bearers of the sharia he knows.

    Original page

  • Should I emigrate to a non-Muslim country? ⁦(a tobacco-company worker granted Canadian residence)⁩

    A questioner who worked for a cigarette manufacturer and had obtained permanent residence in Canada asked whether to emigrate. The Assembly of Muslim Jurists of America (permanent fatwa committee, fatwa no. 87631, 23 October 2012) answered that working in tobacco production is aiding what is objectionable and cooperating in sin, since tobacco is a harmful product, and that such employment should be accepted only under pressing necessity; the answer also set out the conditions governing emigration to non-Muslim lands.

    Original page

  • Citizenship ⁦(a father asking about taking American citizenship for his four American daughters' sake)⁩

    A questioner who had read an earlier AMJA fatwa but could not decide asked about taking citizenship, fearing it yet having four American daughters. The Assembly of Muslim Jurists of America (fatwa no. 87600, 17 October 2012) answered that there is no harm in seeking citizenship given his evident need, provided he observes the controls restated from the earlier ruling: naturalisation stripped of unqualified acceptance of the state's laws and systems and of absolute belonging, and free of religiously forbidden entailments, falls within permissibility for need; what is bound to a prohibition is judged accordingly.

    Original page

  • Naturalisation for a lawful benefit

    An Egyptian doctor working in Saudi Arabia who had earned a British fellowship asked about naturalisation. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 80328, 24 October 2009) answered that naturalisation is unobjectionable when it becomes the means of ordering the affairs of residents outside Muslim lands and settling their presence, and for those coming from abroad when it is the means to a lawful benefit — provided the person keeps his covenant with God and His Messenger and his loyalty to his creed and ummah, while honouring the security covenant with the host state and what flows from it.

    Original page

  • A little clear fluid — only semen obliges the washing

    A questioner asked the ruling on a little clear fluid leaving the member. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 79164, 13 June 2009) answered that of what exits the front part, only semen obliges the washing — the gushing water that leaves in a gush with desire followed by lassitude; whatever lies beyond that obliges only istinja and wudu — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Climax without intercourse — the washing still binds

    A woman whose husband's foreplay brings her to climax without intercourse asked whether washing binds her. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 80851, 21 January 2010) answered that washing binds on intercourse even without emission, and on emission even without intercourse; one reaching the peak — which mostly comes only with emission — owes the washing whether her husband entered her or not — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • The conditions of excusable coercion

    A questioner asked whether the coerced is excused unconditionally, and whether one who says 'in that case I would have done it' — aloud or in himself — is excused. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77741, 7 February 2009) answered that coercion-questions are delicate and branching; the essence: sharia coercion is forcing another into an act he neither wills nor accepts, and the conditions for the coerced to be excused are the coercer's power to carry out his threat, the coerced's fear of it, the threat being killing, loss of a limb or what ranks as such — distress removing consent — that the coerced would have refrained but for the coercion, that the act's object is definite, and that he has no way out, as detailed.

    Original page

  • Colitis and guarding against discharge

    A colitis patient of fluctuating state asked about the protruding of waste-matter. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 80245, 15 October 2009) answered that he should guard himself, such protrusion being an evident likelihood and a near avenue to soiling the clothes, a Muslim's rule being to fear God as far as he can; he asked God to wipe him with His healing right hand and join reward and health for him — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Combining two intentions in a voluntary prayer or fast — no harm

    A questioner asked about combining two intentions in a voluntary prayer or fast. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 21982, 14 October 2012) answered that there is no harm in it — intentions are the scholars' commerce, as they say; one fasting Monday or Thursday among the days the Prophet commended earns both rewards — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • The complete washing — a shower suffices

    A questioner described letting the shower run over his body after janaba and asked whether that suffices. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 86977, 18 June 2012) answered that the complete washing begins with the prayer-wudu, then pouring water on the head thrice, then the right side then the left, with continuity and rubbing; istinja is covered by istijmar — one who has cleansed with stones or toilet paper need not wash the part with water once purity is had, though combining both is better; what is obligatory is covering the body with water, which the shower's flow achieves — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Congratulating Christians on their feasts — Ibn al-Qayyim and al-Qaradawi

    A questioner cited Ibn al-Qayyim's ruling that congratulating disbelievers on their distinctive rituals — their feasts and fasts — is forbidden by consensus, against al-Qaradawi's saying every group may celebrate its feast without harming others. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 83113, 14 November 2010) answered that al-Qaradawi's words point to the scholars' agreement on leaving the dhimmis to their creed and not disturbing their rituals; congratulations on social occasions carry no harm, but on religious feasts the matter is doubtful, and Ibn al-Qayyim's words are in his view the sounder and better-guided. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Scholars congratulating Christians on their feasts

    A questioner asked whether scholars congratulating Christians on their feasts have any precedent or proof. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78925, 20 May 2009) answered that the default is kindness and equity toward covenant non-Muslims, into which some counted among the learned fold congratulations on their feasts — but that is open to question, since the sound view is that feasts are among the rites, per 'for every community We appointed a rite they observe'; sharing in them or congratulating on them is not permissible, while kindness and equity continue in all else. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • The contraceptive patch — judged like a splint

    A woman asked about the square contraceptive patch worn for days — must it be placed in purity, and does it bar washing? Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 86339, 17 January 2012) answered that the contraceptive patch takes the splint's ruling: it need not be placed in a state of purity and has no set duration; but its use should be lawful in the first place — as when delaying pregnancy traces to a recognized sharia interest, not to fear of poverty as the first Jahiliyya's people had, and not harmful to the woman; the Permanent Committee in the Two-Sanctuaries land answered its analogues on this method — as detailed.

    Original page

  • How to call a person to Islam

    A questioner asked how to convince a person of Islam. Dr. Hatim al-Hajj (fatwa no. 21838, 14 May 2006) gave a practical list: seek God's help — servants' hearts are between His two fingers; good character may speak a hundred times louder than words; show the weakness and contradiction of what he holds; introduce Islam's beauty, comprehensiveness and soundness; introduce the Messenger of God, his fragrant life and his miracles — and consult the Islamic sites for more detail on each point.

    Original page

  • Is one who dies of COVID-19 a martyr?

    A question: is one who dies of COVID-19 a martyr? The permanent fatwa committee of the Assembly of Muslim Jurists of America (fatwa no. 87743, 30 March 2020) answered that martyrs are of two kinds: the martyr of this world and the next — the battle-killed who is buried in his clothes unwashed and unprayed over — and the martyr of the hereafter alone, who does not receive the martyrs' worldly rites but has their reward; and that one who dies of COVID-19 has a martyr's reward in the hereafter, falling under the saying 'the plague-stricken is a martyr' for those who extend plague to all deadly epidemics, and under 'one who dies of pleurisy is a martyr' for those who generalise to every chest pain, citing Ibn al-Qayyim in Zad al-Ma'ad.

    Original page

  • Raising the crescent with the cross for national unity

    A questioner asked about raising a crescent-with-cross emblem for national unity in lands where Muslims and Christians live together. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 83460, 3 January 2011) answered that the cross is a Christian emblem its people may raise — Muslims being commanded to leave them and their creed be — but the Muslim holds the crucifixion claim false by the verse, so he cannot raise an emblem he believes void; that does not detract from the duty of national solidarity against security breaches and sectarian tension, and the two groups may fly the flag of the state sheltering them all. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Hanging the crescent on mosques

    A questioner asked about hanging the crescent on some mosques. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 79136, 9 June 2009) answered that the default in worship-acts is restriction to the text, while hanging the crescent on mosques is among customary matters not worship — and the custom-chapter is wide, its default being permission until a proof of prohibition comes.

    Original page

  • Cursing one who died a disbeliever

    A questioner asked whether one who died a disbeliever may be cursed and testified to be among the people of the Fire. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81528, 22 May 2010) answered that the texts show whoever dies in disbelief is among the people of the Fire — 'nor those who die as disbelievers; for them We prepared a painful punishment' — but that is a general ruling to be believed in generally; it does not license cursing an individual nor testifying that a specific person is in the Fire, except one for whom evidence came naming him, just as believing that whoever dies faithful enters Paradise does not license testifying that for an individual unless proof names him. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Cursing lifeless things

    A questioner asked the ruling on cursing lifeless things. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 82312, 24 August 2010) answered that the Muslim is not a reviler, a curser, obscene or foul-mouthed; no living thing or lifeless object should be cursed except where a text has come cursing it — such as the unmarked cursing of wrongdoers generally, as in 'God's curse be upon the unjust' or 'the liars', and the like.

    Original page

  • Cursing religion then repenting

    A questioner asked about a man who uttered a curse-word against religion — whether his wife is thereby separated, whether cursing the religion of lifeless things disbelieves, and whether advising him to wash, re-proclaim and repent suffices. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 84229, 15 April 2011) answered that the word is grave — disbelief from its sayer, and likewise cursing the religion of inanimate things since everything glorifies His praise; but the wife is separated only upon persisting in disbelief: whoever seeks forgiveness and turns back, his wife is not separated and no new marriage contract is demanded, since the Companions did not demand of repenting apostates a renewal of their contracts. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Breaking the prayer to open the mosque door — not legislated

    A questioner asked whether he may cut the prayer to open the prayer-hall or mosque door for a worshipper. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 86935, 3 June 2012) answered that cutting the prayer for such a thing is not legislated — unless the door is near and toward the qibla, then he may advance a few steps to open it, per the hadith transmitted in that — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Necessity and hardship — al-Suyuti's two kinds of mashaqqa

    A questioner asked whether 'necessity' means hardship, and what roughly delimits hardship since it cannot be pinned except approximately by the sharia's rules. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 619, 23 May 2005) answered that among the fiqh maxims are 'hardship brings ease' and 'when a matter narrows it widens'; al-Suyuti delimited the hardship that brings ease into two kinds: a hardship worship is rarely free of — cold in wudu and washing, fasting in fierce heat and long days, travel inseparable from hajj and jihad, the pain of penalties — which never drops the duties at any time; and a hardship occurring only sometimes, which is subject to consideration since the law regards people's states — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Request for a study critiquing Darwin's theory

    A student asked for help preparing for an Australian university a documented study critiquing Darwin's theory by a Muslim scholar. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81759, 28 June 2010) answered that the request lies outside the Assembly's current concerns, and referred him to the International Commission on Scientific Signs in the Quran and Sunna, a body specialising in such questions. Recorded as a referral, not a ruling.

    Original page

  • Deeds within faith — the Murji'a and the Sunnis

    A questioner interested in the shaykh's thought asked about the Murji'a's separating deeds from faith. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21858, 10 July 2007) answered that the essence is: deeds are a condition of faith's completeness, except what the proof shows to be a condition of its validity — and this does not contradict saying faith is word and deed, for the Murji'a excluded all deeds from the name of faith and the Khawarij drew all into faith's root while the Sunnis stand between: faith is word and deed, but some deeds enter faith's root, some its obligatory completeness, some its recommended completeness — the revealed proofs distinguish each.

    Original page

  • The standing of the Companions and of Aisha

    A questioner uneasily raised the old questions turned over against the Companions. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 23570, 24 August 2008) answered that what he holds as religion is that the hearts of Muhammad's companions are the purest of servants' hearts and their age the best of ages; reviling and attacking them is an unerring mark of hypocrisy and of the Judge's displeasure; he holds with certainty that Abu Bakr is the best of this ummah after its prophet, Umar the best of the Companions after Abu Bakr, and that the Mother of the Believers Aisha is pure and purified, his wife in this world and the next — God would not deceive His prophet in her — and whoever insults her in what God cleared her of has his saying thrown back at him. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Defining faith — word and deed explained

    A questioner raised a difficulty in defining faith in sum as word and deed, detailed as the heart's word, the tongue's word, the heart's deed, the tongue's deed and the limbs' deed. Dr. Walid Basyouni (fatwa no. 21834, 18 January 2006) answered that it is simple: the definition describes faith in itself, apart from what is believed — faith in God is the heart's affirming Him, the tongue's declaring Him, and the heart's, tongue's and limbs' acting accordingly; faith in the angels, books, messengers, Last Day and decree runs the same way; whoever leaves acting on any of that is deficient in faith, not outside it entirely — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Post-natal fasting debt carried past the next Ramadan

    A woman was in post-natal bleeding through Ramadan 2010, broke the whole month and made up part before the next Ramadan, the rest still owed. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 86770, 22 April 2012) answered that if delaying the makeup until another Ramadan came was for an excuse, no sin and no fidya is on her — but she must make it up at first ability, and for an obligatory fast the intention must be settled overnight — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • The solvent debtor's delay and the hadith on transfer

    A questioner asked for the explanation of Abu Hurayra's hadith on the solvent man's delaying and 'if one of you is referred to a solvent man, let him follow'. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77688, 4 February 2009) answered that the solvent debtor's stalling on what he owes while able to pay is an injustice not lawful — many, merchants especially, stall on dues begrudging their liquid cash, a clear wrong angering God and His messenger; and 'when one is referred to a solvent man, let him follow' — narrated also as 'whoever is transferred to a solvent man, let him accept' — means the creditor whom his debtor refers to another to pay his due should accept the transfer; most scholars take it as recommended, Ahmad as obligatory.

    Original page

  • Delaying the Eid prayers a day or two — refused

    A questioner asked whether the Eid prayers may be delayed a day or two. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 87601, 17 October 2012) answered that every benefit mentioned is voided, for it stands against texts and practical consensus; and whoever wishes to attend Jumu'a on Eid day has it before him, since the mosques will hold both prayers together — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Delaying Fajr without real excuse — the emigrants' circumstances weighed

    A questioner said they delay the Fajr prayer for no definite reason. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 86088, 7 December 2011) answered that the best of works is the prayer at its time, as the infallible reported; but where emigrants' circumstances outside the lands of Islam require delaying it past the time's start so they can pray it in congregation, there is no harm — the answer detailing the bounds.

    Original page

  • Delaying hajj while able, and takfir

    A questioner asked whether one who postpones the hajj though able is a disbeliever, as the Friday preacher said. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 82871, 15 October 2010) answered that scholars differ on whether hajj is due at once or may be deferred — two well-known opinions, the sounder being immediacy for whoever is able in body and wealth — yet that does not mean declaring the postponer a disbeliever or equating him with the denier, something he had only read in this very question; perhaps the preacher's zeal carried him away, and the questioner should quietly ask the speaker for clarification without stirring clamour, and busy himself with what benefits him. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Answering those who deny the Fire after the reckoning

    A questioner asked for the answer to those denying the Fire after the reckoning — like Jehovah's Witnesses holding that after it comes either eternal life for believers or annihilation for the rest. Dr. Hatim al-Haj (fatwa no. 82870, 15 October 2010) answered that reason proves the return and reward and punishment, but their duration and eternity lie beyond reason's power of denial or proof, known only through the truthful Prophet's report; Islam is the religion whose proof is manifest and whose root does not contradict sound reason, so the details are sought in it alone — with the rest of the answer as written. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • The descent of Isa at the end of time

    A questioner asked about the return of Isa son of Maryam at the end of time. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77611, 28 January 2009) answered that the Messiah's descent is among the major signs of the Hour — 'he is knowledge for the Hour' meaning Isa's descent — and many hadiths reaching mutawatir record it, among them the two-Sahihs report of Abu Hurayra: 'by Him in whose hand is my soul, the son of Maryam will soon descend among you as a just ruler; he will break the cross, kill the swine and lift the jizya'; it is among the established tenets of Sunni creed, proven by decisive texts.

    Original page

  • Whispers of the Fire and forgiving a wrongdoer

    A questioner asked three things — saying 'that's it, I'll enter the Fire' after a sin, pardoning one who wronged him, and evil passing thoughts against his better self. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78104, 6 March 2009) answered the first two earlier; as to the third, fleeting thoughts that vanish upon reflection fall, he hopes, within pardon — and he advised him to magnify his Prophet and know his worth so such thoughts never return: read much in his sira and Shamail and come to know him better, for whoever knows the Messenger of God loves him, and whoever loves him grows in awe of him.

    Original page

  • Whisperings of the soul and God's mercy

    A psychologically exhausted questioner who prays and fasts feared his deeds were unacceptable. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 86572, 14 March 2012) answered that God pardons this ummah for what its souls whisper so long as it is not acted or spoken; that even if he committed or uttered some ill then repented, no sin is too great for repentance per the verse that whoever does ill or wrongs himself then seeks God's forgiveness finds Him forgiving and merciful; he was told to leave the whisperings, to know his Lord is the most merciful, think well of Him and never despair of His mercy — for God forgives all sins.

    Original page

  • One who dies in janaba — the common washing suffices

    A questioner asked whether one who dies in janaba needs more than the shrouding-wash. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 80552, 1 December 2009) answered that one who dies in janaba is purified by the general washing legislated for all the dead — asking God's mercy for all deceased Muslims.

    Original page

  • Caring for children with severe disabilities — seeking help

    A father caring for twenty years for a severely disabled son and daughter asked about seeking help. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 3636, 9 November 2007) answered that when the good hearts of Muslims grow too narrow to carry their sick and special-needs, he may seek help from whom he wills — provided it is not at his religion's and principles' expense nor a passage to temptation in religion; he prayed God make for him relief from his tightness, a way from his distress and ease from his hardship, and counselled abundance of 'no god but You; glory to You; I was among the wrongdoers' and of blessings on the Messenger — that his care be lifted and his sin forgiven.

    Original page

  • Doubted a discharge after wudu — the incontinence rule

    A questioner after wudu for maghrib doubted something descending from him and squeezed it out. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 79922, 10 September 2009) answered that whatever exits the two passages breaks wudu, whether urine or madhy — except one suffering incontinence, the continuous descent of these fluids: he does wudu for each prayer's time, then guards by binding a cloth and prays; what descends after that does no harm — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Discharge after wudu and blood before the period

    A woman asked whether she must redo wudu when something descends after it, and about blood before the period. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 76812, 9 November 2008) answered that whatever exits the two passages obliges wudu whatever the disagreement over some of it being pure or impure; blood descending just before the period, where it is as heralding it, joins it and takes its ruling — known by its signs — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • A viscous fluid with urine — likely madhy, not a ghusl case

    A questioner found much viscous fluid when passing water and wished to pray. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 85958, 20 November 2011) answered that one who dreams and sees fluid on waking must wash, but one who sees nothing owes nothing; what he finds at urination is most likely madhy — a thin, sticky, colourless fluid that leaves on foreplay, recalling or intending intercourse, looking and the like, coming out in drops he may not feel; purification from it is wudu and istinja, and it does not oblige the washing — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Do animals have souls or only life

    A questioner asked whether creatures — big fish and tiny ones, the butterfly, the ant, the worm — have souls or merely life. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 80536, 27 November 2009) declined the speculative question, counselling him to occupy himself with what benefits him and touches his need in worshipping his Lord, and to spare the muftis' time for questions that constitute scholarly rescue. Recorded as a deferral, not a ruling.

    Original page

  • Does supplication change destiny

    A questioner asked whether supplication changes destiny. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81834, 9 July 2010) answered that God legislated and commanded supplication — 'call upon Me, I will answer you' — and that supplication is itself part of decree: when the servant takes the lawful means and prays, that is repelling decree by decree if God wills it; it is established in the hadith that a servant may be denied provision for a sin he commits, that nothing repels decree but supplication and nothing lengthens life but piety — all inscribed in the Mother of the Book.

    Original page

  • Doubt in worship — build on the lesser, the certain

    A questioner asked about dealing with doubts in worship. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77550, 24 January 2009) answered that the rule for one who doubts a worship-matter is to build on the lesser, that being the certain — except for one whom doubt haunts till it becomes like waswasa or an illness: such a one casts the doubt off and pays it no heed — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • A doubtful discharge — purity stands until certainty

    A questioner had surgery on his nose, bled, and doubted some wetness he found. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 83917, 7 March 2011) answered that the rule is purity stands until its removal is certain — by descent of semen, intercourse and the like; as long as he is not certain the wetness is semen no washing binds him, the default being no obligation and purity until certainty removes it; and one unable to use water for illness does tayammum, a dispensation God legislated for such states — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Doubt over when the khuff-wiping began

    A questioner doubted whether he had wiped his khuffs for the noon or the afternoon prayer, and whether his prayer was valid. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 83918, 7 March 2011) answered that the rule is no wiping, building on the certain; so if he doubts whether he wiped for zuhr or for asr he begins the term from the asr prayer, the assumption being no wiping; the proof of this maxim — that what was, stays as it was, and the default is absence — is the Messenger's answer to the man who fancied he found something in his prayer: 'he is not to leave till he hears a sound or finds a smell' — as detailed.

    Original page

  • A doubt about mocking a Companion

    A questioner feared he had mocked a Companion's name or done something requiring him to re-utter the testimony, dreading his state at death. The site's sharia section (fatwa no. 78824, 12 May 2009) answered that he should put his doubt before people of knowledge to be answered so it does not settle in him; if it is whispering, he should stop, refuse its indulgence, seek refuge in his Lord, multiply good deeds, keep the company of the righteous and hold to the Quran — thereby he is safe and nothing is on him.

    Original page

  • A dream that warned of the dreamer's death

    A questioner told of a young man who dreamt he would die in a road accident, and it came to pass — did God inform him or what? Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81850, 12 July 2010) answered that it may be as he says, though they cannot assert it; the matter returns mostly to the dreamer's righteousness or lack of it.

