The book's answer to the question: why did al-Hadi not call down harm on his opponents?

جواب صاحب الكتاب عن سؤال: لماذا لم يدعُ الهادي على أعدائه؟

June 899 CE · Jumada II 286 AH

Najran

The narrator poses an imagined objection: if al-Hadi's prayer is answered, why do many enemies fight him and why does he not call down harm on them? He answers that God gives His friends and tries them to multiply their reward, points to the trials of the Prophet ﷺ from his own people and the killing of al-Husayn and Zayd ibn Ali, reads "thus We made for every prophet an enemy" as naming rather than creating, and promises a separate book on the signs of the imamate.

DraftWritten with AI help from the sources it cites, and not yet read by a human editor.

Depth

At a glance

Era
Abbasid Fragmentation
Region
Arabia

In time

890900910
Abbasid Fragmentation

In space

Najran

Map: Natural Earth, public domain · places and route from the graph

Politics, governance and authority

Overview

After the reports in Reports of a boy's sight restored and a child's tongue loosed at Najran, and of what befell two detractors, Jumada II 286 AH the narrator supposes someone saying: "If you describe this of Yahya ibn al-Husayn and claim his prayer is answered, we have seen many enemies who fight him and spoil his governors' work, so why did he not call down on them until God relieved him of them?" 1 What follows is the view of the Zaydi narrators; the museum gives it as a description of their argument, not a judgment on it. See the imamate, where the Sunni position stands first.

The answer

The narrator says the answer "has been given before": "God gives them and tries them, to multiply their reward by it and turn the pain of punishment from them." 2 He says the Prophet "was tried by his people more than Yahya ibn al-Husayn was tried", that his uncles and all Quraysh fought him, that he prayed and the moon split for him and he called the trees and they joined together, and that al-Husayn ibn Ali (may God be pleased with him) was killed and kept from water, as was Zayd ibn Ali, and that the prophets and messengers before them fought and suffered trials and, had they asked God to turn them aside, He would have. 2

Reading "We made"

The narrator cites the verse al-Furqan 25:31 and says that "making" here is "naming the enemy": it is not creating them but naming them; God named the enemies of the prophets among the criminals and judged them by their deeds; he cites al-Ma'ida 5:103 to show that "God did not make a bahira" means He did not name it. 2 He closes with Qaf 50:37 and says the argument would be long and is clear to "whoever has a heart or gives ear". 2 This is the narrator's reading as the book gives it; the commentators hold other readings and the museum does not weigh them here.

A promise of a separate book

He adds that if everything the deniers deny of the signs of Yahya ibn al-Husayn's imamate were written, it would fill a separate book, "and perhaps we shall take it up, compile and write it, God willing". 2 The book does not say it was written.

Notes

In this passage the Zaydi narrative calls the imam's opponents "criminals"; the museum gives that as the narrator's wording and does not use it in its own voice. The editor's footnote on p. 131 records "yustajab" in the other manuscript where the text has "mustajab".

Connections

Explore the connections

Occurred at
Najran
Had participant
Yahya al-Hadi al-Rassi
Related to
The Imamate· Reports of a boy's sight restored and a child's tongue loosed at Najran, and of what befell two detractors, Jumada II 286 AH

People and things also explored

Al-Hadi at Rajla: the division of a wrongdoer's crop and the felling of his share of palms, Jumada II 286 AH· Reports of a boy's sight restored and a child's tongue loosed at Najran, and of what befell two detractors, Jumada II 286 AH· Al-Da'am writes of Ibn Bustam at Shakir and Abu al-Qasim answers in verse, 286 AH· Al-Hadi at Najran: meeting the tribes, the oath between Hamdan and Banu al-Harith, and the pledge· Al-Hadi's march to Da'a in the land of Shakir, his return to Najran and then Sa'da, Ramadan 284 AH· Al-Hadi's judgment on three men who killed a traveller near Raydah and took his loads, Safar 285 AH· Al-Hadi kills Abu al-Wajih and takes al-Hajar, Dhu al-Hijja 286 AH· Al-Hadi leaves again for Najran and meets Abu Ja'far and al-Ahlaf at al-Hisn, p. 290

Sources

  1. Sirat al-Imam al-Hadi ila al-Haqq Yahya ibn al-Husayn — Ali ibn Muhammad al-Abbasi al-Alawi , p.131
  2. Sirat al-Imam al-Hadi ila al-Haqq Yahya ibn al-Husayn — Ali ibn Muhammad al-Abbasi al-Alawi , p.132
Cite this page

islam.museum contributors. “The book's answer to the question: why did al-Hadi not call down harm on his opponents?”. islam.museum, https://islam.museum/en/event/the-books-answer-why-al-hadi-did-not-call-down-harm-on-his-opponents-286/. CC BY-SA 4.0. Last updated 2026-11-14.

Improve this page on GitHub · Report an error · Help complete it · JSON

Wing

Time

Eras, timelines, this day in history, any year in the Islamic world.
Related

Al-Hadi at Rajla: the division of a wrongdoer's crop and the felling of his share of palms, Jumada II 286 AH

Al-Hadi sought a wrongdoer who had fled his village of Rajla and, getting no answer, pulled down his house; he had the maize crop and the palms held with his brother and partners divided, pulled up the crop that fell to the man and cut his share of palms, a little over twenty, citing the Prophet's cutting of the palms of Banu al-Nadir and the verse of Surat al-Hashr, then returned and settled matters among the people.