Al-Hadi applies the penalty for wine and corrects others, as Muhammad ibn Ubaydallah tells it

إقامة الهادي حد الخمر وتأديب بعض من وُجد مع نساء، رواية محمد بن عبيد الله

Sa'da

Muhammad ibn Ubaydallah relates that he saw al-Hadi brought a drunken man; two trusted men testified he had drunk wine, he was held until sober and then given eighty lashes with a whip al-Hadi chose himself. He tells too of four men and two women: two were given eighty each for wine and two of al-Hadi's own soldiers were given seventy each, as correction below the penalty, on testimony that they had been talking with the women; the women were examined, one found pregnant being held in a house or guaranteed until delivery, and the other, a free woman, received sixty as correction.

DraftWritten with AI help from the sources it cites, and not yet read by a human editor.

Depth

At a glance

Era
Abbasid Fragmentation
Region
Arabia

In space

Sa'da

Map: Natural Earth, public domain · places and route from the graph

Politics, governance and authority

Overview

Ali ibn Muhammad says: my father Muhammad ibn Ubaydallah told me: I saw Yahya ibn al-Husayn when a man was brought to him and he was told this is a drunkard. 1 The manuscript margin carries the heading "his applying the penalties". 1 The account is Zaydi, in the voice of the imam's followers; the rulings and numbers are Muhammad ibn Ubaydallah's report, and the museum describes what is said without comparison or verdict; the general legal subject has its own records at Wine and Fixed penalties (hudud).

The drunken man

Al-Hadi told two of his trusted men to smell the man's breath, and they testified that he was a wine drinker; he held him until the next day when he had recovered from his drunkenness, then had him stretched between two posts and struck with the whip, eighty strokes. 1 He chose the whip himself, of middle thickness, neither thin nor thick, had its tip beaten with a stone, had the man struck stripped of his clothes, told the flogger to spread his blows over the shoulders and not go past them, and told a man to count for the flogger. 1

Four men and two women

Muhammad ibn Ubaydallah also saw Yahya ibn al-Husayn when four men and two women were brought; some people testified that two of the four were drunk, and when they were examined by smell the odour of wine was found on them, so each was given eighty. 1 Witnesses testified against the other two, who were of his soldiers and companions, that they had found them talking with the two women; he ordered them struck, seventy each, less than the set penalty, as correction. 1

The two women

He sent the two women to women to see whether either was pregnant; one was found with child, and he ordered her kept alone in a house until she delivered, unless two trusted men could be found to stand surety for her until she delivered, which two men then did. 1 The other he ordered to sit in a basket of straw and be struck sixty strokes; she protested that she had not been found in any suspicion, and one of his servants was sent to tell her that if she had been found in anything of the kind, and the deed had been proved by testimony, he would have ordered a pit and stoned her, and then asked whether she was free or a slave; she said free, and was struck sixty as correction. 1 The text gives neither day, year nor place. See Al-Da'am swears to al-Hadi, a governor is sent to his land with Abu Jafar Muhammad ibn Sulayman, Safar 286 AH for other penalties in the book.

Connections

Explore the connections

Occurred at
Sa'da
Had participant
Yahya al-Hadi al-Rassi· Abu Jafar Muhammad ibn Ubaydallah al-Abbasi
Related to
Wine· Fixed penalties (hudud)

People and things also explored

More reports on the wine penalty, from al-Kufi and Ibn Abi Hisham· Ahmad ibn Abbad al-Akili leaves Sa'da, writes to al-Hadi and then fortifies himself there, 286 AH· Al-Hadi's stay at Sa'da and his call to jihad with its six conditions, 284 AH· Al-Hadi leaves his son at Sa'da and goes down to Najran, where Banu al-Harith ask pardon, Jumada II 289 AH· Al-Hadi leaves Sa'da for Khaywan and meets al-Da'am at al-Amshiyya, Muharram 288 AH· Al-Hadi leaves Sa'da for Khiwan, his charge to Muhammad ibn Ubaydallah and the journey without rain, Rajab 286 AH· Al-Hadi's march to Wasaha, his eight-day stay and the appointment of Muhammad ibn Ubaydallah there, Shawwal 284 AH· Al-Hadi's march from Sa'da to Najran on the second of Dhu al-Hijja and his camp at the fortress, 286 AH

Sources

  1. Sirat al-Imam al-Hadi ila al-Haqq Yahya ibn al-Husayn — Ali ibn Muhammad al-Abbasi al-Alawi , p.119
Cite this page

islam.museum contributors. “Al-Hadi applies the penalty for wine and corrects others, as Muhammad ibn Ubaydallah tells it”. islam.museum, https://islam.museum/en/event/al-hadi-applies-the-wine-penalty-at-saada-286/. CC BY-SA 4.0. Last updated 2026-11-14.

Improve this page on GitHub · Report an error · Help complete it · JSON

Wing

Time

Eras, timelines, this day in history, any year in the Islamic world.
Related

More reports on the wine penalty, from al-Kufi and Ibn Abi Hisham

Ali ibn Muhammad relays further reports on the wine penalty from Abu Jafar Muhammad ibn Sulayman al-Kufi, from Muhammad ibn Abi Hisham and from his father: a frail man given three whips bound together, a woman who begged mercy for the sake of Ali ibn Abi Talib and was told the penalty belongs to God, a saying of al-Hadi about taking what is due even from his grandfather al-Qasim ibn Ibrahim, and two men in whose house wine was found, struck sixty each.