    Original page

  • Seeing the Prophet in a dream — and seeing God

    A questioner dreamt the Prophet flying through the sky inspecting his ummah — nations in groups — and he did not look toward their group. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 23352, 21 July 2008) answered that seeing the Prophet in a dream is among the glad tidings when the dreamer sees him in the form described in the biographies and qualities books — the devil cannot take that form; his not looking toward the group may carry a reproach calling for review of one's bond with his Sunna and guidance, perhaps a neglect one is heedless of. Seeing God in a dream is possible in the scholars' view — the believer may see his Lord in varied forms matching his faith and certainty; with sound faith he sees Him only in a beautiful form.

    Original page

  • Dreams and lifespans — answer to a frightened dreamer

    A distressed questioner dreamt a dream whose reading in Ibn Sirin and al-Nabulsi grieved him. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77335, 3 January 2009) answered that the wise calls himself to account and works for what comes after death; the rule is to be in the world as a stranger or a passing traveller — morning without awaiting evening, evening without awaiting morning — whether he saw this dream or not; lifespans are in God's hand, no dream hastens or delays them, and many such dreams the interpreters read against their face, sometimes meaning a long life.

    Original page

  • Dripping after urinating — guarding and timed wudu

    A questioner suffered dripping after clearing himself of urine. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 79176, 14 June 2009) answered that one with urinary incontinence must guard himself and do wudu for each prayer's time where he knows no hour of its ceasing; but if he knows that waiting a set span after relieving himself will stop the urine, he waits that span — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Driving non-Muslim parents to church

    A questioner cited a report from the Malikis permitting a child to drive his non-Muslim parents to church when they cannot reach it themselves. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 86373, 22 January 2012) answered that the report is doubtful: the child owes his parents kindness short of disobedience, may not serve them by fetching wine since that aids sin, and has ample lawful kindness besides — spending on them befittingly while they or their co-religionists handle their unlawful wants themselves. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Supplicating to change one's fate from misery to felicity

    A questioner cited al-Tabari's tafsir that Companions and Successors used to ask God to change their fate — bringing them from written misery to felicity. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 86498, 29 February 2012) answered that everything of decree is foreknown, forewritten in the Tablet and willed, God being the Creator of all; but some decrees are determined and some suspended, and among the suspended are those hanging on supplication, charity and keeping kinship — which adorn houses and lengthen lives — God having known and written the determined, the suspended and what they hang on.

    Original page

  • Asking God for beauty of face and limbs

    A questioner asked whether one may pray for beauty of face, appearance, limbs and form, and whether God could grant it in our time. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 23301, 14 July 2008) answered that a servant may ask his Lord whatever he wishes of this world's and the next's good, so long as his prayer contains no sin and no kinship-cutting — and what he mentioned holds none of that; let him pray certain of answer, thinking well of his Lord, who is generous and bountiful.

    Original page

  • Praying for a mother's long life, and decree

    A questioner asked whether praying for his mother's long life opposes decree and whether God would lengthen it. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 82478, 8 September 2010) answered that praying for her life to be lengthened in obedience is not objectionable; some scholars explain that decrees are of two kinds — determined and suspended — and the suspended include those hanging on the supplicant's prayer, or on charity and kinship which adorn houses and lengthen lives per the hadith, all inscribed in the Mother of the Book; better than praying for long life is praying for salvation from punishment, per Umm Habiba's hadith in Muslim.

    Original page

  • A heart tracing that exposes the chest

    A woman whose doctor ordered an ECG — which exposes the chest — though she felt well asked whether to proceed. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81629, 7 June 2010) answered that exposing the awra for treatment is relaxed only under pressing need; otherwise a Muslim woman is treated by a Muslim female doctor, failing that a non-Muslim female, failing that a Muslim male doctor, failing that a non-Muslim male — so if she senses no need for it and her judgment outweighs it, cancelling the appointment is likely more pleasing to God and nearer to the sharia's rules.

    Original page

  • Performing the Eid prayer at home during the COVID crisis

    A questioner asked the ruling on performing the Eid prayer at home during the COVID crisis. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 87758, 16 May 2020) answered that the Eid prayer is among Islam's outward rites, scholars' sayings ranging between collective duty, individual duty and emphatic sunna; since the feasible does not lapse with the infeasible, the answer sets out the rulings for performing it in homes under the crisis.

    Original page

  • Eid prayer organized in cars — ruled on for the COVID closures

    A questioner asked about the proposal to hold the Eid prayer with people in their cars during the COVID closures. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 87759, 23 May 2020) answered that the Eid prayer is a sunna for the Malikis and Shafi'is, an individual duty for the Hanafis, and a collective duty for the Hanbalis; on the sunna view there is no harm in leaving the standing in it even when able — as the answer details its performance rules in the crisis.

    Original page

  • Entering the bathroom does not break the wudu

    A woman entered the bathroom while in wudu, not intending to relieve herself — to change a bottle or the like. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 79072, 2 June 2009) answered that the wudu is not broken by merely entering the bathroom; it is broken by the hadath — urine, stool, wind and the like — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Entry alone — the washing binds both spouses

    A woman asked a precise question on the spouses' janaba. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78613, 21 April 2009) answered that the washing binds on emission even without entry, and on entry even without emission; if her husband entered, the washing binds them both whether he emitted or not and whether she did or not — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Equal compensation in game-killing, intent or error

    A questioner asked on what proof the four madhhabs based their equalising of compensation between intentional and accidental killing of game in the sanctuary. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77618, 29 January 2009) answered that the proof is what he had told him: this falls under liability for destroyed property, in which intent and error are treated alike — a general principle of the sharia.

    Original page

  • A father who cut off his children — patience, prayer and lawful ruqya

    A questioner whose father left them small, married another, practised every form of estrangement — once disowning them — asked, suspecting sorcery. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21867, 28 August 2007) counselled leaving any unlawful means, seeking a lawful one, and asking help of patience and prayer; then consulting a scholar in his locality known for sound creed and straight path, versed in lifting sorcery from the bewitched with prayers and lawful ruqya — perhaps he would find his wish there, if sorcery is suspected; and he asked God to guide the father's heart to them and return him beautifully.

    Original page

  • The reality of the evil eye and envy

    A woman whose academic standing had declined asked whether the evil eye and envy are real and can reach the point of effect. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81873, 15 July 2010) answered that the eye is real — it can bring a camel into a pot and a man into a grave — yet none of its effect happens except by God's cosmic permission, as He said of magic and magicians that they harm no one except by God's leave; for telling whether an affliction is from magic or the eye there are Quran-therapists among the Sunnis with the skill — let her seek one of them, religious and competent, for this door draws many impostors, demanding care and scrutiny — praying God wipe over her with His healing right hand. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • A fateful exam and the duty to learn

    A student facing a decisive exam asked whether he must still learn obligatory knowledge, and asked the meaning of God's name, where intention sits in wudu, and the senses of knowledge, wisdom, power, hearing and sight among God's names. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78677, 28 April 2009) answered that when an issue befalls him he should refer it to a scholar he trusts in religion and learning and act on his fatwa — he need not follow one imam in all his choices; 'Allah' is the One hearts worship in love, hope, fear and desire who alone deserves worship; intention accompanies wudu's acts — entering upon it aware he intends wudu, not mere cleaning; and the meanings of knowledge, wisdom, power, hearing and sight are clear yet affirmed in a manner befitting His majesty, without likening.

    Original page

  • Excuse-holders — wudu at the time, then any prayers

    A questioner asked whether excuse-holders like the urine-incontinent do istinja and wudu at the time's end. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21935, 19 July 2006) answered that holders of purity-excuses — incontinence of urine, wind and the like — do wudu for each prayer's time: when the time enters they do wudu for it, then by that wudu pray whatever God wills them to pray until the time exits — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Eye-matter on the face — not a barrier unless massed

    A questioner asked three questions, one of them finding eye-matter on touching his face after wudu. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77973, 25 February 2009) answered that it turns on what is meant by eye-matter: if the specks in the eye are meant, they are no barrier and their presence does not spoil the wudu; if it has massed and thickened into a barrier keeping water away, its removal is required — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • The 'Iblis with the Messenger' hadith is fabricated

    A questioner asked whether the 'Iblis with the Messenger' hadith is sound, weak or fair. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78216, 14 March 2009) answered that it is a fabricated lie against the Messenger of God — the marks of fabrication evident to whoever knows the reports — so it may not be published, transmitted or attributed to him; whoever spreads it is among those who lie against him, per Muslim's introduction: 'whoever reports from me a hadith seen to be a lie is one of the liars'.

    Original page

  • The criteria of faith and takfir

    A questioner asked: since one who says or does shirk is not declared a disbeliever except under takfir's criteria — does faith too have criteria, if someone says the word of faith? Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77697, 4 February 2009) answered that the default for anyone ascribing to Islam who has not clearly engaged a nullifier is that he is a Muslim, the ruling leaving him only with certainty meeting takfir's conditions and clearing its barriers; the Prophet rebuked Usama ibn Zayd for killing a man after he uttered the testimony, alleging he said it sheltering from the sword — 'did you split open his heart?'; whoever ascribes to Islam is a Muslim, and if he engages a nullifier, the meeting of takfir's conditions and absence of barriers is examined. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Qunut in the Fajr prayer — an ijtihad matter not to be condemned

    A questioner asked the ruling on qunut in Fajr and the soundness of following an imam who insists on it. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 21987, 14 October 2012) answered that this is among ijtihad's questions in which the dissenter is not condemned, though people counsel one another with proofs; some imams of the followed schools did hold Fajr qunut — the answer detailing the ruling on following.

    Original page

  • A father suspected of praying without wudu — gentle counsel

    A questioner said doubts haunted them that their fifty-six-year-old father prays at home without wudu. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 85907, 14 November 2011) answered that the way is gentle counsel — making plain to him that wudu is broken by the hadath, that God accepts no prayer of one in hadath until he does wudu, that standing before his Lord in prayer calls for purification from both the lesser and greater hadath, careful istibra from urine, and a clean garment and body; they should repeat the counsel gently and bring him some dawa-materials explaining these principles for whoever wishes to learn more — as detailed.

    Original page

  • A feeling in the rear — certainty is not removed by doubt

    A questioner who felt something in his rear asked whether he must count it wind. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78366, 27 March 2009) answered that one who did wudu then doubts the hadath remains on his wudu until the hadath is certain — certainty is not removed by doubt, especially for one afflicted with waswasa, which is of Satan seeking to spoil his worship — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Does Islamic fiqh cover all of life

    A questioner asked whether Islamic fiqh covers everything in life, and about a doubt that had struck him concerning God's existence. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78020, 28 February 2009) answered that nothing befalls one of the people of God's religion but the Quran contains a pointer to the way of guidance in it; whatever a bound person meets in life has a ruling of God in it — known to those who know it, hidden to those who do not — and fiqh covers events either by a text naming the thing or by subsumption under a general cause or rule; as for doubt, a passing whisper is met with seeking refuge and refusal to indulge it — 'praise God who turned his plot into whispering' — while a settled deep doubt is treated at the hands of the people of knowledge and bearers of the sharia, and he advised much remembrance and Quran reading.

    Original page

  • The fitra's ways — removing barriers before wudu

    A questioner asked whether erring after seeking the truth on a matter obliges repeating. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78638, 23 April 2009) answered that a Muslim keeps to the fitra's ways — trimming the nails and removing any barrier on the wudu or washing limbs; if what passed had barred water's reaching, he repeats what was void, else no repetition — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Fluid after the washing — wudu suffices

    A questioner asked the ruling on much clear fluid descending from a woman after the washing. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 80970, 14 February 2010) answered that the fluid whose exit obliges washing is the gushing water — what leaves in a gush with desire; what descends after the washing with no arousal present obliges no washing, only wudu, and its descending in prayer requires redoing the wudu and the prayer — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • A foot ailment caused by water — khuff wiping is the way

    A questioner had a foot ailment whose cause is water, so he cannot wash them daily several times. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78210, 14 March 2009) answered that wiping over khuffs or socks is lawful where they were put on in purity — timed at a day and a night for the resident and three days with their nights for the traveller, the term counted from the first wiping — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • A foot skin-disease — wash, wipe, or tayammum in turn

    A questioner had a skin disease on his feet keeping water from them. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 79669, 15 August 2009) answered that he performs what wudu-acts he can; for the part harmed by water — if a splint covers it he wipes over that, else he wets his hand with water and wipes it; if even that harms him he does tayammum for the member — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Congratulating non-Muslim players and loyalty-and-disavowal

    A questioner asked whether Muslim footballers congratulating their non-Muslim teammates on a goal and the like mars loyalty and disavowal. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 84561, 29 May 2011) answered that congratulating a non-Muslim on a renewed blessing is unobjectionable — it belongs to the kindness and equity commanded toward peaceable non-Muslims, per the verse that God does not forbid you from those who neither fought you in religion nor expelled you from your homes, that you show them kindness and deal justly.

    Original page

  • Foreplay without emission — wudu only

    A questioner described fondling and touching his wife with desire. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77563, 25 January 2009) answered that wudu suffices him so long as he did not emit — the washing binds only on intercourse even without emission, or on emission even without intercourse; mere fondling with desire, even where madhy attends it, obliges no washing — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Visiting a fortune-teller then repenting

    A questioner asked about one who visited a fortune-teller or diviner, then felt guilt and sought God's forgiveness — must he renew the shahada? Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 84138, 3 April 2011) answered that whoever goes to a diviner and believes him has disbelieved in what was sent down on Muhammad, and whoever goes and asks without believing has no prayer accepted for forty nights; but one who slips, repents, seeks forgiveness and turns back finds God relenting and merciful and need not renew the shahada, since he did not disbelieve — his fall was of another kind — so he repents to God from it. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Attending Friday prayers and reopening the mosques — the COVID ruling

    AMJA's fatwa committee received several questions on the ruling of attending Friday and congregational prayers and on mosque administrations reopening to hold worshippers amid the COVID pandemic. The committee (fatwa no. 87757, 10 May 2020) answered detailing the rulings on all of it as the response sets out.

    Original page

  • Covering the body with water after wind — it suffices

    A questioner asked how to act when wind escapes him mid-bath. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77694, 4 February 2009) answered that covering his whole body with water after the wind's exit suffices him for wudu, the covering including the wudu-limbs among all it includes; if he wishes to redo wudu out of caution there is no harm — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Compensation for game killed by intent or error

    A questioner asked for the proof of scholars who rule compensation for game killed in the sanctuary whether intended or accidental. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77597, 27 January 2009) answered that the basis is al-Ma'ida 95 — 'do not kill game while in ihram; whoever of you kills it intentionally owes the like of what he killed in cattle, judged by two just men of you, an offering reaching the Ka'ba, or expiation feeding the poor, or fasting its equal, that he taste the upshot of his deed' — the verse obliging the penalty for the intentional; the accidental case enters by analogy on the intentional under liability for destroyed property, where the prohibition stands equal.

    Original page

  • Wearing gemstones and amulets against evil spirits

    A questioner asked about wearing gemstones — emerald, ruby, diamond — or hanging them to repel evil spirits and draw luck, and about writing verses for that purpose. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 86951, 9 June 2012) answered that hanging gemstones or anything else to ward off evil spirits is unlawful, since none brings good or repels harm but God, citing the hadiths that whoever hangs an amulet has committed shirk and that ruqya-of-that-kind, amulets and love-charms are shirk, and closing with counsel to resort to God with good opinion and earnest prayer. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • The janaba washing — its complete and adequate forms

    A questioner described doing wudu first then showering for janaba. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 76855, 14 November 2008) answered that the washing is of two kinds — complete and adequate: the complete begins with naming God, washing the hands thrice, washing what the impurity touched, doing the prayer-wudu, then scooping three scoops over the head wetting the hair's roots, then pouring water over the body; the adequate is covering the body with water together with intention — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Washing over covered spots — the Hanbali middle view

    A questioner's water could not reach all his body's parts for covered patches — is the washing valid? Dr. Muhammad Mawfiq al-Ghalayini (fatwa no. 80747, 31 December 2009) answered that the jurists differed here, the middlest and strongest view being the Hanbalis': it suffices in the stated case to pass water over the covered member and wash the remaining sound limbs — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • How to bathe after nocturnal emission — step by step

    A questioner asked how to bathe after nocturnal emission and the consequence of not bathing. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21940, 26 January 2006) answered: first clean the body of any impurity, wash the hands with soap, do wudu, then pour water over the right side then the left then the whole body — with what the answer sets out of its being obligatory for the prayer and the sin of delaying it.

    Original page

  • The janaba washing — water over the whole body

    A questioner asked whether janaba requires washing the whole body head to foot. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 79811, 29 August 2009) answered that the adequate janaba-washing is covering the entire body with water — not merely washing the area with water and soap as he described; for the complete washing he begins with istinja, does his prayer-wudu, pours water on his head thrice, then over his body — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • The phrase 'may God not change us'

    A questioner objected to the phrase 'may God not change our state', common on the tongues of those who profit from a regime or condition without regard to others. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81482, 16 May 2010) answered that his zeal and desire to relieve the distressed and reform affairs is appreciated, but his reading is one of two interpretations: the phrase also bears another — an invocation for blessings to last and not vanish, and for success in the obedience that keeps blessing and well-being — like the transmitted prayers seeking refuge from sudden wrath, the turning of well-being and the removal of blessing, per 'that is because God never changes a favour He bestowed on a people until they change what is in themselves'; and the default is to carry a Muslim's words on their best sense.

    Original page

  • Good intercession in worldly petitions

    A questioner cited a study on intercession's rulings listing examples of good intercession today — recommendations for university admission, charitable funding or public posts. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 86533, 6 March 2012) answered they had not read the study, but the examples have a sound interpretation: some Islamic universities, charities and public offices require letters of recommendation so the authority makes the right decision and invests in the right place — nothing objectionable in that, and whoever intercedes properly we hope is rewarded, per 'whoever intercedes a good intercession has a share of it' and 'intercede and you will be rewarded'. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Entering the green-card lottery

    A questioner asked whether entering the US green-card lottery — registering one's details on its site — is lawful. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 80821, 16 January 2010) answered that entering the scheme itself is unobjectionable provided the traveller to those lands is safe from trial in his religion and able to show it, and has a good intention — conveying the call, learning beneficial worldly sciences the ummah needs, or other sound purposes.

    Original page

  • Removing pubic hair, clipping nails while menstruating — no bar

    A woman asked the ruling on removing pubic hair or cutting the head's hair or nails while menstruating. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21945, 28 September 2006) answered that there is no harm in it — nothing in the proofs obliges purity for removing any of that — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Guide dogs for blind Muslims — a dispensation of need

    Islam By Touch petitioned for a fatwa for the blind Muslim community on keeping guide dogs. AMJA's Permanent Fatwa Committee (no. 87778, 14 January 2025) answered that a blind person is given leave to keep a dog to lead him in the road or assist him in some of his life-matters, this being a need measured by analogy on the cases in which the Prophet licensed keeping dogs — the hunting, crop and livestock dog; most jurists hold the permission is not confined to those three but extends by analogy to whatever keeping is a genuine need, such as the blind man's need of his dog — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • A pharmacist joining prayers routinely — concessions are not habit

    A pharmacist starting work at a pharmacy asked about joining the two prayers for his job. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 86601, 18 March 2012) answered that God made the prayer on believers a timed ordinance; joining without a legal excuse — travel, illness or rain — must not become a habit, though its occasional happening to lift hardship is unobjectionable — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Answering the claim that recording the sunna was forbidden

    A questioner cited an article claiming the Prophet forbade recording the sunna, citing the hadith 'write nothing from me but the Quran'. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 82899, 19 October 2010) answered that the article is a chain of errors and falsehoods: the ummah, early and late, agreed on the sunna's authority, countless verses indicate it and plain reason confirms it — how would the details of prayer, zakat and hajj be known from the Quran alone? God appointed for the sunna master memorisers who vetted it as assayers vet coins, fulfilling in them 'We sent down the Reminder and We are its guardians'; he reminded the questioner that this knowledge is religion — mind whom you take your religion from — and that scavenging for religious knowledge online is no path to guidance. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Hair gel does not bar the water in wudu

    A questioner asked whether gel put on the head bars water reaching it in wudu so the wudu fails. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21941, 9 February 2006) answered briefly that he does not think it forms a crust barring the water's arrival — as the concise answer states.

    Original page

  • Hair gel and cream — what bars the water, what is absorbed

    A questioner asked the ruling on hair gel and cream for the wudu — applying gel then the time comes. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78137, 9 March 2009) answered that the rule here and elsewhere: whatever stands as a barrier keeping water from the skin must be removed for valid wudu; but as far as he knows creams are absorbed into the skin after a while leaving no barrier layer, so they do not affect it — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • What hair is shaved or plucked — the fitra's rules

    A questioner asked what hair must be shaved and what plucked, for man and woman. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 23020, 20 May 2008) answered that among the fitra's ways for men and women together are plucking the armpit and shaving the pubes; forbidden for both is plucking — the eyebrows or a woman's facial hair — and forbidden the man is shaving his beard — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • The hadith of Hajj every five years — its bearing

    A questioner asked about the hadith that a servant given health of body and ease of living who lets five years pass without coming to God is deprived, narrated from Abu Sa'id and Abu Hurayra. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 76955, 27 November 2008) answered that were it sound it would mean the healthy well-off man should not leave Hajj five years — al-Mundhiri citing it in al-Targhib via Ibn Hibban's Sahih and al-Bayhaqi, and al-Hasan ibn Hayy approving it — but its use is troubled by the sound report of al-Aqra' ibn Habis asking 'every year, Messenger of God?' and hearing 'had I said yes it would have been binding — Hajj is once; beyond that is voluntary'.

