The book market or the goods market?

Baghdad in its golden age expands a new quarter on the Tigris bank: a stationers' market selling books and copies and gathering scholars, or a goods market receiving silk and spice caravans to enrich the treasury? The decision: intellectual capital or material capital?

The positions

the stationers' party

the book market makes the scholars who make every market

The evidence

Baghdad was famed for its stationers more than its silk

Sources: place/baghdadbuilding/bayt-al-hikma

the goods party

the caravans feed the city and pay the translators' wages

The evidence

silk and spices entered her roads and she became the world's trade capital

Sources: exhibit/pathway-g11-chw3m-baghdad-and-the-silk-roadsplace/baghdad

You decide

Which market would your land have deserved as the planner? Write your reason.

Saved on this device