More reports on the wine penalty, from al-Kufi and Ibn Abi Hisham

أخبار أخرى في حد الخمر: من روايتي الكوفي وابن أبي هشام

Ali ibn Muhammad relays further reports on the wine penalty from Abu Jafar Muhammad ibn Sulayman al-Kufi, from Muhammad ibn Abi Hisham and from his father: a frail man given three whips bound together, a woman who begged mercy for the sake of Ali ibn Abi Talib (may God be pleased with him) and was told the penalty belongs to God, a saying of al-Hadi about taking what is due even from his grandfather al-Qasim ibn Ibrahim, and two men in whose house wine was found, struck sixty each.

DraftWritten with AI help from the sources it cites, and not yet read by a human editor.

Depth

At a glance

Era
Abbasid Fragmentation
Region
Arabia

Politics, governance and authority

Overview

After the account of al-Hadi applying the wine penalty, the page 1 continues with more reports that Ali ibn Muhammad gives from three narrators: Abu Jafar Muhammad ibn Sulayman al-Kufi, Muhammad ibn Abi Hisham, and his father Muhammad ibn Ubaydallah. The account is Zaydi, in the voice of the followers of Yahya ibn al-Husayn; the rulings and numbers are its narrators' report, and the museum neither compares nor judges; the general subject has records at Wine and Fixed penalties (hudud).

Al-Kufi's report

Al-Kufi said: a man who had drunk wine was brought to Yahya ibn al-Husayn and testimony was given against him; he was frail in body, so three whips were gathered for him and he was struck with all of them together until the full eighty was reached. 1

The woman who begged for mercy

Muhammad ibn Abi Hisham told that a woman was taken who had drunk wine, with witnesses testifying to it, and he ordered her flogged the penalty; she said, "Pardon me by the right of Ali ibn Abi Talib", and Yahya ibn al-Husayn answered, "By the right of Ali ibn Abi Talib, were the matter mine I would not strike you, but it is God's"; he then said, "By God, if the penalty fell due on my father I would take it from him." 1

Muhammad ibn Ubaydallah's reports

Muhammad ibn Ubaydallah said that one day he saw a man brought who had drunk wine, with testimony given, and he was struck; being frail, two whips were gathered for him and he was struck with both together until the eighty were complete. 1 He also heard him one day, speaking of taking what is due and with a group of people about him, say: "By God, if it were my grandfather al-Qasim ibn Ibrahim and the penalty of the sword fell due on him, I would not pray noon prayer until I had struck his neck." 1 The narrator gives it as a statement that what is due is taken from the near as from the far. He saw too two men brought in whose house wine had been found, with a group testifying before Yahya, and he ordered each struck sixty, and they were. 1

Notes

The text gives no place or date for these reports. The editor's footnotes mark small manuscript differences (the added words "qad" and "four" taken from the second manuscript) that do not change the sense. 1

Connections

Explore the connections

Had participant
Yahya al-Hadi al-Rassi· Muhammad ibn Sulayman al-Kufi· Abu Jafar Muhammad ibn Ubaydallah al-Abbasi· Ali ibn Muhammad ibn Ubaydallah al-Abbasi al-Alawi
Related to
Wine· Fixed penalties (hudud)

People and things also explored

Al-Hadi applies the penalty for wine and corrects others, as Muhammad ibn Ubaydallah tells it· Al-Hadi gives retaliation for a slave's blows and answers an extra lash· Yahya al-Hadi al-Rassi· Abu al-Qasim ibn al-Hadi leads the Friday prayer at Khiwan and urges jihad, Sha'ban 286 AH· Ahmad ibn al-Dahhak and Murawwi ibn Abdullah on al-Hadi's prayers against Abu Mihjan and Jaftam, 286 AH· Al-Hadi at Hawth and the array at the pond of al-Damriyya, Rajab 286 AH· Banu Ma'mar return on Saturday 21 Sha'ban 286 AH and al-Hadi grants them safe-conduct through the elders of Khiwan· Al-Hadi leaves Sa'da for Khaywan and meets al-Da'am at al-Amshiyya, Muharram 288 AH

Sources

  1. Sirat al-Imam al-Hadi ila al-Haqq Yahya ibn al-Husayn — Ali ibn Muhammad al-Abbasi al-Alawi , p.120
Cite this page

islam.museum contributors. “More reports on the wine penalty, from al-Kufi and Ibn Abi Hisham”. islam.museum, https://islam.museum/en/event/al-hadi-more-wine-penalty-reports-from-al-kufi-and-ibn-abi-hisham-286/. CC BY-SA 4.0. Last updated 2026-11-14.

Improve this page on GitHub · Report an error · Help complete it · JSON

Wing

Time

Eras, timelines, this day in history, any year in the Islamic world.
Related

Al-Hadi applies the penalty for wine and corrects others, as Muhammad ibn Ubaydallah tells it

Muhammad ibn Ubaydallah relates that he saw al-Hadi brought a drunken man; two trusted men testified he had drunk wine, he was held until sober and then given eighty lashes with a whip al-Hadi chose himself. He tells too of four men and two women: two were given eighty each for wine and two of al-Hadi's own soldiers were given seventy each, as correction below the penalty, on testimony that they had been talking with the women; the women were examined, one found pregnant being held in a house or guaranteed until delivery, and the other, a free woman, received sixty as correction.