    Original page

  • Emission without intercourse — the washing binds

    A questioner heard something that aroused him and semen descended. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 80134, 5 October 2009) answered that as the washing binds on intercourse even without emission, so it binds on the descent of semen even without intercourse — semen being the water that leaves at desire's height followed by lassitude; if what descended was semen the washing binds him, and if madhy then wudu and istinja — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • The pact of al-Fudul — its story and its meaning

    A questioner asked for the basis and meaning of the pact of al-Fudul. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 76805, 8 November 2008) answered that Quraysh clans gathered and covenanted that they would find no wronged person in Mecca — of its people or of outsiders entering it — without standing with him against his wronger until his wrong was restored, Quraysh naming it the pact of al-Fudul; al-Humaydi relates the two sons of Abu Bakr saying the Prophet said 'I witnessed in the house of Abdullah ibn Jud'an a pact — were I called to it in Islam I would answer; they covenanted that wrongs be returned to their owners and no wronger prevail over the wronged'. Its meaning: general cooperation in righteousness and piety is commended.

    Original page

  • The hinn and binn before Adam

    A questioner cited reports from some Companions that God created before Adam creatures called the hinn and the binn, and asked what they are. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77690, 4 February 2009) answered that scholars know God created the jinn before Adam and commanded Iblis — who was of them — to bow to Adam; he refused and was among the disbelievers. As for the binn, they had not heard of them, and he counselled him to busy himself with what benefits, since wading into questions on which no action rests is the needless exertion we were forbidden.

    Original page

  • The ruling on unlawful relations — a teaching for students of Islam

    A questioner asked Islam's ruling on homosexual relations — male or female — for people studying Islam seeking guidance. The Assembly of Muslim Jurists (fatwa no. 309, 15 July 2004) answered that the lawful sexual relation is, in principle, between a man and his wife, every form of intimacy being allowed them save anal intercourse, which is not lawful — 'those who guard their private parts, save from their spouses or what their hands own, are blameless', and 'your women are a tillage; come to your tillage as you will'; this must be taught to all seeking Islam's rules in this chapter, as the answer details. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • The ruling on homosexuality

    A questioner asked about Islam's ruling on homosexuality between men or between women. AMJA's permanent fatwa committee (fatwa no. 21822, 14 October 2012) answered that the lawful sexual relation in principle is between a man and his wife, to whom all forms of intimacy are lawful except anal intercourse; that this must be taught to whoever wants Islam and he must commit to it; that whoever later weakens and falls into a violation has the door of repentance open; and that whoever persists, his affair is left to God. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • The ruling on reading horoscopes

    A questioner asked about the sharia status of horoscopes and astrology, many around him reading 'your sign today'. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 82932, 23 October 2010) answered that inferring earthly events from celestial states is the astrologers' trade: whoever goes to a diviner and believes him has disbelieved in what was sent down on Muhammad, and whoever goes without believing has no prayer accepted for forty days; every sign births all the types they discourse about while they guess at the unseen, and he knows of no disciplined science behind it — so he should keep himself from this futility and busy himself with what benefits him. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • How the seeker learns tawhid

    A questioner asked how a seeker of knowledge learns to affirm God's oneness — 'how do I affirm it'. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77975, 25 February 2009) answered that the general profession of tawhid is realized in all Muslims — none of them but professes God's oneness and Muhammad's messengership — while the details and realities of tawhid are what must be learned, by reading the creed books: he recommended Dr. Umar Sulayman al-Ashqar's Beliefs series as useful for him, or if hard to get, his own book 'Know that there is no god but God' on his site — let him begin there and each step will deliver him to the next.

    Original page

  • Touching the husband's member — wudu, not washing

    A woman asked whether her husband's member touching her body obliges her washing. Dr. Muhammad Mawfiq al-Ghalayini (fatwa no. 81056, 26 February 2010) answered that this does not oblige washing; it obliges wudu if she intends to pray, the contact breaking the wudu — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Hypothetical fiqh questions

    Following up on an earlier question about the four madhhabs' agreement on requiring compensation, the answerer was asked more. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77698, 4 February 2009) said its basis with them is that the value of destroyed property is alike for intent and error — then asked in turn whether these questions were actual cases he lived or mere pastime: how fine it is to occupy oneself with what benefits, sparing time and effort for worshipping one's Lord and learning what has actually befallen him; what has not befallen him he should leave, for when it befalls God will grant relief at its hour.

    Original page

  • Iblis's state before his disobedience

    A questioner cited Shaykh Abd al-Hamid Kishk saying in a lesson that Satan before his disobedience — refusing to bow to Adam — had been obedient to God and known for devotions. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77578, 26 January 2009) answered that to his knowledge no reliable reports ground this; they are transmitted tales and loose narratives; what is certain is that Iblis was of the jinn and disobeyed his Lord's command, and among jinn are the righteous and those less so; busying with such matters builds little action, and every question on which no action rests is the needless exertion we were forbidden.

    Original page

  • Why Abraham is clothed first on the Last Day

    A questioner asked why Abraham is advanced before others in being clothed on the Last Day. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 83370, 21 December 2010) answered that the first of God's servants clothed that day is the Friend of the Merciful, father of the prophets, Abraham — per Ibn Abbas's hadith in Sahih al-Bukhari 'the first of creation clothed on the Last Day is Abraham the Friend' — with Ibn Hajar noting al-Bayhaqi's addition of a chair placed right of the throne; the scholars give his precedence to none before or after fearing God more than he, so his clothing is hastened as reassurance, and possibly because he was first to wear the sarawil, as recorded.

    Original page

  • Excuse by ignorance, computer games, and the heedless

    A questioner asked four things: whether a man is excused by ignorance in the fundamentals of religion when he is lazy about learning; the ruling on 3-D computer games; repeating a prayer doubted; and the meaning of 'those who are heedless in their prayer'. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78093, 5 March 2009) answered that the default is hastening to learn and teach to lift ignorance — let him busy himself with learning rather than judging the ignorant, that question being of the fitna questions whose fire he should not enter; computer play is lawful so long as the images hold no obscenity and it does not bar him from remembrance and prayer; redoing a doubted act of worship to leave the disagreement is good, the wary course being recommended — if he thought one unspecified prayer of yesterday void he repeats them all and is cleared; 'heedless in their prayer' means those who delay prayer past its time.

    Original page

  • A heavily waswasa-afflicted woman — treat the whispering as nothing

    A woman very heavily afflicted with waswasa asked the ruling on her state. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21958, 5 November 2007) answered that she should disregard this whispering and count it as though it were not, paying it no heed, and know it is of Satan to grieve the believers — it will not harm them at all save by God's leave — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • The imam joining prayers in the mosque when it rains

    A questioner asked whether the imam may join two prayers in the mosque when rain falls. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 86010, 29 November 2011) answered that when rain soaks the clothes, the concession of praying at one's lodging and joining the prayers is lawful — while counseling against dry overuse of the concession given modern means of handling weather — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Does iman increase and decrease with deeds

    A questioner asked whether the iman that increases with obedience and decreases with sin is the heart's assent and knowledge, or whether it is the limbs' deeds that grow and shrink. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 83183, 24 November 2010) answered that the heart's works vary in decrease and increase just as the limbs' works do: the prophets' assent is not like others', the assent of Companions who saw the miracles is not like that of those told later, and the prophets' humble devotion and love is not like others' — as self-evident in all intangible things like intelligence, courage and nobility.

    Original page

  • Impurity noticed on the garment after finishing the prayer

    A questioner asked the ruling for one who finds impurity on his garment after finishing the prayer. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 86588, 16 March 2012) answered that removing impurity from the worshipper's clothing and body is obligatory where remembered and possible; one who prayed with impurity on his garment forgetfully or unable to remove it has a sound prayer with no repeat owed — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Impurity on the praying body — removing it is a condition

    A questioner went to the mosque to pray and something befell him during wudu. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 85549, 20 September 2011) answered that removing impurity from the praying person's garment and body is obligatory where remembered and possible, in the clearest of the scholars' sayings — the Kuwaiti Fiqh Encyclopedia records Hanafis, Shafi'is and Hanbalis holding it a condition of valid prayer save what is pardoned, while the Malikis have two well-known positions, one counting removal of filth a sunna; so he must remove what struck him before praying, and if unable within the time he prays as he is with no make-up owed — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Urinary incontinence — its two states

    A questioner asked the ruling on urinary incontinence. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 79982, 16 September 2009) answered that incontinence is urine's free flow and failure to hold; the afflicted has two states: first, where it is continuous, never ceasing — whenever something gathers in the bladder it descends — such a one does wudu when the time enters and guards his private part with something; second, where it ceases at known hours — he waits for its hour of ceasing, as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Waiting for the incontinence's pause — even past congregation

    A questioner noted the sharia lifts hardship yet the majority's rules burden excuse-holders. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 80496, 21 November 2009) answered that incontinence is the hadath that attends all the time; if it ceases at a known hour he waits for that hour even at the cost of the congregational prayer, so long as the time does not run out — if he fears the time's exit before it ceases, he removes the filth, does wudu and prays. The answer details the excuse-holders' rules.

    Original page

  • An infant's impurity does not break the mother's wudu

    A woman asked whether her infant's impurity breaks her wudu when she handles it. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21693, 29 January 2008) answered that a nursing infant's impurity does not break its mother's wudu if she handles it; what binds her is washing the impurity that reached her, then praying — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • A boy's urine sprinkled, a girl's washed — the two rules

    A questioner asked the ruling on an infant's urine reaching the clothes. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 23261, 7 July 2008) answered that the rule is sprinkling over a boy's urine so long as he is not yet fed food — once he is fed, it is washed; as for a girl, her urine is washed in every case, fed or not; the root of it is what al-Bukhari and others narrated from Umm Qays bint Mihsan — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Whispered thoughts are pardoned

    A chronic whisperer who kept returning to the same topic in new shapes asked whether anything is on him. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78061, 4 March 2009) answered that his whispers had wearied him and they had answered before: God has pardoned this ummah for what its selves whisper, so long as it does not act on or utter it; he should not indulge the whispers but cut them at the root and say 'praise be to God who turned his plot into mere whispering' — it will not harm him, God willing.

    Original page

  • Praying for whom — a youth's sharp answer to his father

    A questioner recalled that in his early youth he once went two days without praying; his father said 'you do not pray' and, angered, he answered 'whom am I praying for?'. Dr. Walid ibn Idris al-Munaysi (fatwa no. 21850, 21 October 2006) answered that he must repent and seek forgiveness for what he said — works are rendered void only for one who dies a disbeliever, per 'whoever dies a disbeliever, their works are lost'; so long as God granted him repentance, remorse, keeping the prayer and winning back his father's pleasure, he is on good ground — with counsel to multiply good deeds as his expiation and to beware slips of the tongue, for nothing casts men into the Fire on their faces like their tongues' harvest.

    Original page

  • Insulting God in a rage — the door of repentance

    A questioner who had several times, in ignorance, cursed his Lord in anger asked how to expiate the crime. The site's sharia department (fatwa no. 21857, 13 July 2007) answered seeking refuge in God from His wrath and punishment: repent at once, beseeching and turning to Him; return to your Islam and religion before death surprises you and you meet the Almighty with this destroying sin; multiply good deeds after weeping in fear and awe, with firm resolve never to return and not to anger — the Prophet's thrice-given counsel 'do not get angry'; and know that repentance's door is open — hasten to it before the death-rattle, when neither wealth nor sons avail.

    Original page

  • Insulting the Companions — and insulting Ali in reply

    A questioner described people — young and old — cursing Abu Bakr, Umar and Uthman in the streets, and Sunnis answering by cursing Ali and the imams, asking for a fatwa forbidding it. Dr. Hatim al-Hajj (fatwa no. 21847, 24 September 2006) answered that the Shia's cursing of the caliphs and other Companions is known far and wide, many not even concealing it; but whoever of the Sunnis curses Ali — the Sunna is innocent of him, he is only of their foolish or ignorant, for the Sunnis know Ali's merit, the fourth rightly-guided caliph, whose place with the Messenger is as Aaron's with Moses; cursing any of these Companions lies between disbelief and a major sin. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Insulting religion and its effect on the marriage bond

    A questioner asked about cursing religion in the forms 'curse your mother's religion, curse your mother's creed' — whether the utterer leaves the fold, and what of his wife. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77211, 22 December 2008) answered that cursing religion as described is disbelief and a slipping from Islam's bond; the utterer must hasten at once to repent, utter the testimony, repair his past with remorse, his present with immediate desisting from the destroying sin, and his future with resolve never to return — then multiply good deeds that God may grant repentance and forgiveness; his wife's marriage need not be renewed if he declares his repentance and bears the true witness, the answer detailing why in the post-prophetic case.

    Original page

  • Intercourse after menses — washing first

    A woman said her husband wished intercourse after her menses' blood ended, before she washed. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 84269, 21 April 2011) answered that intercourse with the menstruant is lawful only once she has left the menses and washed from it, per 'they ask you about menstruation: say, it is a hurt — keep apart from women in menstruation and draw not near till they are pure; when they have purified themselves, come to them as God commanded you; God loves the repentant and loves the purified' — 'when they have purified themselves' showing the washing is conditional, as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Intercourse after the period's end, before washing

    A questioner asked the ruling on intercourse after the wife's period ended, before she washed. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81452, 10 May 2010) answered that the majority of scholars hold intercourse with the menstruant comes only after her menses has ceased and she has purified herself from it, per 'draw not near till they are pure; when they have purified themselves, come to them as God commanded you — God loves the repentant and loves the purified', the majority reading 'purified' as washed; the Hanafis permit it after the blood's ceasing once it passes the habit — as detailed.

    Original page

  • Intrusive thoughts whispering disbelief

    A questioner described intrusive thoughts he cannot repel, making him feel he is an unbeliever and driving toward a conviction that man is compelled. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 86920, 29 May 2012) answered that he had already given himself the gist: God wrongs people in nothing — a truth above every whisper, attested by reason, revelation and nature; God does not judge by His prior knowledge but by deeds that come forth, having given His servants the instruments of responsibility and sent messengers with tidings and warnings; none is punished before the proof stands; and he should not despair at such passing thoughts, for their like passed over some Companions too.

    Original page

  • Involuntary emissions — istinja and timed wudu

    A questioner had recurring impurity befall him lately. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 23177, 19 June 2008) answered that incontinence of urine, or semen leaving not in a gush with desire but involuntarily with no desire present, obliges only istinja and wudu for each prayer's time — then he performs by it whatever worship he wishes — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Praying nafl, then the iqama for the obligation — women's case

    A questioner asked whether he prays the nafl then gives the iqama and prays the obligation. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 85809, 1 November 2011) answered that the iqama belongs to the obligatory prayer: when he finishes the nafl he gives the iqama and prays the obligation — if the asker is male; a female has neither adhan nor iqama on her — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • An unregulated fluid — wudu at each prayer-time

    A questioner asked four questions, among them an unregulated descending fluid. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78086, 5 March 2009) answered that where no set time is fixed for the fluid's descending and ceasing, he owes wudu for each prayer's time; what descends after that does him no harm until the next prayer's time comes, when he renews wudu after istinja — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Menses past its course — istihada and its discipline

    A woman whose menses usually lasted seven days found it differed this month. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 85787, 30 October 2011) answered that in menstrual blood the habitual woman works by her habit and the distinguishing woman by her distinction; the utmost span of menses is a fortnight, and what passes that is istihada — she washes, guards against the blood's spreading, does wudu for each prayer-time and performs by it, between the two times, every worship requiring purity; at the next prayer-time she renews wudu, and this holds until the blood stops and matters return to her habit — as detailed.

    Original page

  • Islam and the theory of evolution

    A questioner asked whether Islam is the truth and what it says of the theory of evolution. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 87496, 27 September 2012) answered that Islam is the clear truth by the texts' testimony, and that evolution is in his view empty talk refuted by the western academies themselves, pointing to God's creating creation in stages as stated. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Al-Isra and al-Mi'raj — the bounds of denial

    A questioner asked whether the Isra and Mi'raj is religiously necessary knowledge, whether denying it is disbelief, the ruling on calling it a dream-vision, and whether Aisha, Mu'awiya and Hudhayfa really said it was by the spirit. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 23427, 31 July 2008) answered that the denier of the Isra and Mi'raj itself is a disbeliever by the Muslims' consensus, God having made it recited Qur'an; one claiming it a dream errs and misses the right but is not a disbeliever — the matter was disputed and belongs to knowledge's subtleties some common folk miss; Aisha and Mu'awiya reported it by the spirit without his body being lost — but saying 'by the spirit only' differs from saying 'a dream': they did not say dream, they said 'he was carried by his spirit; his body was not lost'.

    Original page

  • Istibra without torment — the customary measure

    A questioner after urinating cleansed with paper till he found water, squeezing until he felt pain. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81726, 22 June 2010) answered that he need not squeeze till pain — God did not bind him to torment himself: 'He has placed no hardship on you in the religion'; istibra is done by the customary measure that clears urine, not the described pain, and the paper he places serves — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Istibra within one's span — not till morning

    A questioner asked whether istibra obliges drawing out the urine's remainders even till morning. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78605, 19 April 2009) answered that the religion is ease — none contends with it but it overcomes him — so be gentle with yourself lest worship become hateful: God did not bind you to stay till morning drawing out your urine, He bound you within the limits of your capacity — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Seeking aid through the Prophet and tawassul

    A questioner cited al-Salihi's Subul al-Huda on those who sought tawassul through him. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 87059, 4 July 2012) answered that tawassul through the Prophet is among the disputed questions where the dissenter is not censured — the dispute transmitted by early and late scholars — distinguishing tawassul (asking God by the Prophet's or the righteous' standing) from istighatha (seeking aid from a creature), quoting Muhammad ibn Abd al-Wahhab's distinction as the text records. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • The pig transformed — does istihala purify it

    A questioner noted that impurity is purified by transformation (istihala) and asked about the pig whose substance transforms. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21944, 11 May 2006) answered that the pig is forbidden in itself; so the jurists' rule is that where its substance transforms into something else it is not purified and remains on its original prohibition — with differences among them over the living, the dead, part and whole — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • A woman's istijmar — tissues suffice

    A woman asked whether her istijmar differs from a man's and whether wet tissues serve for water. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 84295, 26 April 2011) answered that women are men's co-sharers — their like in rulings; if a woman's istijmar means using stones or tissues after relieving herself it is lawful without objection even where water is present, woman and man equal in this by consensus; and paper tissues may replace stones, paper being more cleansing for its softness — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Istikhara and the servant's will in choosing a path

    An architecture student — whose grades could have taken her to dentistry — chose engineering by her own wish, then doubted her choice. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 79020, 28 May 2009) answered that the servant has a will, certainly, but it does not escape God's will — 'you will nothing unless God wills it'; she should not enter the philosophical quarrel over destiny: what matters is that the servant who turns to something, seeks God's guidance over it, finds it eased and proceeds should not grieve at what follows — she spent her capacity and made her effort; striving is on her, reaching the goal is not; and should fortune fail her on this path, let her believe what struck her is good, of the kind by which God expiates slips and raises ranks.

    Original page

  • Fearing a wrong marriage for one's sister, and istikhara

    A questioner feared his sister might marry a man who would not fear God toward her, saying the engagement period is too short to know, and asked whether istikhara helps. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 82369, 28 August 2010) answered that the remedy is combining consultation with istikhara — none who consults fails and none who seeks God's choosing regrets — then pressing God in supplication to choose for her and not leave her to herself for a blink, repeating such prayers as 'O God, the matter is Yours and veiled from me; I know no affair to choose for myself, so be the chooser for me'; his certainty, he said, is that God will not abandon one sincere in resorting to Him.

    Original page

  • Order stands — istinja first, then wudu

    A questioner asked whether one may put wudu before istinja. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77593, 27 January 2009) answered that the order is required — istinja first, then wudu; nothing else serves — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • A set number for istinja — the three-wipe rule

    A questioner asked whether istinja has a set number like istijmar. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 82017, 2 August 2010) answered that the number is required only of the stones — three wipes, and if they do not achieve cleansing he adds until cleansing is had; some scholars, as the Hanafis and Malikis, hold the measure is cleansing itself — if achieved short of three it suffices, and what exceeds the cleansing is recommended — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Washing the passages at every wudu — only after relieving

    A questioner asked whether the passages must be washed at every wudu. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21569, 7 April 2008) answered that the scholars agree istinja is obligatory only on relieving oneself of urine or stool — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Traces after water-cleansing — the recommended join

    A questioner found traces of stool remaining after cleaning with water. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78797, 9 May 2009) answered that one who has a hadath of urine or stool owes istinja; joining istijmar with stones or toilet paper followed by water is the doing-well — the answer detailing how cleansing proceeds until cleanness is had.

    Original page

  • Bleeding after an IUD — istihada, not menses

    A woman had blood descend after an IUD was fitted, stop, then descend a week later outside her period. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 23057, 24 May 2008) answered that blood descending right after the fitting is outwardly a haemorrhage and istihada, not of the kind of menstrual blood — barring neither the prayer nor other purity-bound worship; the like of it is what descends after operations — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • The IUD changes the monthly habit — how to judge

    A woman flustered by having an IUD fitted asked about her rulings. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21956, 3 October 2007) answered that a woman's monthly habit changes with an IUD in most cases, casting confusing shadows on many rulings — purity, prayer, fasting, tawaf, touching the mushaf, intercourse and the like; so the blood she sees should be measured against her renewed habit and what distinction settles — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • The jester's oath and the plunging oath

    A questioner asked whether a jester's unintended oath takes effect, and whether one who promotes his goods with false swearing falls under the plunging oath (al-yamin al-ghamus). Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 84164, 5 April 2011) answered that an oath-phrase running off the tongue without intent to swear is not a binding oath and incurs no expiation — it is a vain oath per the verse that God does not take you to task for the vain in your oaths but for what you bind — except jesting about divorce, per the hadith that three things, serious or jested, are serious; and promoting goods with false oaths is a plunging oath bringing its sayer to ruin unless God forgives him.

    Original page

  • Al-Baqara 120 — the wrong gloss corrected

    A questioner cited religious speculators glossing 'the Jews and Christians will never be pleased with you until you follow their creed' to mean they would not be pleased even then. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77598, 27 January 2009) answered that the gloss is not sound — the negation in the verse has a bound at which it ends, 'until you follow their creed'; the verse did not say 'even if you followed their creed', and he asked God for sound understanding of His book and protection from deviation and slips in word and deed.

    Original page

  • The supplication on Jibril's wing — fabricated

    A questioner asked about a supplication said to be written on the inside of Jibril's wing when he raised Isa to heaven. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77634, 31 January 2009) answered that it is a fabricated lie against the Messenger of God — not to be transmitted, published, or attributed to him.

    Original page

  • The report of jinn abducting a man in Umar's time

    A questioner asked about one raqi's citing the report that jinn abducted a man in Umar ibn al-Khattab's time as proof that seeking the jinn's help is lawful. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81531, 22 May 2010) answered that this is among the questions open to scholarly consideration; the report could be true or false, and even if sound it cannot stand as an independent proof — the proof is the protected revelation, Quran and sound sunna, and everyone after may have his words taken or left; such reports are used for comfort, not as final evidence here. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Affirming that the jinni enters the human body

    A questioner cited the hadith that incantations, amulets and love-charms are shirk, touching on the question of spirit possession. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81305, 14 April 2010) answered that the questioner's intent was unclear — but if he means to deny possession, as some touched by the Mu'tazila hold that it is neither possible nor conceivable, he is wrong: a jinni entering a human body is established by the agreement of the imams of the sunna and the community; among the proofs are 'those who consume usury rise only as one the devil drives mad by touch', and the sound report that the devil runs in the son of Adam like blood, which the great scholars — al-Qurtubi, Ibn Taymiyya and others — used for the possibility of the jinn's entering the human body. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Joining the two prayers amid the COVID crisis

    A questioner asked whether joining the two prayers is lawful amid the COVID crisis. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 87732, 23 March 2020) answered detailing the joining rulings in the crisis and which excuses permit it — as the response sets out.

    Original page

  • Joining prayers for the incontinent — one wudu each pair

    One suffering urine incontinence and irregular wind asked about joining prayers on one purity. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21942, 16 April 2006) answered that he may join Zuhr and Asr on one purity and likewise Maghrib and Isha as a real joining, and that the excuse-holders' wudu joined nominally on one purity breaks when the time exits — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Drawing a cross sign in jest

    A questioner said a humorous relative had drawn a cross sign on his chest in jest and he feared it was disbelief. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 86565, 13 March 2012) answered that no sin is too great for repentance — his remorse is repentance, his fear of what he may have fallen into and his eagerness to shed its consequence are repentance; let him keep to good deeds and good company; and he taught that a man may fall into disbelief over a jest, as the hypocrites' verse 'you have disbelieved after your belief' came down — while repeating that no sin is too great for repentance. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • A worker in France — Jumu'a is among the firmest rites

    A young man resident in France, working at a company and keeping his prayers, asked about Jumu'a. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 86469, 22 February 2012) answered that the Friday prayer is among the firmest rites of the religion and must be kept by every means — the hadith warns that people must cease leaving the Jumu'as or God will seal their hearts — the answer detailing ways to secure its performance.

    Original page

  • Is Jumu'a obligatory on the prisoner — the two abodes weighed

    A questioner asked whether Jumu'a is obligatory on a prisoner. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 21990, 14 October 2012) answered that the Friday prayer is an individual duty on every legally bound adult male resident, in dar al-harb or dar al-Islam alike — no sound proof in the shari'a restricts its obligation to dar al-Islam — the answer detailing the prisoner's case.

    Original page

  • A late Jumu'a for schoolchildren — the Maliki sunset boundary

    A questioner said they currently hold a Jumu'a for young children at a late hour. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 87510, 29 September 2012) answered that the Malikis hold a doctrine on Jumu'a's last time — that it extends to sunset — quoting the Mudawwana's text, as the answer details the imams' difference over the time's beginning and end.

    Original page

  • Days in janaba in Ramadan — the prayer was the loss

    A young man had been in janaba on a Ramadan night and stayed days unwashed, asking about his fast. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 80012, 19 September 2009) marvelled at the question — he asks how janaba spoils his fast yet not how it spoils his prayer; how did days pass him unwashed and what was he doing in his prayers? Janaba does not corrupt the fast but bars the prayer's validity until he washes; he owes repentance and the make-up of the missed prayers — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Oath expiation — the order of its kinds

    A questioner heard an imam say the oath expiation offers a choice between fasting and feeding among others. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77194, 21 December 2008) answered that the choice lies among freeing a slave, feeding ten poor, or clothing them; fasting stands only for inability in those — the expiation verse of al-Ma'ida being clear: 'God does not take you for the careless talk in your oaths, but for what you bound as oaths; its expiation is feeding ten poor of your households' average food, or clothing them, or freeing a slave; whoever finds none, fasting three days'.

    Original page

  • The word of tawhid and prayer's nullifiers

    A questioner asked what the word of tawhid is, whether the testimony to Muhammad's messengersip enters it, and why the four madhhabs list scores of prayer-nullifiers while contemporaries mention few. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78105, 6 March 2009) answered that the word of tawhid covers the testimony of God's oneness and of Muhammad's messengership; fiqh books' expansiveness on prayer's nullifiers is natural — they authored exclusively in fiqh, unlike What a Muslim Cannot Ignore, a general digest of creed, fiqh and manners for the layperson, while whoever wants breadth has the fiqh books and references; as one greets his brother on meeting, he should greet him on parting; and he should learn What a Muslim Cannot Ignore within his capacity.

    Original page

  • The Kawthar basin — is it the Prophet's alone

    A questioner asked about the Kawthar basin — the Prophet's alone or does every messenger have one, and their names. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 23371, 24 July 2008) answered that al-Kawthar holds two meanings in the sharia: a river in paradise God gave His prophet — the meaning of 'We gave you al-Kawthar' as the Prophet himself glossed it in Sahih Muslim from Anas — and the Prophet's basin to which his ummah comes on Judgment Day drinking before entering paradise; for the other messengers no text reports a named basin for each.

    Original page

  • Al-Khidr — alive or departed

    A questioner asked the preponderant view on al-Khidr's life or death. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 76981, 30 November 2008) answered that every hadith mentioning al-Khidr's continued life is a lie — not one sound hadith stands for it from the Prophet; all the pro-life side can cling to are tales of men saying they saw al-Khidr — is there a sign by which a seer would know him? — and many are duped by a claimant saying 'I am al-Khidr', though such a claim may not be believed without God's proof. The sound view is that al-Khidr has met his Lord, the Qur'an and Sunna declaring it plainly.

    Original page

  • Wearing the Jewish skullcap inside the synagogue

    A questioner who lectured at a synagogue saw some of his companions put on the skullcap, and asked. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81616, 5 June 2010) answered that they erred in what they did and erred again in their reply to him: imitating those to whom such religious emblems belong is forbidden by the Muslims' consensus. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Kissing a child in the prayer — unlike carrying him

    A questioner asked whether kissing a child in the prayer is lawful by analogy to carrying him. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 86400, 27 January 2012) answered that it found no proof in the Sunna for it; what appears is the rule of prevention — it is not of the prayer's kind of acts, nor does need or pressing necessity call to it, unlike carrying — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Kissing one's wife and the wudu

    A questioner asked whether a man's kissing his wife breaks the wudu. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 82559, 17 September 2010) answered that the wudu's breaking on kissing one's wife is among the scholars' disputed points; what appears to them is that nothing of it breaks it except what comes with desire — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • A knife used on a pig — its impurity and cleansing

    A questioner asked whether a knife used slaughtering and cutting a pig is impure and how it is cleansed. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 3274, 23 July 2007) answered that once the blood leaves the knife by water or the like, the impurity has left; hence the legislation of istinja by water or istijmar by something hard like a stone, where it cleanses and removes the filth; if anything of the pig's impurity-trace remains it is not pure until that is removed — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Finding out the foetus's sex

    A questioner asked about his sister, three months pregnant, who wants to learn the foetus's sex out of curiosity — she and her husband having been told it is haram. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 86478, 24 February 2012) answered that seeking it by lawful medical means is not objectionable since the default for such a thing is permission and no sharia evidence he knows forbids it; the claimant of prohibition must produce the proof.

    Original page

  • Is information a creed

    A questioner asked whether information counts as creed, noting people with much knowledge about Islam. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77891, 19 February 2009) answered that the matter's first, axis and sum is knowledge — 'know that there is no god but God' — for action without knowledge is impossible, as knowledge without action is madness; knowledge of God, His angels, books, messengers, the Last Day and decree is creed — but this creed must then lead you to action, else it is evidence against its holder and ruin on Judgment Day: some orientalists amassed much information on Islam that never led them to faith, so it is evidence against them, and Abu Talib knew Muhammad was on truth, saying 'I have known Muhammad's religion to be the best religion of people'.

    Original page

  • Men late to the mosque — may they pray a second congregation

    A questioner asked about men late to the mosque who find the congregation finished — may they pray in a congregation? AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 21989, 14 October 2012) relayed the Saudi Permanent Committee's answer: one coming to the mosque to find the people have prayed under a permanent imam or not should pray it in congregation with his like — as the answer states.

    Original page

  • Laxity in declaring sinfulness, heresy and disbelief

    A questioner raised the spread of laxity in declaring others sinful, heretical or disbelievers over differences in questions where ijtihad is legitimate, splitting the Muslims. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81295, 12 April 2010) answered that ijtihad questions should be argued with proofs and scholarly evidence, without crowding the dissenter, and may not licence trading accusations and abuse.

    Original page

  • Learning English and computing, and the hadith on intention

    A questioner asked whether learning English and computing is lawful, and what is meant by the hadith that whoever learns knowledge meant to be sought for God's face only to gain some worldly offer will not smell Paradise's scent. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81134, 11 March 2010) answered that learning a trade to run one's living is unobjectionable — the Muslims' consensus — and does not contradict the hadith, which concerns purely sharia sciences, as in 'whoever seeks knowledge to vie with scholars, dispute with fools, or draw people's faces to himself — the Fire'; one who learns a trade to spare himself begging's humiliation, feed his family and keep kinship does a good deed intended for God's face — let him make his intention good.

    Original page

  • Leaving Jumu'a for one who prayed Eid — a dispensation, not a resolve

    A questioner asked about a shaykh's saying that one who prayed Eid on a Friday has Jumu'a lifted from him. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 87629, 22 October 2012) answered that leaving Jumu'a for the Eid-goer is a dispensation among dispensations, not a resolve among resolves — so he is not burdened with coming to the mosque twice, though he may be among those who set out to the congregational mosque — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Of the sunna is leaving the sunna — the maxim

    A questioner asked about the maxim 'of the sunna is leaving the sunna' and its soundness. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 86827, 7 May 2012) answered that the saying is an ambiguous expression, right or wrong by the speaker's intent: a recommended act may be left when doing it carries outweighing corruption — as rebuilding the Ka'ba on Abraham's foundations was left in regard for the Quraysh's recent Islam — and Ahmad and others recommended an imam leave what he deems best to conciliate those he leads; but merely leaving the sunna because it breaks people's habit is invalid, as detailed.

    Original page

  • Leaving a bank job, then unemployment

    A man who left his bank job out of fear of God and had been unemployed over a year — though he had believed God would grant him better, per 'whoever leaves something for God, God compensates him with better' — asked about it. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81748, 25 June 2010) advised more patience, good opinion of God, earnest humble supplication; to know that God withheld it only to compensate him with better, and gave him tidings of near relief, reminding him of the hadith that your Lord marvels at His servants' despair while relief is near — He looks at you lowly and despairing and keeps smiling, knowing your relief is close.

    Original page

  • The left hand for cleansing — why the right is spared

    A questioner asked whether the private parts are washed with the left or right hand after relieving oneself. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 80297, 20 October 2009) answered that the rule is using the left hand to cleanse the place of urine, stool and the like, the prohibition on using the right here being established; part of the wisdom is the right's honor — it being for the nobler doings — so it is not put to removing filth, as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Drawing a line on the mosque mat for the row's alignment

    A questioner asked the ruling on drawing a line on the mosque mat to align the row where the qibla is slanted. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 21986, 14 October 2012) relayed the Permanent Committee's answer: there is no harm in it, and if they pray there without a line there is no harm either, since a slight tilt does not hurt — as the answer states.

    Original page

  • A litany praying for named saints — a Moroccan wird reviewed

    A questioner cited the litany of Morocco's al-Adl wal-Ihsan movement praying by name for the saints — al-Junayd, al-Fudayl ibn Iyad, Bishr al-Hafi, Abd al-Qadir al-Jilani and others. Dr. Walid ibn Idris al-Munaysi (fatwa no. 2085, 10 November 2006) answered that among those named are righteous saints, straying misleaders, and some whose state is not truly known; he therefore disapproves of using this prayer — all the more since it was not the Prophet's way to keep daily litanies praying for saints or righteous men by name, and the best guidance is his guidance; the transmitted general prayer suffices: seeking forgiveness for believing men and women, and 'our Lord, forgive us and our brothers who preceded us in faith, and place not in our hearts any rancour toward the believers'.

    Original page

  • Madhy by night — the fast stands, no washing owed

    A questioner described something that stirred his desire and brought on madhy in Ramadan. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 82461, 7 September 2010) answered that madhy does not spoil the fast — especially having happened by night, fasting being by day and not by night; and madhy obliges no washing but only istinja and wudu: Sahl ibn Hanif said 'I suffered badly from madhy and washed often for it; I asked the Messenger of God and he said: wudu suffices you for it' — as detailed.

    Original page

  • Years of madhy drops — washing the member and wudu

    A questioner had suffered for years from viscous drops descending. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 82447, 6 September 2010) answered that madhy obliges washing the member and whatever of the body it touched, together with wudu — per Ali's 'I was a man of much madhy and shied from asking the Messenger of God for his daughter's sake, so I had al-Miqdad ask him; he said: he washes his member and his anus and does wudu', narrated by Abu Dawud — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Madhy incontinence outdoors — is tayammum open to him

    A questioner spends all day outdoors with madhy incontinence and finds wudu for every prayer hard. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 76784, 5 November 2008) answered that tayammum is legislated where water is lacking or unusable; the hardship licensing the dispensation is the surpassing hardship that harries its people and wearies them — ordinary hardship does not suffice; so he does wudu for each prayer as long as he can use water — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Madhy on the clothes after washing and wudu

    A questioner asked the ruling on madhy — leaving him when he thinks of intercourse — falling on his clothes after he washed his member and did wudu. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 79095, 4 June 2009) answered that madhy is the white viscous fluid that leaves at desire's wane without desire, no bodily lassitude following its exit, mostly unfelt, descending at foreplay or thinking of intercourse; it is impure — whatever of body and clothes it touches must be washed, and wudu renewed — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • The claim that the Mahdi is alive now

    A questioner asked about a circulating piece claiming the Mahdi is alive and providing and attacking its evidence. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 85679, 16 October 2011) answered that the Mahdi is a reality, not a myth — hadiths on him are sound, reaching mutawatir in meaning for some scholars, among them Ibn Masud's hadith of filling the earth with equity and justice; the hadiths fix no time except that he emerges before the Dajjal; declaring him alive now by name is guessing at the unseen and saying of God without knowledge, not to be indulged. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Looking at one's mahram women

    A questioner noted that the sharia permits a man to look at his mahram women where it is not forbidden him. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77406, 11 January 2009) answered that a man may look at what customarily appears of his mahrams in their working clothes — the hair, the neck, the chest, part of the leg and part of the arm and the like, as the household's mixing requires, without strain or hardship and without suspicion.

    Original page

  • Urinary incontinence in the Maliki school

    A questioner asked the Maliki rule for urinary incontinence. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 80544, 30 November 2009) answered that it is known of the Malikis that the mustahada is recommended wudu at each prayer without its being required; they analogised to her the incontinence-holder whose excuse attends all, most or half the time — their detail being that the incontinence does not break wudu when it persists through half the prayer-time or more — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Recourse to man-made law for one's rights

    A worker of fifteen years whose company withheld his rights asked whether he may go to the civil courts. The site's sharia department (fatwa no. 21861, 26 July 2007) answered that resorting to man-made laws is forbidden and among the major sins, judgment belonging to God's book and His messenger's sunna — yet it distinguished: one driven by need to take his due from a wronger who withholds it but by this route may proceed in litigation; mere filing is not necessarily 'referring judgment to them' when the wronged finds none to aid him but the civil court, his aim being to extract his right, not to suspend God's rule — as the answer details. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • A miserable or happy marriage and divine decree

    A questioner asked whether a marriage's misery or happiness belongs to destiny. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 82370, 28 August 2010) answered that everything God created is by decree — the wretchedness of the wretched and the felicity of the happy befell by His decree and the Pen ran in the first Book; the believer's affair is all good, gratitude in ease and patience in hardship; yet decree is no excuse for neglecting means — if the woman neglected the lawful means of choosing a partner, not choosing on the basis of religion and character or stubbornly refusing her guardians and counsellors, she should blame only herself and not reproach decree; decree is consolation, not a plea for squandering means.

    Original page

  • A woman is married for four things — the hadith explained

    A man about to marry asked for a detailed explanation of 'a woman is married for four things'. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78315, 22 March 2009) answered that the hadith is in Bukhari, Muslim and the Sunan: people's custom runs to seeking a woman in marriage for one of four traits — beauty, wealth, lineage and religion — and what befits people of honour and religion is that religion be the aim of their regard; so the Prophet urged winning the religious one and stressed it most emphatically in 'win her of religion, may your hands be dusty' — originally 'your hands stick to dust' from poverty, but the Arabs use it for reproach, emphasis and urging, as detailed.

    Original page

  • Marrying a layman of Ash'ari creed

    A questioner asked about marrying a person of Ash'ari creed who is a layman. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 85393, 1 September 2011) answered that there is no harm in marrying such a person, especially a layman, since knowledge comes by learning, and he prayed God grant him righteous company guiding him to follow the pious predecessors. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Marrying women of the People of the Book — conditions

    A questioner asked the ruling on marrying women of the People of the Book and with whom the marriage contract is written — a Muslim or one of them. Dr. Ibrahim al-Darmali (fatwa no. 21830, 27 November 2005) answered that God permits marriage to a Jewish or Christian woman provided she is chaste — protected from fornication — and the guardianship is the Muslim's over her, per 'today the good things are lawful to you, their food lawful to you and yours to them, and the chaste of the believing women and the chaste of those given the Book before you, when you give them their wages, chaste, not fornicating'; and the contract is written with the Muslim side since the contract is an Islamic one — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Official collective dua after every prayer — no basis

    A questioner asked the ruling on officials imposing a collective dua after every obligatory prayer. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 21983, 14 October 2012) answered that the collective dua as run in some mosques after the prescribed prayers has no basis indicating it in Book or sound Sunna, and the rule is leaving such things — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Celebrating the Prophet's birthday

    A questioner who learned from Sunni shaykhs that celebrating the Prophet's birthday is an impermissible innovation met objectors with interpretations. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78159, 11 March 2009) answered that the turning of some toward such interpretations away from the path of the righteous forebears should not grieve him: far and near know worship is textual, and those who perform these celebrations do so as devotion and worship — yet the virtuous generations were free of them, and they loved the Prophet more and knew his sunna and way better; as for dreams, they cannot establish a sharia ruling, especially where the virtuous generations ran otherwise — he should not dispute beyond an open argument and occupy himself with what benefits him of worship. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • The meaning of la ilaha illa Allah — the three tawhids

    A questioner asked whether the testimony 'no god but God, Muhammad His messenger' means the tawhids of divinity, lordship, and names-and-attributes, plus following the Messenger. The site's sharia department (fatwa no. 21721, 5 February 2008) answered that the testimony means just that — 'no god but God' being no rightly worshipped but God, the tawhid covering the three kinds: lordship's tawhid is the gateway and entailment of divinity's, for whoever believes God alone creates, owns, provides and manages must turn to Him alone in worship and prayer.

    Original page

  • Ordinary istibra — no straining the self

    A questioner described straining hard to istibra after urinating. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21955, 16 September 2007) answered that he should not strain himself — lest he make worshipping his Lord hateful to his soul and bring it bodily and mental illnesses; he suffices with the ordinary istibra at which the urine's ceasing prevails in his suspicion — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Menses that stops and returns within its span

    A woman said her menstrual blood comes five days, stops, then returns. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 82054, 5 August 2010) answered that if the days' total does not exceed menses' utmost span — fifteen days — all the blood she sees in that span is menses; as for the intervening clearness, the scholars have two sayings: some count it true purity, so she must wash and pray on seeing it; others count it of the menses, so she does not wash — the answer weighing between them.

    Original page

  • The sign of purity — dryness or the white discharge

    A girl asked the sign of her period's end. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81731, 23 June 2010) answered that purity is known by one of two things — dryness or seeing the white discharge; yellow or murk in the days of menses is the menses continuing, while yellow or murk outside the menses-days is nothing; on these rules, if she knows her period's days settled at seven, say, then on seeing purity by one of its signs she washes and prays — as detailed.

    Original page

  • The menstruant reading the Qur'an — the schools weighed

    A woman asked whether a menstruant may read the Qur'an from memory and the transmitted suras. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 23234, 1 July 2008) answered that the scholars disagreed: a party forbade it and annexed her to the junub person, others permitted her reading without touching the mushaf; what preponderates for him is permission for the need — menses and postpartum possibly running long — the answer marshalling the positions and their proofs.

    Original page

  • A new Muslim raising doubts in a small community

    A small community in Mexico — their mosque the state's only one — asked about a recent Muslim among them who kept raising doubts about the religion. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 83681, 3 February 2011) answered that saying flatly there are no fixed truths people know and knowledge is God's alone is wrong: they hold for certain that Muhammad is true, the Quran true, Islam true, and the Companions the masters of God's friends in this ummah, the best being Abu Bakr, Umar, Uthman and Ali; the man's excuse may be that he is a new Muslim of little reading, so they should embrace him with a broad chest, gentle manners, beautiful patience and goodly debate, as detailed. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Nifas after miscarrying a four-month fetus — the forty days

    A woman miscarried a four-month fetus for health reasons. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77517, 21 January 2009) answered that the majority of scholars hold nifas's utmost span forty days — per Umm Salama's report that the postpartum woman sat forty days in the Messenger of God's era; where the blood stops before that, purity is had — the answer detailing the nifas rulings.

    Original page

  • The rulings of a miscarried child — washing and burial

    A questioner asked the rulings of a miscarried child — washing and prayer over it. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 84578, 31 May 2011) answered that the scholars agree a child known to have lived and voiced a cry is washed, shrouded and prayed over, shrouded like an adult in three wraps; as for one that did not cry out, the measure is the breathing of the spirit into it, which the majority places after four completed months of pregnancy — one reaching that mark is washed, prayed over and buried in the Muslim cemetery; the answer details the rulings attaching to the miscarriage.

    Original page

  • The deviation of misguided sects versus other religions

    A questioner raised a ruling issued by one without knowledge touching the judgment of the misguided sects versus the followers of other religions. The site's sharia department (fatwa no. 21865, 26 August 2007) answered that the deviating sects' deviation is not like that of other religions' followers, for they remain of the qibla-people in general — except the inward hypocrite, or one specifically known to have engaged a certain nullifier; and scholars' settled position is that the followers of the other sects are not covered by one ruling — distinguishing among them is required; it faulted the man who dared a fatwa without knowledge: had the Prophet's 'the cure for incapacity is asking' not reached his ears? Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Work that keeps one from Friday prayer

    A questioner cited the sound hadith that whoever misses three Fridays without excuse has his heart sealed, and asked whether the same holds when earning a living is the cause. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 82632, 20 September 2010) answered that Friday prayer must be kept up and not abandoned, inside and outside Muslim lands alike — the Muslim is bound by piety wherever he is; a job that forces him to drop Friday is no place to stay: his remaining in it should measure his need of it while he keeps looking for an alternative and expends his effort to move at the first ability.

    Original page

  • Attending a brother's wedding in a mixed hall

    A veiled young woman asked whether she may attend her brother's wedding in a mixed hall possibly holding objectionable things. Dr. Walid ibn Idris al-Munaysi (fatwa no. 1873, 8 December 2006) answered that men and women gathering in one place is not forbidden so long as no seclusion occurs between a single man and a single unrelated woman with no third in a closed room, and so long as the gathering does not lead to forbidden acts such as women's display and soft speech or whatever stirs temptation; if the party is free of objectionables there is no legal bar to attending even mixed, and if some objectionables are present, attending with the intention of advising and inviting them is governed by intentions — with a caution to be careful.

    Original page

  • More than three washings — disliked, not voiding

    A questioner had heard Ibn Baz's fatwa on exceeding three washings in the wudu acts. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77580, 26 January 2009) answered that the majority of scholars hold exceeding the three times in wudu's acts disliked — contrary to the Prophet's guidance — though it does not void the wudu; al-Darimi reported of some that they did it approvingly — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • A mother who curses religion unknowingly

    A sixteen-year-old whose loving parents have divorced twice asked about his mother, who curses religion not knowing it leads to disbelief. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 85782, 28 October 2011) praised his dutifulness, urged him to persist in advising them and to make clear the gravity of cursing religion as a nullifier of Islam; as for the past, done in ignorance of its ruling, he hopes it does not affect the marriage between them — but letting the state continue ruins their world and hereafter, so he should be among their counsellors and tend their hereafter as they tended his childhood world. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • The successive guardians before and behind

    A questioner asked about Ibn Abbas's reading of the 'successive guardians' who keep a servant by God's command, and how guarding works when the matter is already written. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 86511, 2 March 2012) answered that the meaning, plainly, is that God decreed causes in the universe and made a cause for everything: He made the guardians a cause of preservation, as He made the angels a cause of victory at Badr though He could have granted victory Himself without causes — and as He told Maryam to shake the palm trunk though He could have sent His provision without any cause.

    Original page

  • Repeating Jumu'a or the Eids in one mosque — by need only

    A questioner asked the conditions permitting multiple Jumu'a or Eid prayers in one mosque. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 21985, 14 October 2012) answered that the rule is the Jumu'a's unity in the congregational mosque; if it is too small for its people, multiplying it is lawful without harm — to the measure that answers the need and achieves the benefit — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • The mushrik and the kafir — al-Ma'ida and al-Baqara reconciled

    A questioner asked the precise difference between the mushrik and the kafir, and how to reconcile al-Ma'ida's permitting women of the People of the Book with al-Baqara's forbidding marriage to the idolaters until they believe. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77277, 28 December 2008) answered that al-Ma'ida is among the last revealed, and its permitting Book-women despite shirk's meaning holding in them makes it a specification of al-Baqara; some scholars reconcile another way — the People of the Book, though the meaning of shirk holds in them, are not the ones this name turns to unqualified: it turns to those who hold no heavenly religion, as in 'the disbelievers among the People of the Book and the idolaters are in hellfire forever'.

    Original page

  • The Muslim who takes his own life

    A questioner asked whether a Muslim suicide equals the disbeliever in punishment — eternal fire with no exit. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 80094, 30 September 2009) answered that suicide is among the gravest major sins, with severe warnings — Muslim's report that whoever kills himself with an iron will pierce his belly with it in hellfire forever, and God's word about the wounded man who slit his hand, 'My servant hastened to Me with his soul; I have forbidden him Paradise'; yet suicide is not disbelief expelling from the community — it is among the major sins within God's will on Judgment Day, forgiven if He wills or punished if He wills — and he told of al-Tufayl ibn Amr al-Dawsi dreaming of one covering his hands, for whom the Prophet prayed forgiveness. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • The mustahada — her state bars nothing

    A questioner asked whether intercourse with a mustahada is lawful where her bleeding ran four months. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 80070, 26 September 2009) answered that istihada does not bar what menses bars — prayer, touching the mushaf, intercourse and the like are lawful to her, provided she guards herself at prayer lest she soil her place of prayer and does wudu for each prayer's time — the answer detailing the mustahada's rulings.

    Original page

  • The successive guardians before and behind — causes in creation

    A questioner asked the meaning of 'he has successive guards before him and behind him who guard him by God's command' with Ibn Abbas's report that they are angels. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 86502, 1 March 2012) answered that the sense, simply, is that God decreed causes in creation and set a cause to everything — making the successive guardians a cause of protection, as He made the believers' angels a cause of victory at Badr, though He could have granted victory Himself with neither angels nor causes, and as He bade Maryam shake the palm trunk though able to bring His provision without causes.

    Original page

  • Saying 'my heart tells me God's pleasure and anger'

    A questioner asked about the saying 'I know when God is pleased with me and when angry — my heart is my guide'. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81395, 1 May 2010) answered that uttering it unqualified is open to question: it is sound in one respect — that sin is what wavers in your breast and you hate people to see, per Muslim's hadith 'righteousness is good character, and sin is what wavers in your breast and you hate for people to see', and Ahmad's 'righteousness is what the soul rests in and the heart is at peace with, sin what the soul does not rest in even if the muftis give you fatwa' — and he detailed the other respect in which it fails. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • The evil-prompting soul's whispers in creed

    A questioner asked whether the evil-prompting soul whispers in creed-matters as the devil does. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 76697, 25 October 2008) answered that the soul may whisper whatever harms, grieves and saddens a person — in actions or beliefs alike; such whispers the devil aims to grieve the believers and sour their worship of their Lord, so she should cast them off, seek God's refuge from them, give them no heed, and fortify herself with much remembrance, Qur'an-reading, pre-dawn prayer, frequent voluntary fasting, avoiding solitude and bad company.

    Original page

  • Naming an individual to paradise or fire

    A questioner asked the Sunni creed on a disbeliever known to have died in disbelief. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21695, 29 January 2008) answered that the general ruling is that one who dies in disbelief is in the Fire — but that does not require judging a named individual or testifying him to the Fire, and likewise paradise: none may be testified to paradise or fire except one God witnessed to in His book or His messenger in the sound sunna; the ummah testifies the people of faith generally to paradise and the disbelievers generally to the Fire, for what counts is the endings.

    Original page

  • The meanings of the names and attributes are known, their how is unknown

    A questioner asked whether the meanings of God's beautiful names and high attributes — as we grasp them through the scholars' explanations and language — exhaust their sense. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 80531, 25 November 2009) answered that in the names-and-attributes chapter the rule is that their meanings are known to people of learning and insight, while their modalities are the unknowable that no human can reach the essence of — the meaning is known, the how is unknown.

    Original page

  • Treating binding magic with God's beautiful names

    A questioner described a method for treating 'binding' magic by writing certain of God's beautiful names in a set pattern. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81529, 22 May 2010) answered that he knows no proof establishing its soundness or benefit — such things rest on experience, provided they involve no shirk: incantation is unobjectionable so long as it is not shirk and involves no disrespect to the mushaf or any part of the remembrance. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Naming a child with one of God's names

    A questioner asked the ruling on naming a child with one of God's beautiful names such as Ahad, and whether a forbidden name must be changed. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81904, 19 July 2010) answered that naming with a name God kept for Himself — like al-Rahman or al-Khaliq — is not permissible; the Prophet changed such names when they occurred, turning al-Jabbar into Abd al-Jabbar and al-Hakam into Abdullah, and in the Quran stands 'do you know of any namesake for Him' — no equal deserving such a name. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Patriotism and nationalism

    The Assembly of Muslim Jurists of America (fatwa no. 21817, 14 October 2012) answered that 'patriotism' and 'nationalism' are ambiguous terms: if they mean the natural longing a Muslim feels for his homeland or people, there is no harm in it and no blame on those who have it — provided it does not carry him into doing what is forbidden or abandoning a duty; but if it means supporting one's people in their injustice and falsehood, that is the partisanship and call of jahiliyya against which the texts warn.

    Original page

  • The one the call never reached, on Judgment Day

    A questioner said that one who dies outside Islam today having never heard of it — or heard only lies about it — has his account with God, and was challenged. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 80442, 11 November 2009) answered that God punishes no one until the call has reached him and the argument established — 'We never punish until We send a messenger'; one the call never reached who sought guidance but could not know it is measured by the people of the interval among the four who present their plea on Judgment Day, when God kindles a fire and orders them to enter — whoever obeys finds it cool and safe, whoever disobeys is cast on his face; and he cited the hadith of the four: the deaf man, the simpleton, the senile, and him who died in the interval. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • The fate of one who died without hearing of Islam

    A questioner asked about one who died a non-Muslim never having heard of Islam, or only lies and forgeries against it — paradise or fire? Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 80434, 10 November 2009) answered that such a one's case is that of the people of the interval: he will be tested on the plain of Judgment Day — God kindles a fire for them and commands them to enter; whoever obeys finds it cool and safe, whoever disobeys enters the Fire — God best knowing what they used to do. The chapter holds a group of hadiths to this meaning, which al-Hafiz Ibn Kathir cited at 'We never punished until We sent a messenger', judging some of them sound as other scholars stated. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Remaining remnants of jahiliyya ⁦(tattoos and jewellery on new Muslims)⁩

    A questioner asked about new Muslims who retain remnants of jahiliyya such as tattoos — must they remove them — and about rings, bracelets and earrings on different parts of the body. The Assembly of Muslim Jurists of America (fatwa no. 21820, 14 October 2012) answered that tattooing is prohibited in the sharia and should be removed by whoever can without harm or damage, and where impossible it falls under pardon and the lifting of hardship, since God charges no soul beyond its capacity and Islam effaces what came before; that women's wearing of gold is lawful within the customary and without imitation, while men are forbidden gold except a silver ring, and anything beyond that remains under the original prohibition unless need calls.

    Original page

  • No istinja for wind — it is not even legislated

    A questioner asked to verify a saying he had read about cleansing after wind. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81337, 19 April 2010) answered that a previous fatwa had covered it: istinja is not obligatory for passing wind — indeed it is not legislated at all; some scholars hold that whoever does it believing it prescribed commits an innovation, istinja belonging to urine, stool and the like requiring cleansing — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • No istinja where nothing exited — wind only breaks wudu

    A woman asked whether she must enter the bathroom before wudu, and whether entering it while in wudu calls for istinja. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78563, 14 April 2009) answered that istinja is required only of urine, stool, madhy and the like of cleansing-obliging discharges; where nothing of that exited and all there was is wudu's breaking on wind, only wudu binds — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Falsehood has no logic

    A questioner brought a forum piece reasoning about the misguidance of the jinn and their polytheists in terms of their 'logic'. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81567, 27 May 2010) answered that he is, by such premises, judging the error of the jinn and polytheists by logic — and when has the straying had logic? Did cow-worshippers or Buddha-worshippers or devil-worshippers have one? God bred many of jinn and men for hell — hearts that do not understand, eyes that do not see, ears that do not hear — so they will say on Judgment Day 'had we listened or reasoned we would not be among the people of the blaze'; let him leave this logical indulgence about them — falsehood has no logic, only whim, bewilderment and confusion. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Witr prayed early, then tahajjud — no two witrs in a night

    A questioner described most brothers and sisters at their mosque praying tarawih, doing witr with the imam early, then holding tahajjud at night's end. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 87276, 11 August 2012) answered that there is no harm in this form — stressing there are no two witrs in one night: who prayed witr early does not repeat it late, and one attending tahajjud who wishes to stand witr with the imam voids his earlier one — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Attending a non-Muslim mother's funeral

    A recent convert whose Christian mother died asked whether he may join her funeral, which passes through the church before burial. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 80757, 4 January 2010) answered that attending a non-Muslim's funeral is unobjectionable where a ground like kinship calls for it, so long as he keeps clear of the idolatrous rites within it — the precedent being that the Prophet ordered Ali ibn Abi Talib to bury his father though he died outside Islam.

    Original page

  • The nullifiers of faith and their consequence

    A questioner asked what the nullifiers of faith are, what follows for one who nullified his faith, and whether a Muslim's prayer is valid while his faith is voided. The site's sharia department (fatwa no. 21863, 14 August 2007) answered that the nullifiers are faith's corrupters, invalidators and frustrators — faith is nullified by apostasy as wudu is by ritual impurity; the chief ones: shirk in lordship, shirk in divinity, shirk in the names and attributes, and objecting to, holding oneself above, denying, rejecting, mocking or ridiculing the sharia's rulings; the one who nullifies his faith leaves the community — no prayer or deed of his stands until he renews his faith. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Swearing by 'haram' over one's wife — zihar or oath expiation

    A questioner had sworn by 'haram' on his wife that he would not go to his family's house except once. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77408, 11 January 2009) answered that in his case, if he meant to render his wife forbidden to himself upon the act, he owes the zihar expiation — freeing a slave, or fasting two consecutive months, or feeding sixty poor; if he did not mean her forbidden but meant to bar her from the act — it being haram for him, and she is not to do it — the oath expiation applies: feeding ten poor a day's or night's staple, or clothing them. The matter returns to his intention — affairs rest on the preponderant, so act on what outweighs in his judgment; beyond that is pardon, God willing.

    Original page

  • What a Muslim may not be ignorant of — research guidance

    A questioner needed to prepare a study fixing what a Muslim may not be ignorant of across the sharia-sciences' chapters — fiqh, creed, thought and dealings. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 527, 5 February 2005) gave him leave, asking God's guidance for both, and counselled going back to the compendia of fiqh gathered by trustworthy scholars, extracting their cream as his material, then ordering it on a method he approves; best he have a sharia supervisor to guide and help him if new to writing — pointing out knowledge is half of knowledge.

    Original page

  • Organ donation after death

    A questioner asked about the permissibility of donating one's organs after death. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 82987, 29 October 2010) answered that there is no harm in bequeathing some of one's organs after death to save the lives of the sick and afflicted, provided the specialists' assessment makes benefit likely; and that one's heirs may make that donation on one's behalf if one dies before bequeathing it.

    Original page

  • The conditions of post-mortem organ donation

    A questioner asked the ruling on organ donation. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 82446, 6 September 2010) answered that there is no harm in organ donation after death where benefit to the recipient is probable under the medical standards agreed among specialists, provided the deceased consented before death, or his heirs consent after it, or the Muslims' governing authority approves where the deceased is unidentified or heirless — the meaning, he noted, of resolutions issued by the fiqh academies and senior scholarly bodies across the Muslim world.

    Original page

  • Outer contact with neither entry nor emission — no washing

    A questioner asked whether spouses' outer contact without entry obliges the washing. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 80361, 28 October 2009) answered that washing binds on entry even without emission, and on emission even without entry; but where neither happened — mere contact from outside with no entry and no emission — no washing binds, as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Washing the outside suffices — no probing inside

    A questioner asked whether washing the rear from outside suffices for stool while a trace remains inside. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77983, 25 February 2009) answered that washing is for the outside and covers part of the inside incidentally; what lies beyond that is not required — it is of the overreaching we were forbidden — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Years of prayers without the obligatory washing

    A young man had masturbated for three years without knowing washing was obligatory, and prayers had passed over him unwashed. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 83983, 13 March 2011) asked God's forgiveness for his neglect in learning — living among Muslims with the means of learning open and scholars plentiful, he ought not to have neglected learning what he may not be ignorant of in worship, and the Prophet said 'purity is half of faith'; as for the prayers that passed for want of the washing, he owes their make-up — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Past prayers on a mistaken timetable — valid for the effort made

    Muslims in Edmonton, Alberta asked about prayers already performed on locally calculated times. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 87506, 28 September 2012) answered that past prayers whose times they exhausted their means to fix and strove over are sound God willing, whether they matched the real time or not — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Paying taxes to the host state

    A questioner asked about his Egyptian relative living in America, whom some fault — even deeming him an enemy — for paying taxes to a government with hostile positions. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 79064, 1 June 2009) answered that residing outside Muslim lands is judged person by person, per circumstances: one able to show his religion and safe from trial may live where he wills — the lands are God's and the servants God's — with a good intention of seeking knowledge, earning a living or fleeing with his faith; as for taxes, they return as services to their payers, and what is spent from them in corruption belongs to the weighing of benefits and harms and the entangling of the two in times of trial, as detailed. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Pen ink is no barrier — the wudu stands

    A questioner asked whether wudu is valid with dry pen ink on his hand. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21934, 11 September 2005) answered that ink is not an insulating layer and does not bar the water's arrival; so the wudu is sound and the prayer sound — as the answer states.

    Original page

  • Permanent residence outside Muslim lands

    A questioner asked about permanent residence in foreign lands, citing scarce salaries in Muslim states and the ease of performing duties anywhere. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78512, 10 April 2009) answered that residing abroad to broaden provision is unobjectionable for one able to show his religion and safe from trial in it; the Assembly has a resolution on residence outside Muslim lands treating the question in its various forms — to be found on its site under Resolutions and Statements.

    Original page

  • God's power over all things — will and power together

    A questioner raised the puzzle of God's power over all things and the problems built on it. The site's sharia department (fatwa no. 21724, 5 February 2008) answered that God is able to do all things — provided the thing is willed by God, since an act takes place by will and power together: power alone does not suffice if its owner does not will the act, nor will alone if its owner lacks power; will and power must concur.

    Original page

  • Practising law — lawful advocacy

    A questioner asked the ruling on working as a lawyer. Dr. Walid ibn Idris al-Munaysi (fatwa no. 902, 7 November 2005) answered that advocacy is lawful in the Islamic sharia, belonging to delegation in litigation — which the jurists of the four madhhabs expressly permit; a Muslim may work as a lawyer to aid the wronged and extract their rights, provided he holds enough knowledge of the sharia to bar him from cooperation in sin and aggression; and it makes no difference whether he pleads before Islamic, foreign or civil courts — what counts is the lawfulness of referring judgment in the case itself, not the place of pleading.

    Original page

  • Prayed in impurity, forgetting — the prayer stands

    A questioner asked about one who prayed with impurity in his garment. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 79623, 11 August 2009) answered that removing impurity from the praying person's garment and body is obligatory where remembered and possible; one who prayed in impurity having forgotten, or unable to change his clothes — his prayer is valid and nothing of it is repeated, praise God for His widening — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Prayed forgetting a state of janaba — the prayer is repeated

    A questioner did wudu for fajr and prayed, forgetting he was in janaba, then washed that morning. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 85472, 10 September 2011) answered that one who prays then learns after his prayer that a greater or lesser hadath lay on him must purify himself of it and repeat the prayer, per the Prophet's 'God accepts no prayer without purity'; and the janaba-washing is valid only with intention at the majority — Ibn Qudama in al-Mughni counts intention among purification's conditions; the answer details repeating the prayer and the correct washing.

    Original page

  • Praying in a cramped cell holding a toilet — permitted

    A questioner noted that most prison cells are cramped with the toilet inside — is prayer lawful there? AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 21993, 14 October 2012) answered that there is no harm holding the prayer in such a room, striving to avoid impurity as far as possible — God tasks no soul beyond its capacity — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • The prayer for one with intellectual disability — duty follows comprehension

    A questioner asked the prayer's ruling for one bearing intellectual disability — impaired in his faculties. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 86197, 22 December 2011) answered that so long as he comprehends address and grasps the meaning of command and prohibition, keeping the prayer is required of him; his caretaker should strive to teach and habituate him to it as possible, counting the reward in that — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Praying behind an innovating imam in Europe

    A Muslim resident of a European country who moved next to a mosque prayed its five prayers behind two imams trained in particular schools. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21853, 29 January 2007) answered that whoever's prayer is valid for himself is valid for others, and a Muslim's prayer stands unless he clearly engages a nullifier of Islam expelling him beyond dispute; leaving prayer behind innovators or sinners is of the order of disciplining them and warning against their sedition, not because the prayer itself is void — the forebears did not declare individual Jahmites disbelievers though they called some of their tenets disbelief or shirk; so if prayer behind innovators can be left without a greater corruption, it should be — guarding the sunna and deterring the innovator and the commonalty. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Praying for beauty of form

    A questioner asked whether a Muslim may pray for beauty — improvement of his form — if his nose is large or his head crooked. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 23368, 23 July 2008) answered that a servant may ask his Lord whatever carries no sin and no kinship-cutting and is not among the rationally impossible; seeking improvement of form is none of those, and when his Lord wills a thing He carries it out — but he reminded him that beauty is not in the physical alone: what settles on a face of faith's bloom and piety's light is a beauty the limpid-souled perceive, compensating its owners for whatever lacks elsewhere; he asked God to grant him beauty of form and of character and contentment with what he was given.

    Original page

  • Praying in a mosque built with unlawful funds

    A questioner asked about praying in a mosque built from money in which lawful and unlawful funds were mixed, such as riba income or proceeds of prohibited activities. The Assembly of Muslim Jurists of America (fatwa no. 21823, 14 October 2012) answered that in principle the prayer in such a mosque is valid, the sin of the unlawful gain resting on its earner — unless mosques were built entirely from the money of those involved in illicit earnings and boycotting prayer there is intended as censure reasonably hoped to turn them back to the right, in which case there is no harm, so long as it does not lead to abandoning Friday and congregational prayers.

    Original page

  • Finding Arabic hard — may he pray in another language

    A questioner found learning the prayer in Arabic hard — may he pray in another language? AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 21997, 14 October 2012) answered that the prayer's obligation never lapses, and duty reaches only within capacity — 'God tasks no soul beyond its capacity' and 'when I command you a thing, do of it what you can' — the answer detailing the case of one unable to manage Arabic.

    Original page

  • Praying in shoes — lawful, with a note on today's mosques

    A questioner asked how the sunna of praying in shoes is clarified. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 21984, 14 October 2012) answered that there is no harm in praying in shoes — for the command to differ from the Jews who do not pray in their sandals — but the mosques in the Prophet's day were not carpeted as they are today, the answer weighing present-day mosque cleanliness.

    Original page

  • Praying seated or in a car — the standing pillar and its exemptions

    A questioner asked about praying in a car. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 87593, 16 October 2012) answered that standing is a pillar of the prayer — 'stand to God in devotion' — so one unable to stand prays seated, and one unable to sit prays on his side, citing the hadith of Imran b. al-Husayn — as the answer details the rulings for the unable and the traveler.

    Original page

  • The presumption of purity — no checking demanded

    A questioner asked two questions about tracking impurity and purifying. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21938, 23 November 2005) answered the first: he is not tasked with it — the presumption is purity unless he is certain an impurity needing cleansing exists; the second answered the post-purification ruling — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • The prison-appointed imam — accepted if qualified

    A questioner asked whether imprisoned Muslims must name the imam who leads their prayers. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 21992, 14 October 2012) answered that if the prison administration appoints an imam meeting the imamate's conditions, accepting him is unobjectionable; if it chooses for them one unfit, they may point that out and set out the qualities required in their leader — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • The faith of the Prophet's parents — a question best left

    A questioner raised the view that the Prophet's ancestors and parents were on Ibrahim's religion, monotheists, citing 'and your going about among the prostrate'. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77070, 9 December 2008) answered that the preponderant view is otherwise, and advised him not to split words over this question and its like — the dispute around it stirs souls' rancour and nothing of action rests on it; he feared wading into it was the needless exertion we were forbidden, and counselled occupying oneself with what benefits.

    Original page

  • Prostate congestion and recurring madhy — the excuse-holder's rule

    A young man with prostate congestion described recurring madhy discharge. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 80865, 25 January 2010) answered that people of excuses whose fluids descend intermittently are looked at case by case: if a time can be fixed in which the fluids do not descend and prayer can be performed, they wait for it; else they do wudu for each prayer and perform it — what descends after the wudu does no harm. The answer details the rulings of incontinence-holders.

    Original page

  • Protesting a speaker, by what is good

    A questioner asked about what Muslim students did during a lecture by the Israeli ambassador Michael Oren at UC Irvine. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81116, 9 March 2010) answered that enjoining good must itself be good and denouncing wrong should not be done with wrong; dawa may be harmed by what he described more than it benefits; these societies have their own channels for conveying a message and registering protest, and stepping outside them puts the actors in the circle of aberrance and notoriety in the public sense of the very people they want to reach — he hoped they would review themselves, consult one another on what is right, and correct their standing for the next round. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Facing the qibla from a locked cell — a condition of validity

    A questioner knew facing the Ka'ba is required but is in a locked cell unable to tell the direction. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 21995, 14 October 2012) answered that facing the qibla is obligatory in the prayer, a condition of its validity — 'from wherever you came out, turn your face toward the Sacred Mosque; wherever you are, turn your faces toward it' — the answer setting out the qibla's direction in America and how to seek it.

    Original page

  • Dedicating congregational night prayer to supplicate for Syria and Palestine

    A questioner asked whether congregational night prayer may be dedicated to aiding Syria, Palestine and the Arab Spring, supplicating for them with the imam. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 86575, 15 March 2012) answered that aiding the Muslim is a duty, advising gatherings to support their brothers in Syria by every kind of aid — publicizing their cause, supplication, collecting donations to console and back them, and drawing near to God by standing part of the night — as the answer details the bounds of collective supplication in it.

    Original page

  • The Qubaysiyyat — the standing committee's fatwa on them

    A commenter objected to the shaykh's ruling on the Qubaysiyyat, claiming its material came only from the Ahbash. Dr. Hatim al-Hajj (fatwa no. 21832, 26 June 2006) answered that what was said of the Qubaysiyyat is not what the Ahbash alone disparage them with — though enmity exists between the two groups — for the Saudi standing committee for ifta issued fatwa no. 16011 dated 18/5/1414 AH against them, the committee having no link to the Ahbash; the answer reproduces its text. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Is qunut legislated for epidemics — the schools weighed

    A questioner asked whether qunut is lawful for epidemics. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 87737, 25 March 2020) answered that most jurists hold the qunut of calamities legislated to repel harm and lift affliction, and the Hanafis, Shafi'is and some Hanbalis hold plague among what qunut is made for — the answer detailing its places and manner.

    Original page

  • The claim that the Quran was distorted

    A questioner asked AMJA's view of reports alleged to affirm the Quran's distortion, and the status of a scholar who says the Quran is distorted — whether he counts as a disbeliever. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 82168, 13 August 2010) answered that God undertook the Quran's preservation — 'We sent down the Reminder and We are its guardians' — and the whole ummah agrees on its preservation and immunity, that it is what lies between the covers of the mushaf which Muslims pass down and recite east and west; whoever claims it is distorted while of sound mind has cast off the noose of Islam from his neck. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Reading the Qur'an during menses — by heart or screen

    A woman asked whether the Qur'an may be read during menses — from memory or off a computer. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81415, 5 May 2010) answered that there is no harm in reading the Qur'an from memory without touching the mushaf during menses or postpartum, both being in God's hand and possibly long, the woman suffering if she forsook reading through that span; the Assembly of Muslim Jurists of America issued a resolution at one of its sessions permitting it — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Numerical analysis of the Qur'an — learn first

    A questioner offered numerical analyses of the Qur'an — counting cows, fat and lean — linking them to the zakat of cattle. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 2644, 14 February 2007) thanked him for his care for the Qur'an and his pondering it, and counselled leaving such analyses for now: the approach needs tools to be acquired first, then analysis and interpretation may follow; let him seek knowledge from its sources at its people's hands and busy himself with that at this stage — once he holds the tools of inquiry and interpretation he will himself discover the risks and overreach in such analyses.

    Original page

  • Reading the Quran over Zamzam water for healing

    A questioner asked whether the Quran may be read over Zamzam water for healing. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 85936, 17 November 2011) answered that it joins two blessed remedies, each attested as healing — citing the verse that the Quran is healing and mercy for believers, the hadiths that Zamzam water is for whatever it is drunk for and is a cure for illness, and Ibn al-Qayyim's report in Madarij al-Salikin that he would recite al-Fatiha over a cup of Zamzam and find in it benefit he had not known in medicine. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Opening the mushaf for guidance — sortilege, not consultation

    A questioner described his habit when a problem comes: opening the mushaf at random and taking the verse his eye lands on as God's answer. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21852, 16 December 2006) answered that it is true the worshipper converses with his Lord in prayer and finds God's command and prohibition in the Qur'an — but sortilege with the Qur'an in the manner described has no basis; it belongs to the order of divining by arrows, a bid'a among innovations and a wrong among wrongs.

    Original page

  • The Qur'an's inimitability and the book's bounds

    A questioner cited the challenge-verses — no jinn or man can produce the like of the Qur'an or even a surah of it. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77583, 26 January 2009) answered that the ummah agreed early and late that the Qur'an is what lies between the mushaf's two covers, opening with al-Fatiha and closing with al-Nas, and that mankind cannot produce its like nor a surah of it, though they backed each other; the extremists alleging extra surahs never claimed to have made them themselves but alleged they were from God — a separate matter in which they lie, its falsity plain by the ummah's consensus. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • The Qurashi condition in the supreme imamate

    A questioner asked whether Qurashi descent is a condition of the supreme imamate and how that fits justice and human equality. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 3263, 22 July 2007) answered that the texts establish the Qurashi condition; it is no preferring of their sinners or commoners over other Muslims but a preferring of their religious and capable over others — that is God's bounty given to whom He wills. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Deliberate eating or drinking in Ramadan — expiation

    A questioner noted that most scholars hold that one who deliberately breaks a Ramadan fast by eating or drinking owes only make-up, expiation being specific to intercourse. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77696, 4 February 2009) answered that scholars indeed differed: the Shafi'is and Hanbalis require no expiation except for intercourse, it being the text's specific ground; the Malikis and Hanafis require it for deliberate breaking whether by food, drink or intercourse, all three equal in prohibition; the question lies in ijtihad, and nearer to the sharia's aims, he held, is confining expiation to breaking by intercourse.

    Original page

  • The call to Sunni–Shia rapprochement — its political and creed senses

    A questioner — having read Shiite books with grave notions and the Sunni scholars' answers — asked what the callers to rapprochement base themselves on. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21855, 28 May 2007) answered that the call to taqrib is an ambiguous term: if it means rapprochement in the political frame and in the two sides' common interests, it is an acceptable call — indeed necessary to spare blood, secure the roads, and let people travel and dwell in their lands safely; it is the basis of settled security and flourishing lands, and by nature admits tact, tolerance and even the yielding of some claims if needed. But rapprochement in the creed-frame is impossible, the differences between the two doctrines being essential and not admitting fusion — as the answer details. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • The rational proofs of God's oneness

    A questioner asked for the rational proofs of God's oneness from the Messenger's words. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77699, 4 February 2009) answered that God's book holds direct verses on the matter — 'if there were gods in them besides God, both would have been corrupted; glory to God, Lord of the Throne, above what they describe', and 'God took no son, nor is there any god with Him — else each god would have gone off with what he created and some would have risen over others' — pointing him to their commentary in the tafsir books and the creed teachers' notes, especially Shaykh Safar al-Hawali's commentary on al-Tahawiyya with its precious words; and studies long and short exist on what he asked — let him consult them.

    Original page

  • Reasoning out the sharia's rulings — no bar to it

    A questioner asked for the proofs forbidding reasoning out the sharia's rulings. Dr. Walid Basyouni (fatwa no. 21835, 19 February 2006) answered that nothing bars ta'lil of the Islamic sharia's rulings — analogy is a proof at the four followed madhhabs, and it runs only by reasoning out rulings and annexing the unspoken to the spoken in judgment for their sharing its cause; perhaps the questioner read that some worship-matters are not intelligible in meaning — the noon prayer four and the sunset three, fasting Ramadan and not Sha'ban — and supposed all rulings like that, which is not so.

    Original page

  • Reckoning for what lies in the hearts — al-Baqara 284

    A questioner asked whether 'whether you reveal what is in your souls or hide it, God will call you to account' means one who intends a wrong but does not do it is punished. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 76689, 23 October 2008) answered that of God's mercy He has overlooked for this ummah what the soul stirs with, so long as it is not acted on or spoken — the Prophet's report establishing it — and in the two Sahihs: whoever resolves on a good deed and does not do it has one good written; does it and ten; resolves on an evil and does not do it, nothing is written; does it and one evil. The verse was abrogated — established in Sahih Muslim — by 'God does not charge a soul beyond its capacity'.

    Original page

  • Regret over a small slip, and seeking forgiveness

    A questioner disliked licking food off his fingers though knowing it is recommended, having thought it applied only when food fell on the finger — and feared that was dislike of a sunna. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78103, 6 March 2009) answered that the measure is the endings, and God had opened his chest in the end — he hopes his earlier state is forgiven; whenever unease stirs in his breast he should hasten to seek forgiveness, sure that his Lord is vast in forgiveness.

    Original page

  • Contentment with God's share in choosing a major

    A second-year architecture student who chose her department by preference — though her grades admitted her to dentistry — and then regretted it asked for guidance. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 79118, 7 June 2009) answered that nothing in existence befalls except by God's decree; having done her duty of istikhara and consultation, she should be content with God's share for her — perhaps the thing she dislikes holds much good, per 'it may be you hate a thing and God makes much good in it'.

    Original page

  • Balancing the sciences of religion and of the world

    A questioner asked how to balance the sciences of religion and of the world. The Assembly of Muslim Jurists (fatwa no. 360, 21 September 2004) answered that among religion's sciences some are individually obligatory — learning them binding on every Muslim, sinful to leave, none excused for ignoring, like what one's prayer, fast and other worship cannot stand on; he need not know each question with its proof — asking a fatwa-authority he trusts in religion and learning suffices for worship on insight; the communally obligatory sciences fall on the ummah as a whole, not each person — medicine, engineering and the like serving its interests.

    Original page

  • Renting a church for Friday prayer when a mosque is near

    Muslims in a Western country asked about renting a church for Friday and congregational prayers, and about displaying God's name over one of its crosses. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78505, 9 April 2009) answered that if a mosque is near and no apparent need requires the rental, it should not be rented — preserving the Muslims' unity of word and guarding their funds; if a pressing need exists to let those unable to reach the near mosques perform their rites, there is no harm; and even then he sees no point in displaying God's name on one cross while the rest stand visible — a mixing not to fall into; judging the need and its degree returns to the community's decision-makers, who should consult one another in good.

    Original page

  • Praying the same obligation twice — home then mosque

    A questioner asked whether he may pray the same obligation twice — once at home and once at the mosque. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 86406, 29 January 2012) answered that there is no harm in what he described: one counts for him as voluntary and the other discharges the duty, citing Abu Dharr's hadith in Sahih Muslim — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Repeating the istikhara after a good dream — dua may be repeated

    A questioner asked whether the istikhara may be repeated many times after seeing a heart-easing dream. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 86391, 25 January 2012) answered that istikhara is a supplication and repeating supplication is legislated, dream seen or not; advancing on the work does not require a good dream after it — one seeks the choice and proceeds — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Repentance of one who insulted the Messenger

    A questioner listed the forms of apostasy scholars record — insulting God or the Messenger among them — and asked whether such repentance is accepted. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77506, 21 January 2009) answered that the rule is sincere repentance wipes what came before — no sin outweighs repentance; 'tell those who disbelieve: if they desist, what is past is forgiven'. For those denying the insulter's repentance, the point is that repentance does not lift the insult's penalty, its right-holder not present to forgo it and the ummah not commissioned in it; he counselled the questioner over the whispers reaching him to seek refuge in God, not indulge them — he is furthest from insulting, among those who venerate the Messenger with hearts full of his love. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Repenting a sin one thought not major

    A questioner asked about one who repented a sin he believed not major — is he still held to what passed, and what increases good deeds? Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21872, 29 October 2007) answered that the repentant of a sin is as one without it; he counselled abundance of seeking forgiveness and doing good, for good deeds do away with evil ones.

    Original page

  • The prisoner barred from congregation — the reward for intent

    A questioner asked Islam's ruling on prisoners who can rarely join the congregational prayer. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 21996, 14 October 2012) answered with hope that one eager for a good deed whose soul yearned for it sincerely, yet whom overpowering excuses barred from it, receives the same reward God willing — citing the hadith on intention — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Creatures' right upon God, and recurring doubts

    A questioner raised recurring doubts harming religion and asked for detailed answers. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 86832, 8 May 2012) opened that creatures hold no right upon God except what God Himself made binding: He bound Himself to aiding the believers and to not punishing whoever associates nothing with Him, per Mu'adh's hadith in the two Sahihs — a right due by His perfect words and true promise, not a creature's claim on God like one creature's on another — then pursued the remaining answers, as recorded.

    Original page

  • The over-strict and the wary of doubts

    A questioner asked the difference between the over-strict — blameworthy per 'none makes the religion hard but it overcomes him' — and the wary of ambiguities, praised in the hadith. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21843, 20 July 2006) answered that the over-strict is one who imagines ambiguities with no ground and scruples where no scruple belongs, while the wary of ambiguities guards against a doubt whose existence has real standing and whose supposition has a sound possibility — earning praise for it.

    Original page

  • Al-Baqara 158 — the word yattuf explained

    A questioner stumbled on 'al-Safa and al-Marwa are among God's rites — whoever performs hajj or umra, no blame on him that he circles them (yattawwafa bihima)'. Dr. Muhammad Mawfiq al-Ghalayini (fatwa no. 21849, 12 November 2006) answered that the point is morphological: the root of yattawwafa is yatatawwafa, its ta merged into the ta' yielding a doubled ta' — the Arabs commonly doing this for lightness, and the Qur'an, revealed in clear Arabic and inimitable in its eloquence, could not use a rough or discarded speech; as for the sharia tawaf, it is the very circuit the Muslims make between al-Safa and al-Marwa.

    Original page

  • Wudu with sea water — in Ramadan and outside it

    A questioner asked whether wudu with sea water is lawful by a Ramadan day. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 85328, 24 August 2011) answered that wudu with sea water is lawful in Ramadan and outside it — the Prophet was asked and said 'its water is the purifier, its dead lawful'; Abu Hurayra reports the man who said 'Messenger of God, we ride the sea carrying little water — if we make wudu with it we thirst; shall we do wudu from the sea?' and he answered 'its water is the purifier, its dead lawful' — as detailed.

    Original page

  • Seeing the Prophet in a dream

    A questioner asked whether the hadith 'whoever sees me in a dream has truly seen me' ties such visions to a certain rank. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78162, 11 March 2009) answered that whoever sees the Prophet in the form the Shamail books describe has seen truly, for the devil cannot take his shape; the vision indicates well-being in religion and tidings of a good ending, God willing — hopefully a prelude to a complete vision — so he should strive in worship, multiply blessings upon him and hope well.

    Original page

  • Seeking help from the Muslim jinn

    A questioner asked about dealing with or seeking help from Muslim jinn to help others — treating the possessed or showing them the cause of their trouble. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81265, 6 April 2010) answered that among the jinn are the righteous and the less so; if resorting to their righteous involves no forbidden act and counts as general cooperation in piety, he sees no harm in it — yet the matter is slippery ground, rife with mixing and pretenders, and better left off to close the door to corruption; he quoted Ibn Uthaymin that seeking a creature's help in what it can do is unobjectionable, but believing or disbelieving them needs scrutiny — the matter is not easy and requires verification. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Semen drawn by surgery — no washing, prayers stand

    A questioner asked whether semen drawn out by surgery obliges the washing. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 83805, 17 February 2011) answered that what obliges washing is semen leaving with desire; its leaving for a cause, or being drawn at the root by a surgical operation, does not oblige it — accordingly his prayers in that span are valid and no make-up binds him.

    Original page

  • Feeling urine descend with nothing in the clothes — ignore the doubt

    A questioner whose private part is very sensitive always feels urine descending, yet finds nothing in the clothes. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78031, 1 March 2009) answered that the rule for one whom doubt haunts and multiplies on is to pay it no heed and build nothing on it — casting it off as though it were not, until he leaves its whirlpool; so he does not repeat his prayer and gives this doubt no mind — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Changing one's sex — the fiqh academy's ruling

    A questioner asked the ruling on changing one's sex in Islam. Dr. Hatim al-Hajj (fatwa no. 21840, 28 May 2006) referred him to the fatwa of the Islamic Fiqh Academy of the Muslim World League issued at its eleventh session in Mecca, 13–20 Rajab 1409 AH (February 1989), reproducing its text with what the Academy resolves on the matter. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Declaring the Imamiyya's scholars disbelievers — the cautious line

    A questioner asked whether it is true that 'our view of the Imamite Shia is that their ignorant are sinners and their scholars disbelievers'. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 3262, 22 July 2007) answered that declaring the Imamiyya's scholars disbelievers is disputed among scholars; the cautious course is to say: whoever is proven of himself to hold an unbelieving creed is a disbeliever for it — without pronouncing takfir over their scholars wholesale, such a saying being reckless. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Raising symbols of shirk in the mosque to win hearts

    A dawa worker in America who visits churches to present Islam asked about inviting non-Muslims to the mosque while the brothers raised banners of shirk to soften their hearts. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81615, 5 June 2010) answered that letting non-Muslims perform their worship in our mosque when their time comes, to soften hearts, is one thing; taking the initiative to raise those banners of shirk is another — no interest requires it and no ijtihad encompasses it; it is sheer falsehood that must be answered and denounced without causing greater harm, and he referred to the recommendations of the Assembly's course on interfaith dialogue. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Shortening prayers traveling to and from the prison

    A questioner asked whether he may shorten prayers traveling to and from the prison, and what the travel distance is. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 21994, 14 October 2012) answered that if the distance counts as travel in custom he may take the travel concessions — shortening, joining, breaking the fast and the like; if it is near enough not to count as travel, the traveler's rulings do not apply — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Standing under the shower with intent — ghusl complete

    A questioner asked about bathing from janaba. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21936, 2 October 2005) answered that a bather standing under the shower intending the ghusl from janaba, the water covering his whole body in any manner, finds it suffices — the legal purity is attained by it — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • A small dark trace under the nail — the little is pardoned

    A questioner finds a small dark spot under one or some nails from scratching his skin. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21959, 17 December 2007) answered that he pays it no heed — the little is pardoned in the sharia — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Blessing a sneezing non-Muslim

    A questioner asked whether one may bless a sneezing non-Muslim with their customary phrases like 'Bless you' in America, which contain no prayer for mercy or forgiveness. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 23201, 24 June 2008) answered that Abu Dawud narrated — al-Hakim grading it sound — Abu Musa al-Ash'ari's report that the Jews used to sneeze before the Prophet hoping he would say 'God have mercy on you', and he would say 'God guide you and mend your state'; Ibn Daqiq al-Id noted that those who make tashmit a prayer of good bring the disbelievers into the command's generality, while those limiting it to mercy do not; and Ibn Hajar held that legally Abu Musa's hadith shows they enter the general command to bless.

    Original page

  • Does the soul leave the body in sleep

    A questioner asked whether a person's soul leaves him in sleep while he is still alive. Dr. Walid Basyouni (fatwa no. 21846, 26 August 2006) answered that al-Zumar's verse — 'God takes the souls at their death, and those that have not died, in their sleep' — shows the soul that is the spirit is taken by God at sleep then returned at waking; hence the Prophet used to say on waking 'praise God who gave us life after He gave us death'. As for how this taking and return work and the soul-body link during it — that is unseen, its knowledge consigned to God: 'say: the spirit is of my Lord's affair'.

    Original page

  • What jurists mean by a sound and a weak opinion

    A questioner asked what jurists mean by 'sound' and 'weak' opinions, the criterion of soundness, whether acting on either of two sound views is valid, and the wording of the need-sermon. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77736, 7 February 2009) answered that soundness in jurists' opinions is relative — sound to one mujtahid may not be to another — but a mujtahid calling a view sound means it is what evidence-examination requires and reflection witnesses; the measure of soundness is the view's agreement with the proof under his adopted principles; a diversity-difference allows acting on either view, but a contradictory difference requires seeking the preponderant and acting on what one's judgment holds nearer the right and more in keeping with the Lawgiver's intent; a lay questioner is referred to his mufti for the weighing.

    Original page

  • May one say this? ⁦(reviling a deceased non-Muslim vs praying for mercy on him)⁩

    The Assembly of Muslim Jurists of America (fatwa no. 87573, 12 October 2012) answered that a non-Muslim who has died has passed on to what he sent ahead: he may not be reviled, per the hadith forbidding abuse of the dead; kindness to his family is prescribed — condolence, and help with money and support where appropriate; but praying mercy and forgiveness for him is not permitted, citing the verse that bars seeking forgiveness for polytheists after it became clear they were people of the Fire.

    Original page

  • When the mind strays in prayer — refuge, head-turn, left-spittle

    A questioner asked whether, when thought strays to other than the prayer, one spits to the left. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 86021, 30 November 2011) answered that the worshipper feeling the devil's whispering in his prayer is taught to seek God's refuge, turn only his head and spit to his left three times — for Muslim's hadith of Uthman b. Abi'l-As — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Leaving the standing in prayer for work or the market — not allowed

    A questioner asked whether he may leave standing in the prayer while working or in the market. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 86333, 16 January 2012) answered that standing in the obligatory prayer is a pillar, lapsing only at inability — 'stand to God in devotion' and 'pray standing; if you cannot, then seated' — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • The Companions hearing a stone cast into the Fire

    A questioner asked about the hadith in which the Prophet sat with his Companions and they heard the sound of a rock cast into the Fire while still in this world. The site's sharia section (fatwa no. 78237, 16 March 2009) answered that the hadith was narrated by Ahmad in his Musnad and Muslim in his Sahih, and it shows their hearing that fall of the stone into the pit of jahannam in his saying 'do you know what this was'.

    Original page

  • The 'strength of four thousand men' claim is a fabrication

    A questioner heard in a lesson that God gave His messenger the strength of four thousand men, and asked if the hadith is sound. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77630, 30 January 2009) answered that he had never heard of it — it is rather among the fabrications of Islam's enemies aiming to impugn the Prophet, among those trumpeting it the priest Zakaria Boutros, whom God will repay; he warned him to mind such forgeries.

    Original page

  • Is the suicide eternally in the Fire

    A questioner cited the hadith that one who throws himself from a mountain and kills himself falls forever in hellfire, asking whether the Muslim suicide is eternally damned. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78687, 28 April 2009) answered that the self-killer's recompense is eternity in the Fire per the hadith he cited — yet God may pardon him, his affair consigned to God per 'God does not forgive shirk but forgives what is less for whom He wills'.

    Original page

  • The suicide's fate — the Sunni position of hope and fear

    A questioner asked about the hereafter-fate of a sick man who killed himself. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77562, 25 January 2009) answered that the man has gone to his Lord and his account is on God; it is hoped his mental illness had grown so severe it drove him to suicide without free will, placing him within God's pardon — a matter none can now truly know and none should interpose between God and His servants; one should not be much occupied with people's final fates, consigned to their Creator; the Sunni position on the people of the qibla is hope for the well-doers and fear for the wrongdoers, with no certain verdict for any individual — paradise or fire — absent a text declaring his fate.

    Original page

  • Asked about a woman's character by her suitor — tell the truth

    A questioner asked what one must do when a suitor asks him about a woman whose morals he knows are corrupt — tell the truth or keep silent? Dr. Muhammad Mawfiq al-Ghalayini (fatwa no. 21833, 23 January 2006) answered that concealing testimony is not lawful — 'do not conceal testimony; whoever conceals it has a sinful heart' — so he must tell the truth, per 'witness to one like the sun, else leave it'; and secondly he should carry counsel to the woman through a righteous woman, for 'religion is sincere counsel' as the Prophet guided.

    Original page

  • Marriage between a Sunni and a Shia

    A questioner asked whether the sharia bars a Sunni Muslim woman from marrying a Shia Muslim man, or vice versa. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 79514, 26 July 2009) answered that whoever is of the people of the qibla can validly contract marriage, and the Shia are not one kind: the common folk and near-common who know of Shia inheritance only a historical affiliation carry the ruling of their like among the Sunni public; but one who holds as religion cursing the two Shaykhs, or cursing the Mother of the Believers in what God cleared her of, or the Quran's distortion — his contract is invalid, such beliefs being incompatible with the root of faith; whoever lies between, a Sunni woman is not encouraged to risk marrying him, since creedal compatibility and equivalence in religion and character are among the firmest grounds of a sound marriage. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • After surgery, unable to wash — tayammum or bandage-wiping

    A questioner had surgery and, unable to wash, was doing wudu only. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81595, 2 June 2010) answered that he owed tayammum where wholly unable to use water — or to wash, bandage the wound with something and wipe over it if able — God having legislated tayammum for one lacking water or unable to use it, per 'if you find no water, tayammum' — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • The Tablighi Jamaat — Sunnis in general, with cautions

    A questioner asked whether the Tablighi Jamaat are Sunnis and whether going out with them is lawful, or innovators to be shunned, having grown numerous in Egypt. Dr. Hatim al-Hajj (fatwa no. 21845, 25 August 2006) answered that the Tablighi Jamaat is an Islamic preaching and exhorting body of the Sunnis in general, whose members serve the call to God and carry Islam's virtues to Muslims and non-Muslims; it was founded by Shaykh Muhammad Ilyas al-Kandahlawi of India (1303–1364 AH), and among their virtues are sincerity — whose signs are seen on them — and a high resolve in preaching; the answer then details particular sharia reservations about them. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Must recitation in prayer be tajweed — to one's ability

    A questioner asked whether he must recite with tajweed in the prayer. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78680, 28 April 2009) answered that yes — one is to recite the Qur'an with tajweed in and outside the prayers, to the best of one's ability.

    Original page

  • Taking American citizenship

    A questioner asked whether he may take American citizenship to ease re-entry to America even while staying long periods in his home country beyond what residency permits. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 87413, 7 September 2012) answered that there is no harm in obtaining this citizenship for the mentioned purposes, provided the naturalised person keeps his loyalty to his creed and his ummah intact.

    Original page

  • The conditions of moral responsibility: intellect

    A questioner asked for the proof that intellect and grasping the address are conditions of moral responsibility, and how to reconcile them. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77582, 26 January 2009) answered that 'the pen is lifted from three — the child till puberty, the sleeper till he wakes, and the madman till he recovers' proves intellect a condition; the intellect responsibility turns on is what stands opposed to madness — that in whose presence the proof is established — not the intellect of guidance, profiting by what it grasps; for the disbelievers say 'had we heard or understood we would not have been among the Blaze's companions', and what is meant is not that the faculty itself was absent.

    Original page

  • The wordings of doubt in transmitting hadith

    A questioner asked which wordings mark a hadith citation as doubtful, and whether 'such-and-such is established from the Messenger of God' is one. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78471, 5 April 2009) answered that 'established from the Messenger' is plainly not a wording of doubt — it is a wording of certainty, implying commitment to the hadith's soundness, so it should preface a report only when one is sure of it; the doubt wordings are like 'it is reported' with a doubled r and 'it is said' and the like.

    Original page

  • Tarawih prayers amid the COVID pandemic

    AMJA's fatwa committee received several questions on the tarawih prayer amid the COVID epidemic. The committee (fatwa no. 87755, 23 April 2020) answered detailing the rulings on performing it in homes, congregating for it and what the crisis requires — as the response sets out.

    Original page

  • The Malik al-Dar report on seeking rain at the Prophet's grave

    A questioner asked about the Malik al-Dar report in Ibn Abi Shayba of a man who came to the Prophet's grave in Umar's drought. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 87024, 27 June 2012) answered that, even supposing it sound, it is no proof for seeking rain through the Prophet after his death: the asker is unknown, and the Companions' practice contradicts it — none of them came to the grave to ask for rain or anything else; Umar turned instead to seeking rain through al-Abbas with no Companion objecting; what that man did was, in the fatwa's view, reprehensible and a gateway to shirk, and dream visions establish no ruling, as detailed.

    Original page

  • Tayammum on a household stone — only where water fails

    A questioner had a natural stone, washed — may he do tayammum on it? Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21943, 23 April 2006) answered that it is not lawful in a state of choice — the majority's saying, with differences in their details — choice meaning being able to use water; tayammum is a stand-in for wudu where water is lacking or unusable — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • What serves for tayammum — clean earth, not beach stones

    A questioner asked what kind of stones serve for tayammum and whether they must come from the sea. Dr. Muhammad Mawfiq al-Ghalayini (fatwa no. 80692, 23 December 2009) answered that tayammum's instrument is, in principle, clean dust as the noble verse states — 'if you find no water, tayammum with clean ground' — and his saying 'the earth was made for me a place of prayer and a purifier'; the clean ground is pure dust and what stands in its place of the earth's face — the answer detailing what tayammum is valid with.

    Original page

  • Tayammum with sand — every face of the earth

    A questioner asked whether a patient who cannot manage water may do tayammum with sand. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 83287, 11 December 2010) answered that tayammum is valid with whatever rises on the earth's face — dust, stone, sand and the like, dust not being a condition, per 'tayammum with clean ground', ground being the earth's surface; Ibn Taymiyya said tayammum is lawful with other than dust, as with stone and sand — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Tayammum when washing brings on illness

    A questioner said his sister suffers migraine and allergy and falls ill whenever she washes after intercourse. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 83696, 5 February 2011) answered that tayammum is lawful where water is lacking or unusable — where using water brings illness, worsens it or delays healing, tayammum is permitted per 'if you find no water, tayammum with clean ground'; and where she can wash some parts without harm she washes what she can and does tayammum for the rest — as detailed.

    Original page

  • Air-conditioning work in hotels and for Islam's enemies

    A man asked whether he may install and service air-conditioning in hotels and for enemies of the Muslims. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78778, 7 May 2009) answered that hotels are lodging-houses by nature — the corruption marring them is not their function — and housing travellers, paid or not, is lawful; as for working for the Muslims' enemies there is detail: with actual combatants in a real war where ranks are drawn it is not permissible, but with covenant-holders whose states have peace agreements or diplomatic ties with Muslim lands it is unobjectionable, avoiding work that angers God whether with Muslims or others.

    Original page

  • A tenant's dog — the three madhhabs on its purity

    A questioner's tenant kept a dog — must everything it touches be washed? Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 85513, 17 September 2011) answered that the scholars dispute the dog's impurity and purity on three madhhabs, which Ibn Taymiyya marshalled: first, pure even to its saliva — Malik's madhhab; second, impure even to its hair — Shafi'i's madhhab and one narration from Ahmad; third, pure except its saliva. The answer details the schools and the washing of a vessel a dog has lapped from that follows on them.

    Original page

  • The Balance on Judgment Day — one scale or two

    A questioner asked whether the Balance is one or two, whether it has two pans and a tongue, and the meaning of 'We set the just balances for Judgment Day — no soul is wronged at all'. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21574, 8 April 2008) answered that the Sunnis believe the balance set on Judgment Day — by which good and evil deeds are weighed — is real, with two pans: good deeds on one, evil on the other, the deeds' records weighed between them, a balance weighing to a gnat's weight — 'whoever does an atom's weight of good will see it, and whoever does an atom's weight of evil will see it'; and the verse 'though it be a mustard-seed's weight, We bring it; sufficient are We as reckoners'.

    Original page

  • He prayed isha as three rak'as by mistake

    A man who combined maghrib and isha after hospital accidentally prayed isha as three rak'as. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77976, 25 February 2009) answered that if he prayed it three by certainty or strong likelihood, a fourth rak'a is due if he remembers soon, then the prostration of forgetfulness — otherwise he repeats the prayer from the start; the binding ruling reaches the bound person only when it reaches him — 'this Quran was revealed to me to warn you and whomever it reaches' — and the forgetful or mistaken bears no sin, yet the absence of sin does not free him from correcting the act and performing it in the lawful form.

    Original page

  • A tormented questioner advised to seek trusted Qur'an healers

    A questioner complained of severe torment. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 87415, 7 September 2012) answered that he should perhaps present himself to trusted Qur'an healers — an evil eye or touch may have struck him — with much remembrance of God, reading the two refuge-surahs and al-Baqara, and supplication — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Touching without emission — when the washing binds

    A questioner asked whether a man's touching a woman's private part, neither emitting, obliges them the washing. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78757, 5 May 2009) answered that the janaba-washing binds on one of two things: the glans' entering the part even without emission — per the two Shaykhs' report from Abu Hurayra — and semen's descending even without entry; what lies short of that, as touching, obliges no washing though it breaks the wudu — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Washing an infant's parts does not break the wudu

    A questioner asked whether he must redo wudu after washing his small children's parts when they use the bathroom. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81182, 22 March 2010) answered that the wudu is not broken by touching an infant's awra who needs a parent's attending his needs, for the universality of that trial — praise God for His gentleness toward His servants and His widening for them — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Touching the member — a madhhab dispute, per Ibn Qudama

    A questioner asked whether touching the member breaks wudu, citing Companions' positions. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21957, 5 November 2007) answered that the wudu's breaking on touching the member is among the scholars' disputed questions — many jurists have set out the difference; he transmits Ibn Qudama's words in al-Mughni, where the positions and Ahmad's narrations are given — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Touching Qur'an tapes without purity — no objection

    A questioner asked the ruling on touching a Qur'an tape without purity. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 3284, 24 July 2007) answered that there is no harm in touching Qur'an tapes without purity — they are not Qur'an and accordingly differ from it in the rulings — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Transporting a body home from America

    A questioner asked about transporting a deceased's body from America to a Muslim country — shipping requires draining the blood and embalming — and whether it is obligatory if the deceased willed it. Dr. Hatim al-Hajj (fatwa no. 1356, 26 February 2006) answered that carrying the dead home is not required when they die abroad, nor even recommended, especially with the treatment of the body described; but he holds the deceased's wish should be carried out so long as it does not put the heirs or Muslims into hardship or difficulty.

    Original page

  • Trimming the beard — the default is letting it grow

    A questioner asked about trimming the beard generally — not to a fistful — having heard one of the four imams permitted it. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 76957, 27 November 2008) answered that the default is letting the beard grow, except when it grows unsightly; then what removes the unsightliness is taken, the rest remaining on the default of letting grow — and the report that the Prophet used to take from his beard's length and breadth was not established.

    Original page

  • The first Fajr adhan an hour early — the two calls explained

    A questioner asked whether the first Fajr adhan may be called an hour before its time. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 85935, 17 November 2011) answered that Fajr has two adhans: one announcing the approach of its time — the one standing returns and the sleeper wakes — and the second at the time's entry, as established in the two Sahihs — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • The white thread and the black thread — al-Baqara 187 explained

    A questioner asked to explain two stories, the first the Companion who read the 'white thread and black thread' verse. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77627, 30 January 2009) recited al-Baqara 187 — permitting conjugal approach on fasting nights and eating and drinking 'until the white thread is distinct from the black thread, of dawn; then complete the fast till night' — and explained with al-Hafiz Ibn Kathir that the white thread is the light of dawn and the black thread the darkness of night, as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Two prayer timetables from two mosques — shura belongs to the permissible

    A questioner reported that his town's two mosques distributed two prayer-timetables and Ramadan fasting charts over two years, causing hardship. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 87075, 7 July 2012) answered that consultation belongs to permissible matters and lawful alternatives — citing al-Bukhari that the imams consulted trustworthy scholars on permissible matters to take the easiest, while shari'a questions go back to the people of knowledge — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Two who loved each other in God — one of the seven shaded

    A questioner asked for the meaning of 'two men who loved each other in God, gathering upon it and parting upon it' among the seven God shades in His shade. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77594, 27 January 2009) answered that a love ran between them — a love in God, not in money, standing or lineage: he saw him keeping God's obedience and shunning His prohibitions and loved him for it; and 'they gathered upon it and parted upon it' means they met upon it in this world and the love held until death parted them still upon it — a sign that those who love each other in God let no worldly accident cut their love.

    Original page

  • A sacrifice on behalf of ten persons

    A questioner asked about a sacrifice on behalf of ten persons, citing Ibn Abbas's hadith on the camel. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 86120, 11 December 2011) answered that the majority hold cattle and camels each suffice for seven persons per Jabir's hadith in Muslim, while some scholars — Ishaq, Ibn Khuzayma, al-Shawkani and others — held the camel suffices for ten in the udhiyya and seven in the hady, on Ibn Abbas's hadith in al-Tirmidhi and al-Nasa'i, as detailed. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • The story of Umar's proposal to Umm Kulthum bint Abi Bakr

    A questioner asked about the soundness of the story that Umar ibn al-Khattab proposed to Umm Kulthum bint Abi Bakr as one report has it. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 87037, 29 June 2012) answered that the story is unsound because of her young age — she was born after her father's death and was still in her mother's womb when Umar took the caliphate, per Ibn Abd al-Barr's entry on Habiba bint Kharija and the genealogists; Umar's caliphate lasted ten years and she was a child throughout unless it were at its very end, as detailed. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • One barred from the mosque's Jumu'a prays it as Zuhr

    A questioner asked the ruling for one unable to pray Jumu'a at the mosque. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 85712, 20 October 2011) answered that one unable to pray Jumu'a at the mosque — for an illness that seated him, a fear that bound him, heavy rain standing between him and the mosque, or like legal excuses — prays it as Zuhr — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Touching one's private part unintentionally — a disputed break

    A questioner touched himself unintentionally while dressing. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81929, 22 July 2010) answered that if the touch was for desire his wudu is broken without dispute; if not for desire and without intent it is a point of study, the evidences conflicting here — the saying that wudu is recommended is a faced one, joining Busra bint Safwan's 'whoever touches his member, let him do wudu' with the other reports — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • An unknown fluid on the clothes — ruled by preponderance

    A questioner found a fluid on his clothes not knowing if it is semen, and asked whether there is consensus. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77740, 7 February 2009) answered that one finding a fluid he cannot identify acts on preponderance — referring it to what outweighs among these things; where no suspicion prevails he counts it of the kind obliging no washing, the presumption being a clear conscience — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Urine on the clothes — adult's washed, infant's by kind

    A questioner asked the ruling on urine reaching the clothes and on an infant's urine. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21949, 8 July 2007) answered that an adult's urine is impure — the clothes it struck or the place it fell on must be washed; an infant's urine has its known rulings — the boy's sufficing with sprinkling and the girl's being washed — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Residing in the United States

    A questioner asked the ruling on seeking residency in the United States, having heard conflicting opinions. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81087, 4 March 2010) answered that the default is for the Muslim to live among Muslims, but residing outside Muslim lands is unobjectionable for a lawful purpose — trade, seeking beneficial knowledge with no equal in Muslim lands, broadening provision, or like good ends — provided one can show one's religion and is safe from trial in it; the Assembly has a standalone resolution on residing outside Muslim lands, on its site, with detailed treatment.

    Original page

  • Western Muslims visiting al-Aqsa Mosque

    A questioner asked the ruling on western Muslims visiting al-Aqsa given the stated restrictions on visitors. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 84801, 25 June 2011) answered that it is a disputed question: permitters see it as affirming the Muslims' right in Jerusalem, binding them to al-Aqsa, morally supporting its people and displaying the ummah's bond before the world, with the merit of journeying to it; preventers see it as acknowledging the occupier's sovereignty and a call to normalisation through visa-taking with the benefits that returns, noting that the Palestinian scholars' league supports prevention — as the answer records. Both views presented as the fatwa presents them.

    Original page

  • Vowing to give away all one's wealth

    A questioner asked about a man who vowed, in a distressed state, to give all his recovered money — three million Egyptian pounds — to God. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 85343, 26 August 2011) answered that conditional vows are disliked per the hadith that a vow repels nothing and only draws out the miser; yet whoever vows obedience must fulfil it per 'whoever vows to obey God, let him obey'; but whoever vows to give all his wealth in charity, giving a third suffices in the scholars' sounder view — Ahmad's madhhab — as detailed.

    Original page

  • A vow to fast a month, consecutiveness not required

    A man vowed to fast a month upon Libya's liberation, fasted fifteen days then stopped, and asked whether consecutiveness is required or the days may be split. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 86132, 12 December 2011) answered that whoever vows to obey God should obey Him — a vow to fast is an obedience-vow and must be fulfilled; since he did not stipulate consecutiveness it is not binding, and completing the count suffices.

    Original page

  • The vow

    A questioner asked about a vow he had made. The Assembly of Muslim Jurists of America (fatwa no. 87070, 6 July 2012) answered that he must fulfil it because it is a vow of obedience, not of disobedience; that he may not eat of it nor feed his children from it according to the majority of scholars; and that it goes to the zakat recipients such as the poor and needy and the like.

    Original page

  • A vow of ten loaves of bread

    A questioner said her sister, two months into marriage, vowed that if she proved pregnant next month she would make ten loaves of bread for her husband's colleagues. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 86554, 10 March 2012) answered that if she vowed to do it herself she must fulfil it when able — before or after delivery, ability being a condition of obligation; and if her vow was unqualified she may fulfil it through whomever she wills.

    Original page

  • Vows uttered during afflictions

    A questioner who keeps promising God certain acts if He delivers him from affliction — sincerely meaning them, then not doing them — asked about it. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 86169, 18 December 2011) answered that whoever vows to obey God should obey Him and whoever vows to disobey Him should not disobey; his is a conditional vow, which is disliked — a vow brings nothing but draws something out of the miser — yet since its object is obedience it must be fulfilled; whoever cannot fulfil his vow is released by an oath's expiation. He advised fulfilling his vows, gauging them by his best judgment, paying an oath-expiation out of caution for what lapsed, and leaving off such vows in future. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Fluid after urinating — wait for its ceasing

    A questioner described a fluid descending after he urinates. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77830, 15 February 2009) answered that where a time is fixed for the fluid's descending and ceasing, he must wait till it ceases, then do istinja and wudu, then perform whatever purity-conditioned worship he wishes; where it is constant and unceasing, he does wudu for each prayer's time — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Wadi twenty minutes after urinating — istinja and wudu, not washing

    A questioner asked whether a fluid — perhaps wadi — descending within twenty minutes of urinating is ordinary. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77788, 11 February 2009) answered that of these fluids only semen obliges the washing — the gushing water descending in a gush with desire, known to all people; whatever else, wadi or madhy or hadi, obliges only washing what it touched and wudu — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Reconciling loyalty to believers with ties to non-Muslim kin

    A questioner asked how to reconcile the verse forbidding taking fathers and brothers as allies if they prefer disbelief with dutifulness to parents and kinship with non-Muslim relatives. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 84560, 29 May 2011) answered that there is no contradiction: keeping kin though non-Muslim and confining loyalty to the community of Muslims are different things — alliance is one thing, good treatment of peaceable non-Muslims another, per the verse that God does not forbid kindness and equity toward those who neither fought nor expelled you; walaya returns to love and support, so religious love of the people of the faith does not negate the natural affection kinship creates, short of abetting falsehood.

    Original page

  • The gradations of loyalty to disbelievers

    A questioner raised the verse forbidding taking fathers and brothers as allies, noting that loyalty has many facets including love, which has kinds. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 84114, 2 April 2011) answered that 'loyalty toward God's enemies' is an ambiguous expression of uneven degrees: some of it is disbelief, some falls short, though all of it is forbidden; what counts as disbelief is absolute allegiance, or allegiance on account of religion — loving or aiding them for their faith and their transgression against God's command; kindness and equity toward peaceable non-Muslims do not enter forbidden loyalty. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Obsessive whisperings about the divine being

    A sufferer of obsessive whisperings about the divine being — thoughts he cannot utter nor tell whether intended, leaving him feeling he has no faith — asked for help. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 83510, 9 January 2011) answered that what he finds is Satan's toying to sadden him; the duty is not to follow the whisperings, to cut them at their start and to say praise be to God who reduced his plot to whispering; resisting them and standing firm is a sign of pure faith by Muslim's hadith 'that is manifest faith' with al-Nawawi's and al-Khattabi's explanations, as detailed.

    Original page

  • Obsessive doubt over divine decree

    A sufferer of obsessive doubts over divine decree asked whether he may stop holding faith in qadar before projects since it weakens him. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 86499, 29 February 2012) answered that faith in decree is a pillar of iman and that yielding to misreading is the error: everything was created by decree and decree is repelled by decree — illness by treatment, hunger by food; faith in decree never means neglecting means — one takes them well in the station of means and disowns power and might in the station of reliance, as detailed.

    Original page

  • Waswasa and psychiatric treatment — no harm to faith or marriage

    A chronic whisperer feared his waswasa might affect his faith and his marriage. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 84392, 9 May 2011) prayed God wipe over him with His healing hand and join reward with health, urging him to seek treatment for the waswasa with trustworthy psychiatrists — God sent down no illness without sending its cure, known to some and unknown to others; what he describes has no effect on his faith nor on his bond with his wife — let him cast the whispering off, give it no heed, turn to mending his own state, take righteous company aiding his religion and world, and abound in remembrance and Qur'an recitation.

    Original page

  • Watching programmes containing words of disbelief

    A questioner who watches documentaries and foreign cartoons — which may utter words of disbelief such as 'nature's wrath' or swearing by other than God, though he disavows them in his heart — asked about it. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 82416, 2 September 2010) advised him to guard his time rather than waste it on cartoons and the like, and to occupy himself with higher things; occasional viewing for recreation or for the scientific benefit of documentaries is acceptable if free of other objectionable content, and their false words do not harm him so long as he disavows them in his heart and has enough understanding of the religion to tell truth from falsehood in what they say. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Water altered by admixture — unfit for purification

    A questioner asked about the waters chapter in fiqh and what soap mixes into. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81847, 12 July 2010) first counselled direct learning in seeking knowledge where possible — one whose shaykh is his book errs more than he hits — then answered that water altered by admixture until it loses its unqualified name is unfit for purification though pure in itself; such is the soap-admixed water asked after — the answer detailing the kinds of waters.

    Original page

  • Putting the weightier first, and the layman's following

    A questioner asked whether the weightier must come first, and whether he may follow Ibn Humam al-Hanafi's view that patching between madhhabs is valid absolutely. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78360, 27 March 2009) answered that when two matters conflict, scripture and reason both commend advancing the weightier: two benefits unattainable together — prefer the weightier; two harms unavoidable — ward off the graver first, the sharia being built on securing and completing benefits and disabling and minimizing harms; as for taqlid, the sound view is that the layman has no madhhab of his own — his madhhab is that of his mufti: when an issue befalls him he raises it to one he trusts in religion and learning, acts on the fatwa and is cleared, God not having bound him to seek one particular imam's opinion.

    Original page

  • Waking in ihtilam with the time short — tayammum

    A questioner woke finding himself in ihtilam with the time short. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 76708, 26 October 2008) answered that tayammum is legislated for water's being lacking in fact or in law: lacking in fact is its absence, lacking in law is being unable to use it though present — among its examples is what his question brought: fear of the time's running out — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Wetness found on waking — the three cases

    A questioner found wetness in his clothes on waking. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78365, 27 March 2009) answered that it is one of three cases: certain it is semen — the washing binds, whether he recalls a dream or not; certain it is not semen — nothing binds; or doubtful — he refers it to the signs and indicators, as the answer details.

    Original page

  • What is the misguided innovation

    A questioner who keeps hearing 'innovation' from the shaykhs and students asked for an explanation of the misguided innovation. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 78452, 3 April 2009) answered that bida is whatever is newly made in the religion, not of it, intended as worship of God — or as al-Shatibi defined it, a contrived religious way resembling the lawful, the following of which aims at exaggeration in worshipping God; whatever is of this kind is blameworthy per 'every novelty is innovation, every innovation misguidance', and among the finest and most useful books on the matter is al-Shatibi's al-I'tisam.

    Original page

  • Hating the whispers is plain faith

    A questioner who grows angry and receives whispers when a religious duty proves hard asked about it. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77661, 2 February 2009) answered that the futile whispers he finds in himself deserve no attention and no utterance — let him seek refuge in God and ask Him to turn them away, they will not harm him; in the chapter stands the Companions' saying 'we find in ourselves things too grave to speak', the Prophet asking 'you really find that?', and on their yes, 'that is plain faith' — the hadith meaning that hating, detesting and recoiling from the whispers is plain faith, not their existence; should some turn into settled doubts, seeking their cure becomes required.

    Original page

  • Who are the Qubaysiyyat

    A questioner asked who the Qubaysiyyat are, they vehemently denying what is written about them online. Dr. Hatim al-Hajj (fatwa no. 21839, 14 May 2006) answered that the Qubaysiyyat are a female esoteric Sufi order named after Munira al-Qubaysi, a contemporary Syrian woman; they preach an extravagant Sufism and many innovations, and disclose their true business to a novice only after she has spent long with them and they feel her full loyalty; each country's circle has an 'anisa' — a sheikha — the great anisa being Munira herself in Syria, her disciples extravagant in venerating her, as in many Sufi orders. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • What came before the Creator — an answer to the seeker

    A woman asking gratefully posed what puzzles her: what is before zero? and what is before the Creator? The site's sharia department (fatwa no. 21500, 19 March 2008) answered that the mind accepts these self-evident truths: before zero is zero, before matter's origin is matter, before nothingness is nothingness — so the mind accepts that there is no creator before the Creator; God has no beginning before Him, for He is, simply, the beginning itself; and as the mind accepts He has no end, it can be convinced He has no beginning.

    Original page

  • Why did God create me knowing I would sin

    A questioner asked why God created him knowing he would work evils and end in the Fire — does that not contradict mercy embracing all things? Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77963, 25 February 2009) answered that God's knowledge is an attribute that discloses things; God does not reckon His servants by what He knows of them but by the deeds they actually show; the askers of this question equate the compelled and the voluntary deeds of servants — plain stubbornness, like equating the feverish shiver with the body's chosen movement toward obscenity; God gave His servants the tools of responsibility — hearing, sight and heart — and reckons them thereby, and had He taken any away He would have dropped the charge to its measure; and the people of Paradise remain eased to the deeds of Paradise's people and the people of the Fire to the Fire's deeds, as detailed.

    Original page

  • Why does God not intervene at a crime

    A questioner who saw a murdered woman and her little daughter driven mad by the sight asked why God did not intervene and spare the child, and whether a supplication wards off crime. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81607, 3 June 2010) answered that God created everything by measure and does what He wills — everyone among people wills what he cannot do or does what he does not will, but God alone does what He wills; He is not questioned about what He does, yet His acts are never sundered from His wisdom whether we grasp it or it escapes us; good is in His hands and evil is not attributed to Him, and it is not for anyone to say 'why did God not do such-and-such' — that is not courtesy with God. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Why the jurists differ — God's wisdom in the texts

    A questioner asked for the reason jurists and hadith-scholars differ on questions. Dr. Walid Basyouni (fatwa no. 21826, 11 April 2005) answered that their disagreement in many scholarly and practical matters has causes and wise purposes — had God willed, He could have made all the two revelations' texts admit but one reading; but in His mercy and wisdom He made some decisive and certain, representing the common faith-ground of the qibla-people, and some open to ijtihad, giving the ummah room, training its minds, and rewarding its effort.

    Original page

  • A wife's recurring discharge — istinja, guarding, timed wudu

    A questioner described fluid descending from his wife at all times, like the fluid of intercourse. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 80837, 19 January 2010) answered that one with incontinence of urine, madhy, semen or the like must do istinja, then guard herself and do wudu for each prayer's time, performing by that wudu whatever worship she wishes, not minding what descends thereafter — the answer detailing the incontinence rulings.

    Original page

  • Must one hear a sound or find a smell — certainty vs doubt

    A questioner asked whether he must hear a sound or smell an odor to confirm needing wudu again. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21948, 31 May 2007) answered that one from whom gases exit has broken his wudu — he need not hear a sound or find a smell so long as he is certain; that hadith's place is at doubt, while one certain of the hadath has his wudu broken — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Wind incontinence and longing for the mosque prayer

    A questioner with wind incontinence longed keenly for the isha prayer in the mosque. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 82151, 12 August 2010) answered that people of excuses do wudu for each prayer's time and may not bring the purification before it — purity being half of faith and no prayer standing for one in hadath till he does wudu; he hoped his brothers would weigh this matter and that some would stay to help him to the mosque, God willing — or he may pray at the nearest mosque, as the answer details.

    Original page

  • The smell wind leaves — not impure

    A questioner passes wind repeatedly and finds a bad smell in his underclothes. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21410, 23 February 2008) answered that the odor arising from wind is not impure — he need not change his underclothes for it; doing so for cleanliness and good preparation for the prayer is nonetheless good — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Wine as disinfectant — no, while lawful alternatives exist

    A questioner asked whether wine or alcoholic drinks may be used as disinfectant amid the sanitizer shortage. AMJA's Permanent Fatwa Committee (no. 87742, 30 March 2020) answered that using wine and alcoholic drinks as disinfectant is not lawful and is resorted to only in utmost necessity, since lawful alternatives exist in their place — soaps of every kind, hand sanitizers and certain chemical cleaners known to kill viruses and bacteria; accordingly selling and buying wine for this purpose is not lawful, per the sharia's settled prohibition on trading in it — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Wiping the head in wudu — the two reported ways

    A questioner asked the right way of wiping the head in wudu. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 83508, 9 January 2011) answered that two manners are reported: first, moving both hands front to back — beginning at the fore of the head to the nape, then returning them to where they began, a way the scholars agree is recommended; second, wiping the fore of the head only — the Zahiris' madhhab and Ibn Taymiyya's choice; both are valid, as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Wiping over the head-cover in wudu

    A woman asked about wudu while wearing the head-cover. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81296, 12 April 2010) answered that the well-known position of Imam Ahmad's madhhab permits wiping over the khimar when wrapped under the chin, this being reported of some women of the Companions; so a woman may wipe over a khimar tied firm and looped under the chin, and may wipe over what lies beneath it — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Wiping over the shoe or khuff — terms and times

    A questioner asked the ruling on wiping over the shoe in wudu. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 79985, 16 September 2009) answered that there is no harm in wiping over shoe or khuff so long as it covers the obligatory place of the feet and was put on in purity; the wiping's term is a day and a night for the resident and three days with their nights for the traveller — the answer detailing the conditions of wiping the khuffs.

    Original page

  • Wiping over socks — conditions and the report of al-Mughira

    A questioner asked the conditions for wiping over socks and what sort of sock serves. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 79887, 6 September 2009) answered that wiping over socks is legislated — among its proofs al-Mughira ibn Shu'ba's report that the Messenger of God did wudu and wiped over socks and sandals, narrated by Ahmad and the Sunan-men; conditions include putting them on in purity and their covering the obligatory place of the feet — the answer detailing the conditions and term.

    Original page

  • Wiping over socks for the resident — three days by this answer

    A questioner asked about wiping over socks for the resident. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21937, 4 April 2006) answered that socks fall under the khuffs' rulings: wiping them is lawful for the resident provided he put them on in purity, and he may wipe them three days and nights — the answer's chosen lenient view — as it details.

    Original page

  • Leaving the prayer — a call back to repentance

    A woman recounted her tangled story — abandoning the prayer, uncovering, and family conflicts. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21831, 19 December 2005) answered that no affliction descends but for a sin and none is lifted but by repentance — 'whatever strikes you of calamity is for what your hands earned, and He pardons much'; leaving the prayer is among the greatest of the major sins and, at many scholars, a door of leaving Islam — 'the covenant between us and them is the prayer; whoever leaves it has disbelieved', and Umar's 'no share in Islam for one who leaves the prayer'; her uncovering and leaving the hijab are among the wrongs repentance requires; he counselled her return to God with remorse, desisting and resolve to mend. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Women reading Qur'an over the net — without touching the mushaf

    A group of women meeting over the net to read the Qur'an asked about one not in purity. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21950, 8 July 2007) answered that there is no harm in reading the Qur'an without touching the mushaf — the soundest of the scholars' sayings and the choice of Shaykh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyya — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • A study on the knowledge no Muslim may be ignorant of ⁦(asked about preparing the paper)⁩

    A questioner wanted to prepare a paper on 'the knowledge no Muslim may be ignorant of'. Dr. Salah al-Sawi answered for the Assembly of Muslim Jurists of America (fatwa no. 21818, 14 October 2012): do it, and no harm — advising him to go back to the concise fiqh manuals compiled by trustworthy scholars and extract their essence as material, then organise it on a sound method, and to take a religious supervisor to guide and assist him if he is new to writing, for showing the way to knowledge is half of knowledge.

    Original page

  • A Muslim wronging a disbeliever — the reckoning

    A questioner asked whether a Muslim who wrongs a disbeliever loses his good deeds on Judgment Day. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 81006, 20 February 2010) answered that it is well-established a Muslim may wrong no one, Muslim or not, and the Prophet said wrongdoing is darkness on Judgment Day; as for how restitution is made to a non-Muslim against a Muslim, its matter is left to God since no sound text specifies it — knowledge whose ignorance harms nothing — and we are forbidden excessive questioning. Recorded as AMJA's answer.

    Original page

  • Wudu for a man with no hands — washing what remains

    A questioner asked how a handless man does wudu. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 21939, 25 December 2005) answered that God tasks no soul beyond its capacity: this man should wash what remains of his hands; and if the question was about the rest of the limbs, he washes them as far as possible — the duty-by-capacity rule the answer details.

    Original page

  • One wudu serves every purity-bound worship

    A woman asked whether wudu done for the duha prayer or Qur'an reading serves when an obligatory prayer's time draws near. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77378, 7 January 2009) answered that wudu lifts the lesser hadath; having done it, she may perform by it all worship conditioned on wudu — what she intended at the time and what she did not — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Doing wudu uncovered before one's spouse

    A woman asked whether she may do wudu before her husband uncovering something of her awra. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 82833, 11 October 2010) answered that covering the awra is a condition of the prayer's validity, not of the wudu's — so no harm in a woman doing wudu before her husband uncovering some of her awra, nor a man before his wife, God having permitted a wife showing her adornment to her husband in 'they show not their adornment save to their husbands' — as detailed.

    Original page

  • Yawning — holding the hand over the mouth, in prayer or out

    A questioner asked about Abu Hurayra's yawning hadith in Sunan Abi Dawud. AMJA's fatwa committee (fatwa no. 87033, 29 June 2012) answered that Sahih Muslim has 'if one of you yawns let him hold his hand over his mouth, for the devil enters,' quoting al-Nawawi that whether in prayer or out it is liked to stifle it as far as possible — as the answer details.

    Original page

  • Attributing a child of zina to his father — AMJA's resolution

    A questioner asked whether a man who fathered a child by zina may claim the child as his own. Dr. Salah al-Sawi (fatwa no. 77386, 8 January 2009) answered that the Assembly of Muslim Jurists of America studied the matter and, after deliberation and a deferral stretching two years, concluded that the fornicator may claim his zina-child, who then attaches to him with all the rights of a legitimate child — honouring the Lawgiver's eagerness to establish lineage, which He affirms by the weakest route and negates only by the strongest; the resolution operates provisionally outside Muslim lands, while its application inside them awaits further sessions and studies; the resolution can be reviewed on the Assembly's site.

    Original page

Back to the Fatwa Explorer